Darwin (2011) Poster

(2011)

User Reviews

Review this title
15 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A profile of an end-of-the-road California town.
hank-10618 October 2010
The subtitle refers to a sign on the outskirts of this remote wreck of a California town (Pop.35), a sign erected to dissuade uninvited visitors from proceeding any further down a weathered road. A windswept Death Valley location, Darwin seems the end of the road for dilapidated, ramshackle houses, corroding vehicles, mining detritus--and eccentric folk, only one of who, the postmistress, has a job. Government and commerce are non-existent, and a fragile water system as well as the town's close proximity to a naval bombing range lend a dystopian air to the place. Yet the people are resilient, even defiant of their surroundings. Once a mining town of 3500 (cue the archival photographs), it's now home to, variously, a sculptor, a writer, an anarchist, a pagan couple, a car restorer, a trans-gendered female, several retirees, a self- described "bon vivant," and Dell Heter, the "Boogie Woogie Man"; almost all depend on federal checks for their incomes. There are no children. Lots of interviews with these folk, interspersed with lingering shots of what some would label a wasteland that surrounds them. One claims that Darwin is "a magnet for people who've had problems," most of which involve drugs, alcohol, and prison time. One could easily be repelled by this crowd, but their resiliency, pride, and commitment to their place is somehow redemptive. Fine cinematography.
14 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Feels Like Home
shughm20 July 2021
This was an excellent documentary about a beautiful little town. Darwin is a town of less than forty people; who, for various reasons, find themselves living in Death Valley.

Much like the circumstances that led them to their home, the people are incredibly fascinating. Everything municipal becomes a matter of interest: water rights, mail, imminent domain, and burials take a completely new angle when viewed from the eyes of a citizen of Darwin.

I hope this place is still around. Towns like Darwin are one of the last true expressions of Americanism left.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Everybody Has A Place
deager6 April 2020
There is a place for everyone and everyone has a place. This desolate Death Valley community is full of live and let live individuals who have found a home in a desert that has a beauty that must be looked at quietly without your preconceived notion of the place or the people. A wonderful look at a people who just want to be happy in their lost little community at the end of the road offering no services.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Hoped for more
manch4414 December 2013
I'd been watching for this documentary to be available for quite some time and finally found it on i-Tunes. If you like the Mojave desert, the cinematography will definitely appeal to you. Memories of family trips to the Mojave and Death Valley came back to me in a big way while watching this. Now why I docked 3 stars off the review: I tend to agree with xscabboyx's assessment. It took me about 30 minutes to tire of the townsfolk's interviews. The inhabitants were all interesting and seemed like decent people but the monologue style of the conversations kind of bogged down the movie. Perhaps narration would have helped. Having said that, the photography and musical score are excellent; I'd recommend watching Darwin for that alone.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A hidden place, still alive somewhere in the Death Valley.
we-881-64077626 October 2010
Darwin, a place to survive, for those who have not found a proper place in the so called civilized world. The Movie captures this remoteness in a unique way, without trying to be moral about the somewhat dubious existences of the very few souls stranded in Death Valley. Once a prosperous town with nearly 3'500 inhabitants, Darwin cut down, only within 50 years, its population to a slim 35. A quite stunning ratio which usually only happens after a big disaster. Here, the American landscape seems to have eaten up its former inhabitants and in reverse, offers for those who can't find a home the last reason to be. Like the writings of F. Scott Fitzgerald, the movie slowly reveals a drama, which on first sight is not really visible.The uniqueness of this place is reflected in the making of the film. Darwin turns out to be very special, as a place and as a movie. Great imagery, great plot, fantastic sound.......
11 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Fantastic view of Americana in the desert of California
shane118118 December 2019
This is a comprehensive and intimate view of small town America. It is both sad and uplifting at the same time. Tales of family trauma, murder, Manson, a dwindling economy, and more. The cinematography is beautiful. The portraits of the residents are fulfilling and honest. One reviewer commented it was boring and thought it could be improved with narration, however I disagree. The on-screen blurbs provided more than enough context and contributed to the overall somber tone in a respectful way. I think a narrator would have felt condescending or judgmental ... this film does a great job skirting that potential issue.

Another reviewer commented that all the residents are depressing, filthy and living on welfare. They are just wrong. There is one job in town and the postmaster is grateful to have it. Many to most are senior citizens of retirement age so what would you expect them to live on but their well-earned social security? One woman created a library for the town and another an outdoor art museum. There is a small artist community with "summer music camp for adults," and so much more. The residents mostly seem very different from one another yet they are respectful of those differences and even get together for American ways of life such as the Fourth of July. A younger couple moved from Sacramento recover from trauma and by the end have rebuilt themselves enough to move out of town to "get off disability." The reviewer must not have an empathetic bone in their body and been fortunate enough to never experience illness themselves because being clean does have a cost (physical work is not possible for all even those who appear well; invisible illness is real) and where they live in the unforgiving desert where the closest services are 40 miles away, it is not easy to maintain a perfect home. In addition many of the homes looked no different than my friends and colleagues, or much better. Just because someone lives differently from you doesn't make it bad. The man who has no running water by choice says he feels like he is racking bad karma for every gallon of gas he burns so he's made a conscious effort to consume less. I see that as admirable and if the rest of us made a 1/10th the effort, the world would be a better place.

