South Solitary (2010) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
15 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Quietly enjoyable.
bohemiafilms3 August 2010
If you don't mind watching a film populated with flawed but easy to identify with characters, then I urge you to check out South Solitary. I enjoyed this film very much, particularly the performance of Miranda Otto as Meredith, as it would be very easy to find this character unlikeable if it had not been handled as beautifully and sympathetically as Miranda does. It was also interesting to see the inner workings of an operational light house from that period as I new very little of the life of a light house keeper going into the screening. The sound design is also brilliantly weaved throughout helping to add a lot of emotion within the probably smallish budget. I found South Solitary both wryly funny and human in just the right proportion and for the right audience it will be a pleasant surprise.
31 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A woman in need.
Someguysomwhere8 December 2010
A man and his niece, Meredith, arrive on a remote island where a light house is situated and he is to serve as the new head lighthouse keeper ("head keeper" for short). Already serving on the island are 2 keepers: A man named Harry who has a wife and 3 children; a young girl and 2 boys a few years older. Harry is sociable; a smooth chatterbox with a bit of mischief and slyness in his humor and overall personality. The second keeper is a man named Fleet who is the opposite of Harry. So he's a man of few words who likes to keep to himself. As well, he seems to be wrestling with some painful issue concerning a war he served in; an issue that on occasion causes him to become delusional and behave oddly (problematic when it occurs on his watch).

Newly arrived, Meredith encounters some resentment on the part of Harry's wife, Alma, who feels he was unfairly passed over for the job of head keeper though she assures Meredith that she does not blame her personally. Alma comes across as strong and hard-working; someone who has her hands full all the time (Well why not? She has 3 children and maybe to some extent a fourth in her husband). She is no-nonsense and blunt and one has the impression that she is not a good enemy to make.

Just before encountering Alma, Meredith immediately befriends Nettie, Harry and Alma's little girl, by allowing the child to care for a lamb she brought to the island with her. This makes Alma happy. She is a somewhat enigmatic child; and so one get's the impression that one has to be wary or tactful around her lest one say the wrong thing and she goes scurrying off to plot your untimely end (just kidding). In contrast, we do not get as good a look at her 2 brothers; only enough to determine that they are 2 scamps.

On his part, Meredith's uncle Wadsworth wastes no time laying down the law. Essentially saying to his subordinates, "It will not be business as usually. You are irresponsible slackers (the light in the light house was reported out a few times by passing ships). Your conduct will go on record. Shape up, or ship out." So we learn early in that Uncle Waddy has no sense of humor. All business all the time. Old guy treats Meredith likes she's JUST an employee (she actually is; a secretary of sorts) and not also his niece. Their relationship is formal; more so on his side since Meredith is friendly by nature. She also has a weakness in her character suggested by this friendliness which leads to tragedy.

What to say about Meredith herself?

My impression of her is of a friendly, out-going, out-reaching person. This per se or by itself is not a bad thing. But we come to understand that at the root of this friendliness is "neediness". So she's not only reaching out to you, but "pulling you in" as well to be used as a crutch of some sort; to compensate for something lacking. Perhaps a certain level of self-sufficiency that comes with maturity; the ability to deal with being alone sometimes. Meredith is not a bad person but her neediness is very strong. We see this symbolically in the baby lamb she brought to the island clutched to her bosom. This neediness can lead to thoughtlessness and selfishness wherein assuaging one's own need, or in Meredith's case, her "sense of loneliness", takes priority over all else; her sense of honor and decency; her responsibility to others.

