All or Nothing: The German National Team in Qatar (TV Series 2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Shocking Insights
smwspam22 September 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I did not have high expectations when I stated watching the show, but I must admit that the filming, cutting and pacing was very good. These four episodes went by rather quickly, I was not bored for a minute.

I will not discuss the politics regarding the World Cup in Qatar, I believe society has done so and came to a common understanding. Instead, I want to highlight those aspects that fascinated me from a sports perspective.

What stood out the most was the depressed atmosphere within the German team, which this show managed to capture quite intensely. A team fully of highly talented players, that, as much as it hurts to say, seem to lack drive and, most importantly, personality.

Most of these players have played together for years, a majority of them even at the club level at Bayern Munich. Ironically not too long before the World Cup, some of them had won everything possible in just one season under Hansi Flick. Naturally, expectations were high. That makes it all the more shocking to see their low levels of energy, those blank stares at team meetings and the defeaning silence on and off the pitch.

The only exception, in my opinion, was Niclas Füllkrug. Recruited from Werder Bremen, then playing in the second German division, he radiates confidence, positivity and shows he is a true teamplayer. His speech ahead of the game against Spain was heartfelt and tradgically remained the only one that reached the team throughout the whole tournament.

All or Nothing is also a story about fall from grace of Hansi Flick. Having won everything possible within in just one year at Bayern Munich, he failed dramatically to inspire confidence in what seemed to be a broken team. Incapable of leaving aside professionalism, he seemed to intimidate his players even more rather than trying to connect with them emotionally.

All or Nothing was a great show for any fan interested in learning more about the inner workings of the German national team in Qatar, and ultimately about the reasons, why they came short again.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Nobody asked for it. So here it is!
kellermannfranz12 September 2023
The first time I heard about this documentary I was like: "Are they serious?!" Nobody wanted to see a show about a failing team in a tournament nobody wanted in the first. I don't wanna focus to much on the WC in Quatar. The questionable draw by the FIFA, the shocking reports about the construction of the exploited immigrant workers and the overall situation in the caliphate.

I'm here to tell about this show. So how it is? Depends how you view it. I think it displays the overall condition of the team in sometimes positive and at times unintentional hilarious ways. But touching as well. The story of Niclas Füllkrug almost brought tears into my eyes. Especially when you know where he's coming from. It feels like a Rocky Balboa story. For himself he played a great tournament and is the best part by far. The other good part was Thomas Müller who almost an other side of himself. With his social media and his forced quirkiness he became more of a laughing stock over the years. But here he has the opportunity to show what a teamplayer and in interviews for the documentary what a reflecting smart guy he is. And Antonio Rüdiger. He seems like a cool guy or I just like him too much. Dunno.

The hilarity in this one I have mentioned. The funniest thing was definitely the motivation prior to the game against spain. They watch a documentary about grey goose. No joke. I really don't know what was Bierhoffs intention behind this and I'm not the only person who's asking. The blank faces of the players in this scene are just pure gold! Bierhoff has done a great job the last 15 years but he probably knew for himself that his time was already expired. That's why he stepped down after it.

The other is the coach Hansi Flick. You can see that he can't reach the guys with his announcements. And it doesn't help that he talks in a sweet swabian accent. Quite contrary even. Fun fact: He got sacked last weekend.

I missed that this documentary doesn't show why this team with that huge talent in almost every position performed so weak in the end. As a viewer you really have to pay attention to see hints between here and there. The team probably got affected by the politics around. The infamous story about the rainbow- or (because the quatari government doesn't like LGBTQ-rights) "One love"-Armlet. It was a s***show. The players had to handle it by their own and out came the often mocked team photo of the players cover their mouth. And to blame are Bierhoff and his management. They didn't even try and by that failed miserably. Why did they leave it all to players? How could they get their head in the game if they get distracted by a random decision of the association? Too bad that this documentary didn't focus on that. They wanted to make six episodes and needed content. They had an opportunity here.

It wasn't a very informative show. Entertaining if you look a bit further. Why they made this in the first place is beyond me. The team is highly talented on some positions but unbalanced with it on the other side. Flick is a great coach. Beforehand he trained Bayern Munich and won everything in just one season. But he was the wrong coach for this insecure team.

If you want to have a good laugh - go for it. And Füllkrugs story is awesome. The makers of this show didn't do a good job in my opinion. It was my first "All or nothing"-show and it surely be the last. Everything of how not to make a documentary - you see it here. But it was entertaining. I'm sure it wasn't their intention and definitely not of the DFB. It has to be. So give it an 8/10.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I wished here were more episodes. But so does the team probably.
bjoernidler18 September 2023
I get why the All or nothing crew chose the german national team for this documentary. They failed miserably in Russia in 2018, Jogi Löw quit as headcoach. There was a good chance that under Hansi Flick, who had won the triple with Bayern a short time ago, this could turn into an interesting Rocky-like story. But things turned out differently, as is mentioned in the first minutes of the show. So this shouldn't spoil anyone.

I don't know if the true spirit of the team is shown here. You have to know that editing is everything in these kind of sports documentaries. By choosing the scenes, the way they are cut and the music the makers can make the team seem intact or not. The same goes for the players. Do they seem positive and funny or passive and arrogant?

But I'm going to write about what I saw since I don't know about the other filmed material.

Some positive things: Niklas Füllkrug is the real deal. He's confident, a teamplayer and has the most emotional speech in the locker room as a newcomer! Also, he didn't disappoint in the games.

Thomas Müller is a legend. He always gives everything although he is limited technically and physically. He is important for every team he plays in.

Filming was of high quality.

The episodes went by quickly and didn't bore me for a minute.

The stupid affair of the one love arm patch wasn't left out but didn't take up more time than neccessary.

I got the feeling that something was off in this team. It seems that Flick didn't reach the players completely. I also got the impression that too few of the players were willing to give this their all. Many seemed rather distant. And except for some players, they didn't seem to have too much fun as a group. Again, could be that it just isn't shown but that's my impression. It's also kind of sad that they had the feeling of not being supported from home. The World cup in Katar was a bad idea from my perspective. But the team still deserves support. If they give everything,that is.

This documentary isn't a heroes journey. It's a story of defeat. That makes it probably less fun to watch than other sports documentaries, but interesting none the less.

As I'm writing this, Hansi Flick was fired as coach about a week ago. Watching this documentary made me think that this was for the best. So I'm thankful for this insight.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed