"Murdoch Mysteries" The Murdoch Identity (TV Episode 2010) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Murdoch comes to England
miles-331089 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Murdoch is in Bristol, without any idea of who he is. Two armed men chase him through the back alleys, and shoot him in the arm. He ducks into a pub, where Anna Fulford, the landlady, hides him from the chasers. He then explains that the first thing he remembers is waking up on a coal train in Montreal with a steamer ticket to England, which he used. The ticket was in the name of John Dawson, but the Detective doesn't believe that is his name.

In Toronto, there is great concern for Murdoch, and Detective Hamish Slorach from Police Station 5 has been seconded to Police Station 4 in order to lead the investigation. Slorach's approach and methods differ greatly from Murdoch. A body is found, with a hole straight through the head. It takes some effort to find the bullet, which has been fired from a very powerful gun. A man is arrested in possession of plans for the gun, and the Police learn that there was a team of three, of whom he was one, the dead man, Dawson, was the second, and a third man, Keating, has gone to England with the gun. Crabtree suggests that perhaps Murdoch has followed Keating, so the Toronto Constabulary alert the Bristol Constabulary that a man with a powerful gun is en route to England, and to ask if they have heard from Detective Murdoch.

In Bristol, Anna Fulford finds safe lodgings for Murdoch, thanks to her priest. Murdoch and the people pursuing him have several encounters, as a result of which he learns that there is to be an assassination at the Clifton suspension bridge. Murdoch escapes from the assassins, and takes his story to the Bristol Police, arriving at the station at the same time as the telegram from Toronto. When the telegram is read out, Murdoch realises he is the Toronto Detective named in it. The Chief Inspector at the station informs Murdoch that Queen Victoria and Lord Treadwell, her Secretary of State for War, are due to pass over the bridge very soon, and orders all his men to the bridge to prevent the attack. Murdoch, having seen the gun when he was talking to Keating, is convinced that the gunman won't be anywhere near the bridge.

So, will Murdoch or the Bristol Police find Keating and the gun in time to avert disaster? Will Murdoch regain his memory? Will he return to Toronto, or will Detective Slorach keep his office?

This is a refreshingly different style of episode, and it is so absorbing that the time just flies by. It's a clever plot device to have Murdoch lose his memory in the first episode of a new series, because the glimpses of Murdoch's life in Toronto not only move this story along, but would also provide a helpful way in to the series for any new viewers.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Anna is no slouch!
macktoid26 January 2022
I think William should trade Julia for Anna, even up!!

Both are sweet, but Anna seems a little more grounded, and not quite as flighty.

I hope she's going to appear in more episodes..I'm a newbie to the show.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
ctyankee1 error?
amesk15 September 2020
"This episode starts off with Murdoch being chased by 2 men with guns in Montreal." Except he was in Bristol, not Montreal.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Murdoch loses his memory
ctyankee121 March 2015
This episode starts off with Murdoch being chased by 2 men with guns in Montreal. He gets wounded in the arm and hides in a pub.

The female owner of the pub hides him when the men come in to look for him and he stays hidden. They tell her he is a killer. He talks to her later and does not know why the men are chasing him it has something to do with a murdered man. He has amnesia. He does not know who he is, where he is or much else accept that he was taken off the train.

He tells the pub owner Anna what he remembers and how he has to go to the apartment of the man that he was accused of killing so he can figure out what happened to him. She is very helpful and trust him. She calls him "Harry". She starts to care very much for him.

Murdoch series introduces a lot of new scientific products in the making and used to help solve crimes or commit them. This is one of them. It is a long telescope attached to a special rifle that shoots long range.

This is the first episode I ever saw where Murdoch uses a hand gun and shoots at someone. It has a good ending, very moving but also sad.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Period error with modern bicycle
aetsmith2 April 2024
Murdoch 'borrows' a bicycle with modern cable brake handles, disc brake in front and back and straight handle bars and modern slick tyre and steel pedals.

For example, disc brakes were only used on bicycles from 1993.

Straight handle bars only came in to use in the 1960s.

Bit disappointing. Surely it would not have been that difficult to obtain an old bicycle for use in the shooting of the episode.

It would also not have been too difficult to get an engineering firm to modify a mountain bike to look like an old bike so that they could ride down the stairs without damage - which why, I suspect, they used a modern mountain bike.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed