TV food critic Eddie Gourmand is fired when the station chief, a health freak, decides to present a nearly calorie free alternative, which nobody likes to watch. Jon invites Eddie for a consolation dinner, but the glutton proves so much worse that even Garfield can't eat anything, then trips, breaks his food and threatens with a lawsuit unless waited on hand and foot during his weeks of recovery. While the pets try desperately to get rid of him by pretending to have turned into health freaks, the station manager decides his rating require restoring Gourmand. Alas, Jon repeats his naively kind error.
—KGF Vissers