I won't spoil it for you by saying much more. I believe I've given enough hints on how Meredith's flawed character; her neediness (appearing outwardly as excessive friendliness and kindness) get's her into trouble. This movie has a laid back pace. There's no "high drama" until around the middle, or so. And that only translated into raised voices, Meredith crying, and some leaving the island. In a nutshell, no one stabbed or shot anyone, ---or held anyone for ransom (Damn it!). Anyone who likes "relationship drama" will enjoy it much more, I think. Possibly women more than men, though I don't want to stereotype. Love, Boloxxxi.
8 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Australian Film at its Best!
lukejohn-4560120 July 2020
Is this really the best we can do? Actors did a good job with the material they were given. Cinematography was professional. At the end of the day, without a story what's the point.
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A gem of a film
spencer-5213 December 2010
Warning: Spoilers
South Solitary is an Australian story told on a small canvas - a lighthouse off the Victoria coast. The cast of isolated characters makes for often intense, often comic, interactions overlaid by the propriety of 1920s manners. The domineering father and lighthouse keeper played by Barry Otto tries to impose his will on his niece and domestic servant Meredith (Miranda Otto) and on the two assistant keepers. The story revolves around Meredith as her back story is slowly revealed. Her growing friendship with the war damaged assistant keeper, Fleet, consumes the second half of the film but there is no Hollywood ending here. There is superb acting even among the children. The Ottos are two of Australia's finest actors but don't get the recognition overseas they deserve because they do not seek "stardom". Miranda did, however, play in the Lord of the Rings. The music is a character in the story on its own setting the mood without overwhelming.We were playing the CD long before we saw the movie.
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This movie is stunningly beautiful- an underrated masterpiece
Humphreywashere18 March 2017
Thank you Shirley Barrett for writing and directing this movie because you have created a masterpiece. I begin to live in 1928 when I watch this movie. I feel I can step into the screen, help Meredith unpack her belongings and set-up my room in that lovely old house, put the kettle on, and walk outside in that bitterly cold air. I wear the scratchy woollen coat that Meredith wears, the hand knitted woollen vest, the skirt, and loose thick stockings bunching up at the ankles. I look at Mr Fleet (the exceptional Marton Csokas) and am drawn to his shy wounded persona, his awkwardness, and his pain. This movie is astonishing because It draws me into the time of these characters (like no other movie can). I have watched this movie about 8 times and I never tire of it. It was in this movie that I first saw Csokas. I couldn't believe how surpub his performance was. I asked, who is this incredible actor? I have since watched him in many movies and his capacity to express vastly different personalities in every role is just stunning. What an observer of human behaviour and non-verbal communicator! The isolation, the cold, the children, the lonely residents, and those who choose to be alone - the depiction is so real and so true, you feel like you are intruding in conversations. The pace is right, and the music so suited to the telling of the story, and so sublime, that I bought the soundtrack too. I wrote this review because there are so many award winning movies that are appalling, ('la la land' comes to mind), yet masterpieces like this one are overlooked. If you enjoy a love story with warm, gentle characters who are very real (imperfect), if you enjoy the thought of isolation and staring at the wind-swept seascape like in a Bronte novel, and if you like to gently explore the personality of someone you find increasingly fascinating - this movie is truly for you.
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Beautifully filmed, nicely acted, but rather dull
gregking411 July 2010
Warning: Spoilers
The new Australian romantic drama South Solitary is beautifully filmed, nicely acted, but is ultimately a rather dull and vaguely unsatisfying experience. This is the first film from director Shirley Barrett in over a decade. Barrett's debut film Love Serenade was a vaguely disappointing story of love, loneliness and desperation set in rural Victoria, and established her reputation. There are a few thematic similarities with her third film, South Solitary, which is a claustrophobic tale of love, loneliness and desperation set in on a remote windswept island off the coast of Australia in 1927. Wadsworth (Barry Otto) is a veteran of the lighthouse service who has been sent to the remote South Solitary lighthouse to bring the staff into order after several complaints have been lodged by passing ships. He is accompanied by his niece Meredith (Miranda Otto), an unmarried 35-year-old woman, who has never found a man in her life since her fiancé perished in WWI. The family living on the island are initially resentful of their presence because they assumed that Harry (Rohan Nichol) would be automatically promoted. However, the isolation soon begins to take its toll on the desperate, love-lorn Meredith and her demanding uncle. Psychologically damaged World War One veteran Fleet (Marton Csokas) is another regular worker at the lighthouse, and he does not quickly warm to the pair either. And Meredith's affair with the womanizing Harry further complicates the dynamics of the small group. The performances of the key cast are very good. This is the first time that Barry Otto and his Miranda Otto have appeared together on film since Dead Letter Office in 1998, and their dynamic adds to their relationship. Miranda is strong as the psychologically scarred and love-lorn Meredith. Csokas is good as the withdrawn Fleet who has his own emotional baggage to deal with. Barrett's low-key direction keeps everything understated here. South Solitary is deliberately paced, and not a lot happens in the first hour and the running time could have been trimmed by at least 20 minutes. There are few dramatic moments to hook the audience in. Nor does the film really tap into the psychological implications of the isolated setting for the characters. The film has been stunningly shot on location at lighthouses near Point Nelson and Cape Otway, by cinematographer Anna Howard. These isolated locations certainly help underscore some of the film's main themes. But the film is ultimately something of a disappointment. While not quite another typically down beat and grim local drama, South Solitary is nonetheless a moody and largely low key drama that will struggle to find an audience.
11 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
South Solitary - A Film For Those Who Refuse To Give Up On HOPE
raiderhayseed7 August 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Take nine rather unpleasant people who treat each other badly, put them on a small, desolate, windswept island and you should have the makings of a film that even Ingmar Burgman would find tedious Shirley Barrett, who seems to have a predilection for making films about unattractive people, manages to turn these ingredients into an elegy to "hope". Hope, you may be aware, is a member of the trilogy of eternal virtues that can redeem the lives of people who refuse to succumb to feelings of self-loathing and despair.

