Sherlock Holmes has been interpreted, updated or abused countless times. Some get the essence of the original character right (ranging from the extremely faithful Jeremy Brett series to the American update in the form of Elementary (2012)), some have no relation except in name (2009's Sherlock Holmes (2009) comes to mind).
Here we have a film that at least tries and might have got away with a better lead than Ben Syder. Unfortunately, he is not up to the task. Gareth David-Lloyd is a bit too young as Dr. Watson, while William Huw is quite adequate.
Now, this is a C-movie, so we can not expect much in terms of production values. A major letdown is the cinematography. The basic setup of the shots is not to blame neither the overuse of filters but at the end most scenes were simply way too dark (so I had to apply filters of my own to adjust brightness and contrast).
What makes the film bearable is its short running time and reasonably fast pacing. Storywise it deviates from Arthur Conan Doyle's original material, as do most post-copyright productions. It is not always coherent; I feel it could use a better treatment of character development, their backgrounds and the events leading to those depicted in this film.
Overall, fair enough considering the budget, but probably rather recommendable to fans of Asylum's work than to Sherlockians.
Here we have a film that at least tries and might have got away with a better lead than Ben Syder. Unfortunately, he is not up to the task. Gareth David-Lloyd is a bit too young as Dr. Watson, while William Huw is quite adequate.
Now, this is a C-movie, so we can not expect much in terms of production values. A major letdown is the cinematography. The basic setup of the shots is not to blame neither the overuse of filters but at the end most scenes were simply way too dark (so I had to apply filters of my own to adjust brightness and contrast).
What makes the film bearable is its short running time and reasonably fast pacing. Storywise it deviates from Arthur Conan Doyle's original material, as do most post-copyright productions. It is not always coherent; I feel it could use a better treatment of character development, their backgrounds and the events leading to those depicted in this film.
Overall, fair enough considering the budget, but probably rather recommendable to fans of Asylum's work than to Sherlockians.
Tell Your Friends