Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
An epic visual feast for both new and long-time fans alike
12 June 2008
I was a large fan of both the original series, the half-release 'Death and Rebirth' and the replacement ending 'The End of Evangelion', so I'm not giving this praise as some guy who's just walked in on this.

I am extremely pleased with this new iteration of Evangelion. I don't even know where to begin ... Gainax threw out everything they had, completely redrawing all the animation and backgrounds in painstakingly high detail. It is the most apparent revision to the series at first glance ... all the visuals are top-notch, even the computer-generated graphics which I would typically find unforgivable in a film - but everything is drawn and animated so smooth, and the rare use of CG is so well-integrated into the film that it feels like you haven't been taken out of the organic animation at all.

The storyline is quite similar to the original, though first on the side I want to say they've taken much thought deciding how to develop the characters better; and the result is that the cast is much more believable and their chemistry is quite fantastic. The characters just feel deeper, their emotions are more genuine; it's hard to describe in a review but if you're a fan of the original series you'll find their personalities and interactions much more developed and satisfying.

The plot, as I've said; has not changed too much at this point.. there are exceptions here and there, with the introductions of pivotal locations and characters earlier on; no doubt to lay down continuity for the later installments. (The original Evangelion had a slight problem with eclectic character and plot point introductions.) They have taken care to set the stage more carefully for the first scene this time around; and as shown with the early introduction of an important character Gainax intends to make full use of some fantastic characters that didn't get enough time in the spotlight to really add anything especially deep.

I recommend this film to anybody who is a fan of serious animation; and I would say that it's an absolute must-see for fans of the original series.

It's comforting to know that in a world of poor remakes and extensions of popular titles, that Gainax has their wits about them and shows true dedication in their efforts to make Evangelion into everything that it could possibly be.
37 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
I won't enjoy the original trilogy the same way I did before.
7 June 2008
Warning: Spoilers
It was good to see Indy again, but not this way. I don't even know where to begin .. a storyline that seemed like it was rushing us through, the obscure scene/location changes, or the absolutely ridiculous plot. I would write a long critique on this film, but I'm simply too tired from seeing it to even bother. I just want to warn the die-hard Indiana Jones fans ... it's not worth it to go back, unless you think telepathic pan-dimensional generic looking Aliens with a giant UFO are a fantastic place for the IJ series to go.

I didn't think Lucas could escape the epic failure of the recent Star Wars trilogy without learning any lessons about cutting production costs by using computer graphics imagery. I really thought somebody would have stepped in and told him to do this right.

I don't even want my money back. I just want to forget.

This movie isn't for die-hard Indiana Jones fans.

This movie is for kids who don't know the original trilogy enough to be able to make a distinction between it and this cheap ride.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed