Reviews

4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Harry Brown (2009)
9/10
brilliant film
21 November 2009
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this the same evening I went to see 2012, this film was in smaller room but it was packed and I can see why. 2012 should get an Oscar for special effects but this film had all that the bigger budget movie lacked - pace, direction, emotional appeal, setting, gripping story and purpose.

The premise is 'broken' Britain, the one away from the nice parts that we want to live in, the influence of Ken Loach, who has been making these for years was there in the depiction of the setting but the story was very much a 50's western. The problems it clearly depicts are the legacy of 1980's government policy and how they smashed communities and the fabric of society.

The film highlights the failure of the police and authority on these estates (the TV show Spiral II does this too) and the isolation many who live their feel in face of this official indifference and how they are preyed on by their own: however,the solution it presents, 'vigilantism' is unreal.

The film is raw and the presentation of the lead character is realistic and human - a man from another age who has somehow arrived in a different country. I think films in the 70's also depicted this kind of hell to scare the folks in the nice houses who see these people as 'not like' them and ignore the underclass. The denouement makes great cinema, keeps it feet in the real world but for all that, is an unrealistic solution to the problems it highlights - everyone knows in that another gang would move into the vacuum created by the termination of the criminals unless there was social investment.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Secuestro (2005)
7/10
gritty tightly made movie
23 June 2006
Normally in a box like this you would say how much you enjoyed or hated a movie, in this case I think the word 'enjoy' is too pervy. I think that the film maker presents a gritty drama about a crime phenomenon in South America without judging anyone, who is the bad guy, obviously the flaky boy friend. I always watch these movies in hope that the world they show does not exist and the film is over egging the pudding, but sadly things you read elsewhere show how true it is and like many other movies from South America, they show the disparity in wealth between the haves and have nots'. In the past, we could be smug about our societies not being like that, but I am not so sure anymore. I thought that the acting was believable especially from the victims, I am not sure about the hoodlum with principles considering the cruelty of everything else the 'bad guys' did.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Election (2005)
8/10
efficient hong kong crime drama
23 June 2006
enjoyed the movie and efficient Confucian crime drama, the old order survives the threat posed by a brash young greedy man, no doubt representing modern society. I thought the final scene was strange and could not understand if we were to believe that big D was being punished for being greedy or it was part of the plan a long. I loved the scene and for once in a Chinese movie, the violence was not a choreographed martial arts fest. On thing that always amuses me about HK films is that the main influence the British seem to have had is to introduce 'yes sir' and 'sorry' into the local language and its amusing that long after we have gone, they are still there.
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Secuestro express (II) (2004)
7/10
gritty realistic and filmed in a documentary style
23 June 2006
Normally in a box like this you would say how much you enjoyed or hated a movie, in this case I think the word 'enjoy' is too pervy. I think that the film maker presents a gritty drama about a crime phenomenon in South America without judging anyone, who is the bad guy, obviously the flaky boy friend. I always watch these movies in hope that the world they show does not exist and the film is over egging the pudding, but sadly things you read elsewhere show how true it is and like many other movies from South America, they show the disparity in wealth between the haves and have nots'. In the past, we could be smug about our societies not being like that, but I am not so sure anymore. I thought that the acting was believable especially from the victims, I am not sure about the hoodlum with principles considering the cruelty of everything else the 'bad guys' did.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed