Where to begin with Irreversible.... I know from having read other user comments that a number of people out there like Gaspar Noe's style with short sharp cuts and whirling perspective's. To the uninitiated (I include myself in this) this can be hard to watch and can leave you with a nauseating feeling. This however seems apt for the subject matter of this piece.
Stylistically I think the movie is well done, but that would be seriously overlooking the content of the film.
I'm not the type of person who has a weak disposition or feels squeamish at the sight of blood. I've sat through and enjoyed "A Clockwork Orange" and "Silence of the Lambs" and although disturbing in the exploration of violence, and the psychology of the criminal mind, I never felt that there was a gratuitous nature to the presentation of this subject matter. However I couldn't help but feel that the two scenes that define this film were unnecessarily violent and amounted to little more than a dressed up snuff movie.
The suggestion that by telling the story in reverse that somehow the movie ends on a pleasant note doesn't hold water for me. I was so shell shocked that even the sight of Monica Belucci frolicking naked made me feel a little uneasy, after witnessing her humiliation earlier in the movie.
I think it's a disappointment that such an artistically shot movie should gratuitously present such horrific subject matter. I'd suggest that Gaspar Noe should turn his attention to something more worthy of his ability.
1 out of 10.
Stylistically I think the movie is well done, but that would be seriously overlooking the content of the film.
I'm not the type of person who has a weak disposition or feels squeamish at the sight of blood. I've sat through and enjoyed "A Clockwork Orange" and "Silence of the Lambs" and although disturbing in the exploration of violence, and the psychology of the criminal mind, I never felt that there was a gratuitous nature to the presentation of this subject matter. However I couldn't help but feel that the two scenes that define this film were unnecessarily violent and amounted to little more than a dressed up snuff movie.
The suggestion that by telling the story in reverse that somehow the movie ends on a pleasant note doesn't hold water for me. I was so shell shocked that even the sight of Monica Belucci frolicking naked made me feel a little uneasy, after witnessing her humiliation earlier in the movie.
I think it's a disappointment that such an artistically shot movie should gratuitously present such horrific subject matter. I'd suggest that Gaspar Noe should turn his attention to something more worthy of his ability.
1 out of 10.
Tell Your Friends