Elemental has several obvious glaring problems. For one thing, the attempt to make the elements' differences an overt metaphor for race/culture is shallow and misplaced at best most of the time.
The story's themes and plot itself are about as worn-out and tired as the art of the story itself. Not a single new idea is really explored at this level.
And, at the more surface level, the film's visuals vary greatly in quality: the environments are gorgeous, colorful, and vibrant, while the character designs appear haphazard, thrown together, and honestly kind of ugly.
But where this film shines-and I mean REALLY shines, surprisingly-is in the writing of its characters.
Ember and Wade are instantly distinct, understood, and likeable. They both grow tremendously and at a consistent pace. They are 110% the reason to see this film. I got emotionally wrapped up in their lives and desires in a way that I've only felt in Pixar's best films. This is the sole great achievement of Elemental.
The one other thing I can praise is the sound design and the musical score-both of which are largely powerful and memorable.
Maybe it's that my expectations were on the floor going into this, but I'd be lying if I said I didn't enjoy it. Maybe wait to catch it on streaming, but don't write it off completely.
The story's themes and plot itself are about as worn-out and tired as the art of the story itself. Not a single new idea is really explored at this level.
And, at the more surface level, the film's visuals vary greatly in quality: the environments are gorgeous, colorful, and vibrant, while the character designs appear haphazard, thrown together, and honestly kind of ugly.
But where this film shines-and I mean REALLY shines, surprisingly-is in the writing of its characters.
Ember and Wade are instantly distinct, understood, and likeable. They both grow tremendously and at a consistent pace. They are 110% the reason to see this film. I got emotionally wrapped up in their lives and desires in a way that I've only felt in Pixar's best films. This is the sole great achievement of Elemental.
The one other thing I can praise is the sound design and the musical score-both of which are largely powerful and memorable.
Maybe it's that my expectations were on the floor going into this, but I'd be lying if I said I didn't enjoy it. Maybe wait to catch it on streaming, but don't write it off completely.