Playback (1962) Poster

(1962)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
More Georges Simenon than Edgar Wallace
enochsneed29 October 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Most of the Merton Park-Edgar Wallace adaptations from the early 1960's are police procedurals, whodunit and how (the 'locked room' plot turns up a number of times). This entry is more character-driven, and given an intriguing twist by being told in flashback as a man waits to hear the jury's verdict at his trial.

(Spoilers) Dave Hollis is a friendly young copper who has hopes of becoming a detective. Unfortunately he has character flaws, being too willing to be distracted from duty by a pretty face (and, let's be honest, Margit Saad is quite distracting) and a weakness for roulette. These combine to get him in a situation where he has to take the most desperate measures and doesn't see he's being used until it is far too late. The climax of the film gives a grim reminder of the punishment for murder in the UK half a century ago. (End spoilers)

As I said, the film is character-driven, low on action but high in human interest and suspense. I was reminded of Georges Simenon's novels where the mind of a man in relation to his world and the factors that shaped him are slowly revealed. These cheap second-features from Merton Park are not 'great' or 'classic' films but occasionally they come up with something really different that still has considerable dramatic impact, and this is one very good example.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Playback
Prismark104 August 2021
This owes more to film noir as the story is told in flashback from the docks of the criminal court.

Barry Foster is young PC Hollis. He owes money to a small casino and he falls for a married woman Lisa Shillack (Margit Saad.)

Lisa is unhappily married to her wealthy businessman husband. Of course divorce is out of the question she is used to a life of wealth and privilege.

Hollis is the sap who is infatuated by Lisa and commits murder for her.

It's not long that he is left carrying the can for murder on his own. Even his alibi quickly falls apart. Lisa just knew what numbers to press.

It is good to see Barry Foster in an early role, especially when it dawns on him that he has thrown his career away for a woman who used him. Margit Saad is fantastic.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Guilty of being a sap.
mark.waltz13 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
No police officer should ever fall for the trap that Barry Foster does in this very good Edgar Wallace adaptation made as part of a string of adaptions that were B- at best, going Straight to TV as part of a series. Foster aides the obviously opportunistic Margit Saad, a German immigrant married to a wealthy Englishman she does not love but won't leave. So she lures Foster into the web of her clutches and arranges for the husband to be murdered, framing Foster for the crime.

This plot has been done many times before, and when it's done, right, it's an excellent thriller. Saad, like Barbara Stanwyck in "Double Indemnity", uses sex to get what she wants, but Foster is more of an innocent party than Fred MacMurray was. At just an hour, this is lots of fun with a delicious conclusion, although this time, the audience is certain to feel bad for Foster and applaud at what happens to the heartless vixen.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Playback
coltras3513 March 2023
While on the beat one evening PC Dave Hollis (Barry Foster) came across beautiful German girl Lisa Shillack (Margit Saad) locked out of her flat. He helps her and before long the pair have fallen into an affair. Dave learns that Lisa's husband Simon Shillack (George Pravda) is a rich businessman that she has little love for and that she wants rid of. Before long Lisa is scheming to have him murdered and begins to slowly charm and coerce Dave into undertaking the murder.

Margit Saad is a femme fatale in the classic mode, easily seducing the naive young PC Hollis, while the stylish black and white camerawork enhances the classic noir feel of the piece. Barry Foster is excellent as the naive Bobby ( policeman on the beat) who gets suckered into murdering Saad's husband for insurance - definitely a far cry from Van Der Valk. It's a taut, fast-paced thriller that just sucks you into its tale.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Fantastic little thriller
milliefan19 October 2012
Playback is the very best of the Edgar Wallace crime films shot at Merton in the early 60s. The taut script is beautifully acted by Barry Foster as a young policeman who becomes involved with a glamorous German woman in London - a standout performance by the fabulous Margit Saad. It's surprising Saad did not have a major career in British films ... she is sensational in this 60 minute low budget thriller, so imagine how great she would have been in a major movie! Also in support are Nigel Green (the Prince Charles lookalike) as a dangerous casino owner, and a very young Dinsdale Landen as foster's fellow copper. If you only see one of the many Edgar Wallace series, make it this one.
17 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed