Opponent (2023) Poster

(2023)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
A story told in hints
ListenToChris30 January 2024
The acting is good, there's no doubt about that, and the whole film has atmosphere and mood throughout, enough to keep us watching for the whole two hours.

The frustating thing is that the story isn't really told, it's only hinted at in vague terms, so it felt like and opportunity missed.

There are a few reviews here giving it top marks and calling it landmark cinema, but often film makers fall for the temptation of coming here to try and pump up theor movie with top notch reviews. In this case, they've also come back to upvote all their reviews and downvote the real ones, and I expect this review to get the same treatment. It's a shame, it would be so much better to let it find its own audience.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Average
ehsan-aliverdi5 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
The beginning of the movie was great, but everything that followed was nonsensical. The actors, including the children, were amazing, and the story was surprisingly good. I highly recommend this movie because it offers a unique perspective. However, there are many aspects of the movie that I do not comprehend. For instance, the director gave enough hints to explain why Iman and his family fled Iran, but then summarized the whole movie with one dialogue in which Iman reveals he is gay to the case officer. This seemed unnecessary since the movie had already portrayed this aspect.

Additionally, everything after the performance night seemed unnecessary and could have been omitted from the movie. The movie should have concluded with the wife playing piano, the children cheering, and Iman's expression. I am still unsure about what the movie was trying to convey. Was it about Iman, the challenges faced by the gay community in Iran, the difficulty of decision-making, or asylum seekers? Although the movie touched on many topics, as a whole, it did not make much sense.
5 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Exploring the Depths of Dilemma: A Review of Opponent
hosseinab-7673415 April 2024
Iman, portrayed by Payman Maadi, adeptly portrays hesitations and second thoughts through his expressions. This movie truly highlights Payman Maadi's acting prowess. Conversely, his wife fails to effectively convey these emotions. Despite the story revolving around Iman and being presented from his perspective, his wife's inability to respond to him hampers their ability to convey the intended message to the audience.

Another compelling aspect of the movie is Iman's dilemma. He must decide between prioritizing himself or his family. Strikingly, neither choice brings him complete satisfaction; opting for his family leaves him feeling unfulfilled, while choosing himself induces guilt.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A portrait of the uncertainty of asylum claimants.
chong_an1 June 2023
Iman is a wrestler who was once on the Iranian national team. When the police start looking for him, he flees with his family - wife Maryam and their two daughters. They end up living in one room in a run-down refugee shelter in Sweden, "near the Finland border", sometimes delivering pizzas on snowmobile for money. The process drags on with statements and appeals, while the daughters miss their friends and Maryam misses being a pianist and piano teacher.

His initial story was that a jealous teammate falsely accused him of being an anti-regime protestor. Then he tries to leverage the fact that his wife is pregnant. Hearing that elite athletes may get special dispensation, he joins a wrestling club, against his wife's wishes There he meets Swedish wrestler Thomas, who befriends him, and tries to get him to socialize with the team. Qualifying for international training camps, he meets his Iranian club, and gets into a fight with one of them.

Eventually, he confesses to the asylum officers that he is gay, has had an affair with a fellow wrestler, and that was what got him into trouble. This is the 1st he has acknowledged this to his wife. But his family just wants to "go home", regardless of the dangers that may befall them - including being pressured to get him to return.

There is a sub-plot about Abbas, a fellow asylum claimant who is repeatedly drafted to act as translator.

I like the depiction of the dilemmas posed to both sides of the asylum claimants - they may be genuinely in danger, but may not be able to prove it. There is a certain amount of chemistry between Thomas and Iman, though that does not help his cause.

While the story happens over several months, the landscape seems to be permanent winter. To alleviate the blandness, there are some scenes that are fantasy or memories. The most obvious fantasy is them living in a good house and getting their acceptance letter, which backtracks tofantasies of their actually getting their own apartment, and a scene of Maryam playing the piano at a community gathering as a memory.

The languages are Swedish and Persian, with a few English words thrown in. As in these subtitled films, I would have liked to know what language was being spoken, following the developing linguistic skills of the refugees.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A Thriller's Missed Mark
keyframedreamer9 March 2024
"Opponent" struggles with emotional depth, uneven pacing, superficial exploration of queerness, underdeveloped supporting characters, and underutilization of its eerie setting despite promising ingredients.

The film's twists are telegraphed early on, robbing them of impact. Viewers familiar with the genre will see them coming, and the lack of surprise undermines the tension.

Despite Payman Maadi's strong performance, the film fails to deliver impactful storytelling, leaving viewers disappointed and yearning for more depth and nuance.

On a positive note, the snowbound landscapes of northern Sweden create an eerie backdrop. However, the film doesn't fully capitalize on this setting. The cinematography hints at something more profound, but it never fully materializes.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Powerful, ambiguous and fascinating
Fouad Realbox30 November 2023
This film is a real surprise. It explores the world of emigrants who have a secret that drove them away from home but who end up falling in the same pattern of behavior. Nobody can escape from who he is.

The actors are amazing and the atmosphere of snow and alienation in Sweden is very well rendered.

The wrestling scenes are powerful as they carry both homoeroticism and the repressed violence of the hero.

The secondary characters are well defined and reveal the contrast between the emotional of the eastern emigrants and the reserve of the western.

Superbly acted, masterful direction, excellent music. Yet the end is rushed and a bit disappointing compared to the rest of the film

Otherwise an excellent film for adults.
12 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Incredible and authentic
martinpersson972 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This is a very important and well put together film that should definitely be watched both as s great piece of art, and an important eye-opener.

Showcasing the hardship for refugees, both in terms of their every day lives and the opposition from the state they often face, it is beautifully conveyed by this acclaimed director and the actors all do an incredible job.

It is an overall incredible film that conveys its message beautifully and doesn't dwell too much in the melancholy, but rather tries to stay real to the complexities and realities of the situation.

Overall, a very fine masterpiece with lots of twists and turns, beautiful acting and cinematography. Definitely recommended for any lover of film!
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A fantastic moving movie
kentrahmn14 September 2023
This movie have many layers. The move is an intense psychological drama that deals with masculinity, intimacy and violence, themes that have completely different meanings in a country like Iran than they do in a country like Sweden. After a devastating rumor spreads about him in Iran, Imam is forced to leave everything behind and start over in Sweden, together with his family. But his past refuses to let him go. This is a movie from the very talented director Milad Alami. He tells the story very beautifully and the cast is very good. Talented actors, especially Peyman Moaadi. I can really really this movie and I hope it gets the recognition the film so well deserves.
9 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed