Magicians looking to fool Penn and Teller this time: Matt Marcy does a card guessing trick (utilizing Hannigan) after making a long entertaining presentation about it, a vintage-styled mentalist and his female assistant who go by the name The Sentimentalists try to guess an image an audience member drew, engineer and handyman Andrew Evans and his friend Naomi do a levitation trick that keeps building, Australian beer lover Don Chambers repeatedly makes beer magically appear, and finally Piff the Magic Dragon and his dragon friend Penn sing the dragon song where they have to guess the words that the audience will add to its lyrics.
—Penn will never Tell'er