In this intro to The Fake and The Whimsy universe Greg and Jon have a guest cancellation left with no topic so therefore they decide to bash their own podcast as well as past guests and friends of the show.
Greg and Jon recount the events that led to their meeting with Seattle's psychic to the stars Meekie McPhee and how an appearance on the podcast attempting to give skeptic Jon a psychic reading went south.
Greg, Jon and Marc use a time machine to travel back to Thanksgiving after which they discuss pranks, Greg's impression talent that was taken away by a witch and Jon being ambushed to play a game involving Facebook.
Bob Somethingorother calls in on a burner phone from a secret location and does not permit Jon to be on the show. Bob proceeds to give Greg highly classified intel..
Before starting a party of a random potpourri myriad of topics with Lara, Gilberto and Marc Seidenstein for no apparent reason Greg and Jon tell the story of meeting their new sponsors "THE JOUST".
Greg and Jon are joined by Matt McHenry and DJ Nik along with a selected group of past guests of the show celebrating MSV Podcast as a whole along with each other It's just a big old shindig that is filled with lots of laughs, love and fun
Greg recounts to Jon and David Noyce a story his dad used to tell him involving his best friend Steve and he on an evening at a clam bar in Coney Island.
Marc Seidenstein returns to play his Facebook game from the Thanksgiving show but this time Greg plays along with guest Aaron Cohen and much higher stakes this time around.
Jon welcomes back Seattle's psychic to the stars Meekie McPhee to try once more to give him a psychic reading and after much trials and tribulations an old friend of the show returns from beyond the grave with some important predictions.
In the first season finale before new shows in season two begin we hear some excerpt bits from MSV Podcast episodes that didn't "qualify" to be part of "The Fake and The Whimsy" as well as some bloopers and outtakes from other MSV shows.