I have not read the book of Zorba, which I may do in order to find out if the book has any messages and actually says anything more than the film does. I assume, and hope, that it does. I was very relieved, on reading the last few of the previous reviews here, to find that some other viewers found the film depressing, misogynistic and unpleasant.
I agree, as another reviewer suggested, that it's most likely the soundtrack which made this a popular film. Or at least I hope that it is. I did not think I had a very high opinion of human nature, but my opinion will have to be lowered even further if it's true that huge numbers of people actually enjoyed a film in which the two female characters are reviled, made fun of, and either murdered or have to see their house being looted around them as they die.
Female sexuality in this film is treated as a either a pathetic joke or a threat. Even though Zorba is kind to the older woman as she dies, for the rest of the film he treats her like dirt. He humors her while she's awake (and thus presumably able to give him sexual favors), but when she falls asleep he calls her a dirty b***h and mocks her. After the young widow is murdered, Zorba asks "Why do the young die?" as if she had just died some natural death, instead of being murdered by the entire village. When the Englishman says that his books talk about the suffering of men who ask questions like Zorba's, Zorba answers "I spit on their suffering." That, it seems, is what the whole film is doing -- showing immense suffering and cruelty, but then saying that the only thing to do in the face of that suffering is to dance -- rather than trying to do something to stop the cruelty.
The one character in the film who seems to have a sensible, human reaction to the horror around them is the apparent "village idiot", who screams at the villagers "murderers! Killers!" Perhaps that is the point here, that the supposedly sane people are hideous murderers, and only the "idiot" can see how psychotic the rest of the world is.
If that is the intended point, it's an interesting one. But I can't tell if the filmmakers were actually trying to make that point, or if they think it's all right to go through life despising everyone around you, never trying to help anyone, and dancing.
I agree, as another reviewer suggested, that it's most likely the soundtrack which made this a popular film. Or at least I hope that it is. I did not think I had a very high opinion of human nature, but my opinion will have to be lowered even further if it's true that huge numbers of people actually enjoyed a film in which the two female characters are reviled, made fun of, and either murdered or have to see their house being looted around them as they die.
Female sexuality in this film is treated as a either a pathetic joke or a threat. Even though Zorba is kind to the older woman as she dies, for the rest of the film he treats her like dirt. He humors her while she's awake (and thus presumably able to give him sexual favors), but when she falls asleep he calls her a dirty b***h and mocks her. After the young widow is murdered, Zorba asks "Why do the young die?" as if she had just died some natural death, instead of being murdered by the entire village. When the Englishman says that his books talk about the suffering of men who ask questions like Zorba's, Zorba answers "I spit on their suffering." That, it seems, is what the whole film is doing -- showing immense suffering and cruelty, but then saying that the only thing to do in the face of that suffering is to dance -- rather than trying to do something to stop the cruelty.
The one character in the film who seems to have a sensible, human reaction to the horror around them is the apparent "village idiot", who screams at the villagers "murderers! Killers!" Perhaps that is the point here, that the supposedly sane people are hideous murderers, and only the "idiot" can see how psychotic the rest of the world is.
If that is the intended point, it's an interesting one. But I can't tell if the filmmakers were actually trying to make that point, or if they think it's all right to go through life despising everyone around you, never trying to help anyone, and dancing.
Tell Your Friends