Having lived and worked within the same general region at one point in my life, along with my husband who worked just over the hill from this community in the similarly dilapidated and dwindling town of Keeler (pop 50, or less), I can say that this is an accurate and thoughtful portrayal of life in many of the small towns of the Mojave Desert in Inyo and Kern Counties. I loved this film, which I happened to stumble upon by accident on Amazon Prime. ten stars.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Artistically shot look at a small town of... characters...
londondeville10 January 2017
A great look at a few of the 35 people who live in Darwin, California, a former mining town. Those who decided to stay behind when the silver mine closed down (and even stranger - those that decided to move there afterwards) are profiled in a way that is empathetic to them and their situation but at the same time allows for humorous circumstances. The barren landscape is used in many scenes to contrast the dilapidated town to great artistic effect and is a constant reminder to how remote and removed these people are from the rest of the world. The story of Darwin itself, along with the lives of the people living there currently are woven together in a way that presents the documentary as a drama filled soap opera. The best part of it all though is that it is real.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A glimpse at a disgusting and depressing way of life
The_Boxing_Cat9 December 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I found two people in this film that seemed halfway decent: Hank and Monty. The rest seemed very shallow and narrow minded, crazy even.

One idiot woman who slaps her dog, thinks that robo calls are actual people who don't want to talk to her, I can forgive her stupidity, but not animal cruelty.

Hank's wife is another nut job who has "mixed feelings" about Charles Manson (i.e., he's a good guy) even though her husband (who has met him) told her that "Charlie is a piece of sh!t" and there's nothing good about him.

Then there's the felon who has guns buried all over his place and stupid enough to say so on camera- hopefully he will get arrested! He rails against the government, yet happy to collect welfare like the rest of the white trash.

Several seem to have the belief that the world will end in 2012...oops sorry but it's 2019 and Darwin is still there, unfortunately.

They feel the need to prevent outsiders from coming to Darwin...I can't imagine any place more depressing.

No one there has a job and ALL collect government benefits and then have the audacity to complain that they don't get enough and hope for war to improve the economy. Gee, did you ever think about getting a job? I'm sure no one there would consider joining up, but all too happy for others to risk their lives so the residents of Darwin can continue to be on the dole.

Most, if not all, choose to live in filth. In a million years I will never understand that mindset! It doesn't cost a penny to clean up, to have a little decency and self respect. After watching this film I feel the need to scrub everything down- fearing their mentality may creep in...
7 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A captivating look into a soon to be ghost town
rm19840128 December 2011
I have been hearing about this film for a long time and saw that it was shown at quite a few film festivals around the world. I finally got a chance to see it, and it beat all my expectations. The viewer gets immersed in the lives of people who have withdrawn to the edge of society. Every town resident featured in this documentary has a compelling life story to tell and recounts it in an utterly open way. The mood shifts back and forth between light hearted and melancholic. This made it truly remarkable since I found myself laughing one minute to being sad the next. The beautiful landscape and setting only add to its impact. The film definitely deserves the "buzz" it gets and I would highly recommend it.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Very Intriguing
coleyemde5 January 2020
This is a very interesting and even paced documentary. The residents may not be unique to any neighbor any of us may have but it is the combination of that and environmental factors that make it an interesting community. Worth watching.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Wow
gacks_200011 June 2021
I kind of feel sorry for the majority of the people in this documentary. If you want to be reminded how dysfunctional and mentally unstable some humans are. Watch this! A perplexing film about a bunch lost souls.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Well....
mycareergrh31 December 2019
I LOVE docs and was enjoying this; until while watching, I googled "Darwin" to see a map of exact location....and there was a result for registered offender" in Darwin. Turns out, it was one of the main guys of focus in film So, needless to say....I stopped watching because; well just a BIG fact NO for me. *Wondering why filmmaker didn't do a little more research on this.
5 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Visit this place, don't watch this...
ciscobudge12 November 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I visited Darwin and I will tell you that the town is an amazing place with some great people. Just driving down the long Darwin Road, past the old mining town, past "Project Darwin," past the "Population 50 sign, " through the town and out the back roads will be an experience in itself. That's if you don't even talk to anyone.

I made the mistake of taking photographs of peoples PRIVATE homes, which I did not ask permission to do. Being stupid, I didn't realize that people would frown upon this.

So, I was tailed by a black sedan through the town and down the backroads. We noticed the car and turned around. We headed for Darwin Road and saw the car again. We stopped on the side of the road and let it pass... it passed and stopped, turned around, and came back. We hauled ass and the car turned around again.

I digress.

This documentary captures NONE of that. What it captures are people who are entertaining and interesting for about 10 minutes. The documentary focuses on this group of 6 or 8 people (four of them are from the same household) and even though they seemed like people I'd love to meet, I lost interest in them quick.

The documentary had no direction, no narrative, no real story. Basically the documentary was point and shoot and use what we get kind of thing.

I was really bummed. I was looking forward to this and WANTED to love it so much.
4 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
A Place to Visit But Not to Live
malafleur114 November 2019
This town is not in Death Valley as the write up implies. Death Valley is actually a better place to visit.

The movie does show that the Housing is substandard. What the movie doesn't share: NO broadband internet service, ONLY 28.8k modem connection. NO broadcast TV; NO AM/FM radio. NO cell signal; NO stores, restaurants. 40 miles to groceries and gas. ALL phone calls are long distance.

I did like the old retired miner and his wife, but majority of residents interviewed were not that interesting.
3 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Interesting, but sad
tony-9716228 March 2020
35 elderly souls living in a desolate wasteland of Death Valley, California. Pagans, those who practice witchcraft, a pair of homosexuals and a scratch of parched dry earth that marks out a small cemetery, with most just waiting around to become a part of it. A depressing look at a hopelessly lost community who will die in their sins without Jesus.
2 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed