I am so sick and tired of these americanized movies attempting to adapt anime source material. You would think we learned from Dragonball, Avatar The Last Airbender and now this. The Death Note anime is one of my top anime series of all time, and also just one of my favorite television shows. It's so beautifully executed. Intelligent, thrilling, well animated, has an amazing soundtrack. It's characters are compelling. Up until L ultimately dies, the series is pretty perfect. Even afterwards it's done well, but just doesn't hold a candle to the first half of the series.
Now...we have this. This movie is so disrespectful of its source material, which seems to be a trend with these type of adaptations. The director doesn't even come close to its source material, even setting that aside this movie would still be pretty trash. Everything that made the original series great isn't shown here. I like many others were surprised to see the casting. Now I didn't necessarily think we needed an asian actor to play Light or Misa or L even. Whitewashing is a very real problem in filmmaking, however I didn't go there in this case. Since in the anime/manga they are drawn looking more westernized, which is pretty common in Japan. They're characters after all, so they have overly eccentric features and attributes. So I didn't necessarily care about the casting as long as it was good. Unfortunately it just wasn't.
Light's actor is god awful. Now I understand Light is a very VERY difficult character to play. Not only is he a genius psychopath whose masking his inner thoughts constantly, but have you seen his facial expressions in the anime? He's either non-expressive or outlandishly revealing. That's not easy to do and this actor just can't pull it off, he just doesn't have that range. So Light is resorted to being a screaming obnoxious main character. Misa is put in a position of being more manipulative, which isn't her character at all! The screenplay literally skimmed the manga and thought "oh wait! They're a couple right? Let's add in some romance!" Which is so beneath the source material. So we get a force-fed romance that we never wanted.
L is alright, however for some reason he's a vigilante kind of in this movie? His character utilizes his intelligence to his advantage, but never ever does he wave a gun in the anime or attempt to chase down suspects. What the hell was that!? He's also wearing a hoodie constantly which bugged me. His character is so weird and quirky, but in the film he's stripped down to nothing as well. Where's the barefooted, cake eating boy we all love!
Ryuk is actually the best part of this movie. Willem Dafoe voicing him was a brilliant idea and it works! However, his humor isn't quite on par and being surrounded by the rest of this terrible movie...it was impossible to salvage anything. He looks pretty great too, even amongst the poorly lit boring sets they plopped him in. Sure the anime wasn't super colourful or anything (except for the red/blue contrast which NEVER HAPPENS IN THIS) but you can make a scene visually stimulating without bright colours.
I honestly wish this film was never made, because I don't want people to think this is what Death Note is, it definitely isn't! Watch the anime, get immersed and forget about this movie.
Now...we have this. This movie is so disrespectful of its source material, which seems to be a trend with these type of adaptations. The director doesn't even come close to its source material, even setting that aside this movie would still be pretty trash. Everything that made the original series great isn't shown here. I like many others were surprised to see the casting. Now I didn't necessarily think we needed an asian actor to play Light or Misa or L even. Whitewashing is a very real problem in filmmaking, however I didn't go there in this case. Since in the anime/manga they are drawn looking more westernized, which is pretty common in Japan. They're characters after all, so they have overly eccentric features and attributes. So I didn't necessarily care about the casting as long as it was good. Unfortunately it just wasn't.
Light's actor is god awful. Now I understand Light is a very VERY difficult character to play. Not only is he a genius psychopath whose masking his inner thoughts constantly, but have you seen his facial expressions in the anime? He's either non-expressive or outlandishly revealing. That's not easy to do and this actor just can't pull it off, he just doesn't have that range. So Light is resorted to being a screaming obnoxious main character. Misa is put in a position of being more manipulative, which isn't her character at all! The screenplay literally skimmed the manga and thought "oh wait! They're a couple right? Let's add in some romance!" Which is so beneath the source material. So we get a force-fed romance that we never wanted.
L is alright, however for some reason he's a vigilante kind of in this movie? His character utilizes his intelligence to his advantage, but never ever does he wave a gun in the anime or attempt to chase down suspects. What the hell was that!? He's also wearing a hoodie constantly which bugged me. His character is so weird and quirky, but in the film he's stripped down to nothing as well. Where's the barefooted, cake eating boy we all love!
Ryuk is actually the best part of this movie. Willem Dafoe voicing him was a brilliant idea and it works! However, his humor isn't quite on par and being surrounded by the rest of this terrible movie...it was impossible to salvage anything. He looks pretty great too, even amongst the poorly lit boring sets they plopped him in. Sure the anime wasn't super colourful or anything (except for the red/blue contrast which NEVER HAPPENS IN THIS) but you can make a scene visually stimulating without bright colours.
I honestly wish this film was never made, because I don't want people to think this is what Death Note is, it definitely isn't! Watch the anime, get immersed and forget about this movie.
Tell Your Friends