Upstream (2016) Poster

(2016)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
A slow story in every sense
blueboot6 October 2017
Normally most French movies are full of intrigue, superbly relevant dialogue, where tales unfold amidst compelling tension, against beautiful backdrops. More often than not central characters win over the audience and we care about them in no time at all. The main part of this story is certainly set against picturesque scenery; a Croatian river and fjord. Unfortunately the usual impeccable standard of French cinematography ends right there.

Two French speaking fifty-something half-brothers meet and decide to go on a long boat trip and trek deep into the Croatian countryside. Their mutual quest - to learn about each other, and more pertinently, what happened to their father - to see where and why he had mysteriously died in a remote mountainous region.

Much of the film concentrates on revealing what the personalities of the two non-verbose men are like as they initially travel alone in the boat along a winding river. Joe (Sergi Lopez), the more genial of the pair, is an author; a man who had spent time in the great outdoors of Alaska. He is patient, tough in a non-threatening way, but quiet. The other half-brother who had been raised without his father, Homer (Olivier Gourmet) seems similar ....at first. As they spend time bonding, drinking, manning the boat, and caring for a puppy they have with them, we see them gradually share experiences of fishing, cooking, sleeping and hiking. Nothing particularly out of the ordinary. In fact, though the film ambles slowly along in a beautiful setting it is practically devoid of tension or intrigue. We are led to believe that their father may have committed suicide. Could that be true? The brothers are unsure but sceptical. Homer's disposition starts to emerge. He has a short fuse. If anything happened, he would surely be the one to resort to violence. But what would cause him to explode? Devoid of any tension director / producer Marion Hansel presumably realised that as half the film was over she needed to inject a change of pace. At that point, by chance Joe and Homer stumble across an Irish conservationist ranger, Sean (John Lynch) and strike up a conversation. Sean reluctantly accepts a fee to take them to a hard-to-find Monastery where their father had died. Homer becomes suspicious of Sean and thankfully some conflict erupts. All too late, all too brief. If your curiosity is peaked to learn what fleetingly happens then you should watch.

There is a minor twist, but in all honesty, it does not save this film from being drab, uninteresting and at times dreadfully slow. Other cameo characters are largely irrelevant to the story. Perhaps, had there been a more generous dialogue it may have saved the film. It's always preferable to glowingly review films, especially French films. However, the truth is, the two brothers are entirely forgettable, as is this film.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Up the river
searchanddestroy-17 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
A rather sensitive adventure drama, the tale of two half brothers - with only the same dad - who meet in order to seek how and why their old man died in ex Yougoslavia. They only know he was mysteriously shot in the mountain, near Zagreb. So then begins a sort of initiatic journey for both of them, who will slowly discover each other, more than finding how their father actually died, although they will finally know.

SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS But the irony is that they will find out that their father was just a SOB, a brutal asshole who did certainly not deserve to be sought as he was by his boys. Yes, this is a touching story, very beautifully made, with from time to time some DELIVERANCE tributes.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
a story from East
Kirpianuscus7 October 2017
special. because it is like many others. two half brothers. and memories about father. a trip. and the answers. far by expected reality. and a friendship. poetry of image. admirable photography. a bitter portrait of two men looking for the truth behind the appearances. short, one of the films who gives sketches of answers. slow, cold, touching, simple. the dialogues - one of the most inspired parts. and the build of the delicate comradely between Homer and Jo. so, must see it. for its beauty, off course, for the performances. but, more important, for the questions about yourself. because it is a trip across ages and inspired definition of family.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed