Is it just me, or am I the only person here who doesn't understand the hype for this film, i've watched this movie 4 times and couldn't get into it, nor could I understand it.
I've watched fantastic Mr Fox in the past and the film never really appealed to me that much, I didn't like the uncanniness of the characters, and the seemingly mumbling dialogue.
But after watching Isle of Dogs, I completely changed my mind about fantastic Mr Fox, and after re-watching it, despite the creepy animation, fantastic Mr Fox had much better looking visuals, the action scenes look like they had effort put into them, and the film treated. It's happy ending in a way that felt like a happy ending.
Isle of dogs on the other hand, had none of that.
The characters in this movie look just as creepy, and I don't even think the scariest horror movie of all time can come close to this level of creepiness, this is my issue with the film, it's considered a comedy and it's treated like a comedy by so many people, but I've watched the film several times, never laughed once, and I remembered being creeped out by how the way the characters break the fourth wall with their eyes, wide open and grinning unsettlingly.
I noticed that a spike being a PG film, it has quite a lot of blood violence, and that's the type of violence that you wouldn't really see in a PG rated film today. And the violence was so exaggerated that combined with the creepy uncanny characters. Just didn't make the film feel like a comedy it made it feel like a horror film, even if the blood violence was dark humour, then he did a really BAD JOB, because it's not executed in a way that feels funny, I never felt like there was any clever context for why they were in these situations because it comes out dead randomly, in certain parts, making it feel like it was happening just for the shock value.
Despite being a comedy, it was a down right miserable film, now I get that the dogs are dumped on an island, which is understandable, but remembered when I said that fantastic Mr Fox had a happy ending that felt like one, Isle of dogs had one as well, but even with it, the characters still seemed depressed in away, the only emotions that I ever truly saw in the film was angry, sad and confused, and I did not record seeing a single character smile.
I didn't really like how the film had all these random scenes, like the sumo wrestling, kabuki, and the sushi scene, I get that they try to acknowledge Japanese culture in a positive light, but I've noticed that the scenes just happened and never get brought up again. It's like they were just there for the sake of satisfying the audience, I know we all like to be satisfied, and I understand that, but without no plot or reason, it just kind of makes these scenes feel random and pointless, and they don't add anything to the story.
Remember, when I said that fantastic Mr Fox had mumbling voice acting, at least I film exaggerated the dialogue by having the characters shout and all that, all the dogs did host, some voiced actors like Bill Murray, who I think is a legendary actor, and he has the voice of an Angel,
But his voice in this film, just sounds like nails, scraping a chalkboard, the way the characters were speaking, sounded almost like they were mumbling or whispering, and it was just grating to me.
I have never truly seen the brilliance in this, i've heard a lot of people saying that this is the goat of all Stop Motion films, and I'm like GUYS!! We've got paranormal, Del Toros Pinocchio, Coraline, Merry and Max, and you just want this to be the best one of all time.
I've never understood the overwhelming appeal for this form at all, and I don't think I'll ever understand what people like about it.
0 out of 3 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends