Reviews

5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Jane Eyre (2011)
5/10
Not bad, but have seen better
20 September 2011
Jane Eyre has to be one of the best classics of all time, with its intricate plot and darkly mysterious, brooding atmosphere.

It seems such a shame that this film has been made and yet has, in my opinion, left out all of the passion and feeling which makes Jane Eyre the critically acclaimed story that it undoubtedly is.

I felt that Jane was too young, incredibly passionless and quite insipid in this part, which is a shame, as I do not consider this to be a true representation of the Jane from the novel. Mr Rochester was not too bad, although he wasn't interesting enough. Part of Mr Rochester's attractiveness comes from the fact that he is so abrupt, whimsical and mysterious. The viewer wants to know who he really is beneath the mask. Unfortunately, I did not feel like this at all when watching Michael Fassbender act out this part.

It is a shame, as I feel that any film version of this great novel should convey the vibrancy, feeling, mystery and passion which harbours within its pages and yet I was left feeling disappointed that this had not been achieved.

Having said that, I could not say that the acting was particularly bad or that the film couldn't hold the interest of its viewers; simply that, for myself, being a Jane Eyre enthusiast, the casting and also the cuts that were made to make this film disappointed me.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Mary Poppins (1964)
10/10
Dream world!
12 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
It is said that we all have an inner child within us, just waiting for any possible excuse to surface and allow us back into our own childhood when everything seemed possible and we had none of the worries that creep upon us as we grow accustomed to the harsh reality of an imperfect world. In order to really enjoy this film as it ought to be enjoyed, it is necessary to find that inner child again and just sit back and enjoy being wrapped up in a fairy land, seen through the eyes of children. This beautiful film may not have benefited from some of the technology used to provide the special effects or visually stunning films we see these days, but for me, this only adds to its charm. That such a film can have been made a relatively long time ago and yet still be the tireless classic it is today, speaks for itself how truly remarkable it really is. I find myself completely lost in this film every time I watch it, and I suspect many viewers may at first think, like Mr. Banks, that people do not climb smoky ladders or dance on rooftops or ride fairground horses but by the time the film is over, also like Mr. Banks, I am sure they will have changed their mind. Because, you see, children do climb smoky ladders and dance on rooftops and ride fairground horses....in their own little imaginary dream world, and, as an older person who finds this film completely irresistible, it is so nice to escape back to those care free, dreamy, childish days myself...
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Little Dorrit (2008)
10/10
Classic drama
10 October 2010
I love this version of Little Dorrit. Whilst I have not read the book, and so cannot vouch for its following the storyline faithfully, I find it interesting enough to enjoy it immensely every time I watch it.

Some characters are funny, some capricious, others are mercenary whilst a few are kind and good hearted. The juxtaposition of all the different personalities really does make good viewing, and the true Dickensian oddities are very funny and entertaining, like Mr. Panks or the extraordinary French gentleman!

The story holds a lot of events and developments that both interest and satisfy the viewer. A classic tale of love, hardship and affluence, this film is like a ray of sunlight in a darkened room: murky and mysterious, yet somehow also rather quaint and sweet.
15 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Dreadful
6 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
This film was so awful I felt it was degrading to even bother watching it. It is a complete and utter insult to anyone with any common sense. Pride and Prejudice it most certainly was NOT. As a film in its own merit without comparing it to the Jane Austen novel, it was barely passable.

Mr. Darcy spoke so fast you felt he was rushing through the sentences to fit the whole film into its running time. He had so many conflicting moods and moments that you didn't warm to him at all, he didn't seem to know himself what he was meant to be like. He spoke sentences like he was reading them straight from the script.

Elizabeth was so flighty and stupid. I hated the dresses she wore. She often looked a mess and completely irritated me all the way through. She had none of the clever wit that she is supposed to possess.

Mr. Bingley...well! What can I say?! He was such a dolt that no woman with an ounce of sense would want to be seen in his company, let alone get married to him! His complete lack of sense or manners was disturbing to say the least.

Jane was pretty but that was all. I never felt drawn to her character or even interested in her fate.

I couldn't work out which of the girls were Kitty or Lydia, they were like vague shadows with no substance. I realised, of course, who Lydia was when the elopement had taken place with Mr Wickham, but even that was unsatisfactory in the extreme. Mr. Wickham looked awful, and not at all the dashing handsome swindler he is supposed to be. We didn't even get to meet him properly or get to know what he was really like, whilst his past relation to the Darcy estate was hurriedly introduced so there was no time to allow this to sink in or take full effect.

Lady Catherine was much too softly spoken to make a forceful, spoilt woman and her arrival at the Bennet house in the early hours of the morning was just ridiculous. I call it house, pig sty may be a better word. Animals wandering through the house?!

The dances were so crowded it was difficult to follow the story at those points.

Altogether, one of the worst films I have ever sat through. If this is the future of period dramas I am mortified.

Jane Austen would turn in her grave.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Emma (2009)
10/10
Wonderful adaption!
5 October 2010
Emma is a complete delight to watch. In a world where films are usually ruined by having dramatic changes made to the characters or plots, this BBC adaption is quite faithful to the book and is a wonderful "escape" to a world we no longer live in and yet are completely fascinated by. I found this version was warm hearted and funny. Emma was my favourite of all the Jane Austen novels when I read them yet I never felt that any of the previous versions did the book any justice. This one, however, was captivating. The characters were well portrayed and the casting was brilliant.

Romola Garai was light hearted and brought a fresh youthfulness to the part of Emma which I found particularly refreshing, whilst Jonny Lee Miller portrayed a perfect Mr. Knightley, bluntly truthful and sensible, yet somehow catching the "cheerful manner" Jane Austen describes him as possessing.

All in all a very good film that can be watched over and over. I would say that, if you are a true Jane Austen fanatic, this series cannot fail to enchant you!
9 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed