This house is undertaking some ambitious work for which it deserves commendation. In this film an attempt has been made to illustrate some of the phases of a pirate's life, and with success. The film seems more like a series of views depicting disconnected incidents in such a life, rather than any continuous story. The action seems natural, though the movements of the figures are very quick, perhaps the fault of the operator, and the photography is clear, with correct tonal qualities. One of the sea views will rank with the best of that class of work and the rock scenery conveys an adequate impression of mass and solidity. The setting, which is all outdoors, is picturesque and admirably chosen. The picture pleases, even though it tells no well connected story. - The Moving Picture World, November 27, 1909