The other two eternal virtues are faith and love, and if I have a criticism of this film, it is that Barrett does not allow the last two humans standing on the island to consummate their growing mutual attraction, at least within the confines of the film The prop she uses to make this believable is the lighthouse they manage to keep illuminated, shining in the darkness of the surrounding stormy sea

Miranda Otto gives us a grown-up reprise of the character she created in Barrett's first film, "Love Serenade"

Marton Csokas crafts his performance as a World War I shell-shock, neurotic so organically that we can believe his stilted overtures to greater intimacy at the end of the film

Barry Otto's light house keeper has taken a different route to dealing with the moral void uncovered by the evil and stupidity of World War I. He too has been damaged by the experience, but instead of succumbing to the numbing silence of Csokas, he has embraced a near military conformity to the idea of the benign authority of human institutions, all appearances to the contrary. It is a mark of Barrett's skill as a writer-director, that she allows his niece to acknowledge his care for her when she had attracted the disapproval of polite society.

Barett has crafted a small, quietly spoken, life affirming film that draws the viewer into the lives of its protagonists and leaves them feeling richer for the experience.
13 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
What's the point?
injury-6544729 July 2020
The main character is a completely obnoxious and unlikeable whiner. The romance is rushed and undeveloped and pointless.
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Good local content - enjoyable watch
mkorvin5 November 2019
Watched this last night (better late than never) with no expectations and was somewhat enamored by what unfolded. Has an authentic Aussie story feel in a number of dimensions. Delivered without excesses.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Wonderful.
bamco-5015818 July 2020
Competently put together film. Beautifully cast. Held our interest until the very end. Great Australian film making.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A heartfelt film with comedy
Blaich15 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
David Stratton reviewed this film 4/5, but I noticed that other worthy reviewers either gave a high or low score, nothing much in between.

This movie touched on my heart strings, and required genuine empathy to understand the characters. Set in in the early 1900's the setting was isolated and the wheather conditions were unpredictable and sometimes extreme effecting the work on the light house and the life styles. The characters, each had their own story which unravelled details for the viewers to pick up on nuances and interpret.

I enjoyed this film for its superb location, film making, acting and history of the lighthouse. The complex issues that arose between the characters were genuine and in keeping of the era and could be confronting. How the characters interacted and worked through the issues were both sad, moving and humourous in a very Australian kind of way (which could be perceived as black humour). This movie gives credit to Australian film making depicting that tender relationships can develop from the most difficult situations.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Australian film at its best!
diane-3414 August 2010
D and I watched this terrific film yesterday afternoon and we both shared similar thoughts about its quality. This film, about a young woman sent with her administrative uncle to "clean up" the operation of a very remote lighthouse is truly an iconic Australian film. I am reasonably familiar with the world's cinema and can therefore (modestly) make judgments about the types of film produced by various countries and South Solitary is a movie that is Australian through and through. Our movies are gutsy, perhaps rough, slice-of-life movies. The big budget Hollywood types (like Australia) are exceptions to this rule and do not easily sit well with the norm or at least the norm as I see it. Films like Japanese Story, Jindabyne, Oyster Farmer, Beautiful Kate and Last Ride are just a few of the many introspective movies that our film industry produces and that Diane and I anticipate eagerly and now we can add South Solitary to this list of, dare I say, brilliant movies. I know of no other country that produces films of this nature; films that are strangely uplifting in their context. The film's ending, with no Hollywood tears, is perfect. See this film and do not judge it by the standards for which we have been smothered by a foreign culture. South Solitary is rich with feelings that all of us can recognize and I would unconditionally recommend it.
23 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Relationship Drama with Authenticity
jamesmoule8 July 2020
This movie seemed to slip under the radar in Australia when it was released, though it is a very fine production. The cast, headed by Miranda and Barry Otto, give good impressions of their characters, though Barry Otto might be accused of over-doing the grumpiness. That type of officious, hyper-critical person was common in the 1930s (and later). The title suggests that the lighthouse is situated on South Solitary Island which lies off the northern NSW coast near Coffs Harbour, an idyllic spot. The setting of the movie is anything but idyllic, the locations being the windswept capes of Victoria, subject to the fierce Roaring Forties. There is no obvious plot; nearly two hours is spent examining the relationships between Meredith and the other members of the lighthouse crew. The long shadow of World War 1 hangs over the characters, all of whom have major personality problems and psychological defects. There is a hiatus between two major incidents which confused me for a time. Perhaps there is a pile of film on the cutting room floor that would have covered the time between Meredith being sprung by Netty and the scene with the launch heading out to sea. We are left to fill in a lot of gaps here and we can only guess at the turmoil that occurred. Viewers will find it difficult to identify with any of the characters. There is no hero though we might have some sympathy for the hardship endured by all people who used to work in such isolated places.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very enjoyable
annaparry-922773 January 2021
Dramatic landscape . Good storyline. Great acting especially Miranda and Martin- I found it very enjoyable.. felt compelled To rewatch it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Starts out promising... entices and delivers a little
timbartley-1294216 February 2021
A strong start that sets up interesting characters but perhaps some rigour and depth was lost in the editing. It's overall quite pleasant with a non-Hollywood ending that was somewhat satisfying.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed