Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
The Island (2005)
7/10
Promising first half, then goes down the drain...
31 January 2006
Warning: Spoilers
not Being a fan of blockbuster movies, I found myself renting this on DVD. The idea is interesting and raises interesting questions, however the 6th day also deals more or less in the same theme, so it's not an original idea.

so the first half hour is very interesting as it raises questions of why is there this sort of 1984 society in 2019, however as soon as Macgregor starts running away from explosions you see the true aim of the movie. Instead on focusing more on the characters and the interesting story they had in hands, the old movie clichés are brought into the equation, like the quick killed sidekick, the romance, the hero who thinks of the others before himself. Typical blockbuster movie.

Also I found Scarlet's character totally unnecessary, remove her from the movie and you get exactly the same movie, she was not needed at all, but of course, every blockbuster needs some pretty eyes.

Also some very bad and predictable moments, when the guy who helps Macgregor escape says he goes get a map, it was obvious he was getting killed, or when Macgregor sponsor says he's going to get some shoes it was obvious he was either calling the police, or get a gun or call the makers of the clones.

And a bit far fetched was the fall from the building with both the hero's holding to the "R" logo, very unlikely they would survive that.

This reminds me of the new Star Wars films, excellent material to work with, but badly put on screen due to the necessity (why?) to show SFX, eye candy and explosions.

Also the product placements were.. unnecessary and hard to believe that in 2019 the xbox logo and the msn search logo will look exactly the same after almost 20 years!
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Entertaining, but could be better
22 August 2004
Warning: Spoilers
I read most of the comics of Michael Vaillant when I was a kid, and I think this movie captured the spirit of the comics. The story could be better, but it was entertaining.

However I noticed 3 things that in my opinion are errors:

*Spoiler Warning*

  • The scene with Vaillant driving around Le Mans Flat out with is eyes closed... Was that really necessary? I think nobody have done it and nobody will because it's impossible.


  • The scene Vaillant and Warson refuel their racing cars in a regular fuel pump, I might be wrong, But the fuel used in racing cars is a lot different from the one we refuel our cars.


  • The final scene with the Leader car in the final lap in the straight blowing is engine, why is the smoke coming out in the front of the car when the engine is at the back?


*End Spoiler Warning*

If you are a racing fan you should see this movie, don't think much about the storyline and focus on some nice images of cars.

For non racing fans, I doubt they enjoy this movie.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed