Change Your Image
vijayvenkataramanan
Reviews
Anniyan (2005)
Shankar, where art thou flame?
No one ever expects much logic from Shankar. But high-octane paisa-vasool entertainment is something he has always delivered with his anti-corruption or social cleansing stories. Be it his debut Gentleman, Indian, Mudhalvan, Shankar consistently maintained his knack for fast paced, sleek, and epic-scaled storytelling, albeit sans logic. With Anniyan he disappoints big time. The film is illogical, inconsistent, over the top. At no point in the 3 hours does the narrative ever grip you. Oh for crying out loud, hire an experienced screenwriter next time. Don't waste money like this! And please spare us the cheap SFX gimmickry!
Veer-Zaara (2004)
Progressive Film
Reviewed by: Vijay Venkataramanan Reviewer's Rating: 9 out of 10
It's Diwali - the time for sweets, new clothes, fireworks, and as is customary every year in India, a star-studded, feel-good blockbuster. Yash Chopra's reclamation of the director's throne after seven long years is a simple return to the classical traditions of mainstream Indian film-making. The flair and sensitivity for romance is intact along with the passion for deep-rooted cultural and traditional mis-en-scene. However, neither is "Veer Zaara" a classic, nor is it even remotely comparable to Chopra's earlier masterpieces such as "Silsila", "Kaala Pathar", "Kabhie Kabhie", and "Lamhe". Yet, it is an ideal Diwali gift, exquisitely packaged, filled to the brim with sentiments and emotions, presented with only the best of intentions.
Squadron Leader Veer Pratap Singh (Shahrukh Khan) has been decaying in a Pakistani prison for twenty-two years. Saamiya Siddiqui (Rani Mukherjee), a local lawyer representing the Human Rights Commission undertakes the challenge of fighting for Veer so he can return to India. As Saamiya tries to unearth the hidden truth behind why and how Veer ended up in this situation, we are taken through a trip down memory lane as Veer recollects the days when he found and lost the love of his life, a Pakistani girl called Zaara (Priety Zinta).
What "Veer Zaara" lacks in terms of an innovative plot structure, it more than makes up for with Aditya Chopra's sometimes flawed, but sensitive writing. The supporting characters are extremely well fleshed out, and his dialogs witty and subtle. The storytelling is further enhanced with Javed Akhtar's lyrical wizardry, and Yash Chopra's tact for stretching defining moments of the story into musical interludes continues to fascinate. "Do pal ruka, khwaabon ka kaarvaan", a fine example of Mr. Akhtar's and Mr. Chopra's brilliance remains etched in your memory.
The film's grand-scale packaging is embellished by Sharmishta Roy's artistic, and exquisitely detailed production design, with each set being highly reflective of the characters that it holds in. Cinematographer Anil Sharma (Lagaan, Kal Ho Na Ho) sets up a rustic, yet opulent scheme to the film's largely rural setting that brings back memories of the evergreen "Dilwale Dulhania Le Jaayenge".
Actors including the great Amitabh Bachchan (who makes a stunning special appearance in this film with Hema Malini) have always elevated their performances to higher levels under Yash Chopra's baton. Rani Mukherjee follows in the same footsteps, playing the rookie lawyer with an admirable juxtaposition of nervousness and ferocity. While Preity Zinta and Shahrukh Khan too perform well in their respective roles, at no point does one feel that these two talented actors are ever challenged with roles such as these. Having played the loverboy so many times in the past, Veer Pratap Singh is a cakewalk for the Khan. The lead pair's chemistry from their younger days all the way to the days of their fifties is highly appreciable however. The supporting cast comprising of Divya Dutta, Kirron Kher, Boman Irani, and Manoj Bajpai make full use of their well-defined characters to enact high-caliber performances.
Other than the story of two fanatically devoted lovers, "Veer Zaara" is a progressive film for the Indian Film Industry because it makes an effort to break stereotypes with respect to Indo-Pak relations. It is a welcome change from the mindless Pak-bashing fare that we are routinely subjected to. Sensitive approaches like this first of all would help improve cultural ties, considering Hindi movies do comprise of a large portion of India's unofficial exports to Pakistan. Equally important is the economic factor because a culturally sensitive film like "Veer Zaara" is bound to officially open up a potentially huge, untapped, cinema-going audience across the border
Yuva (2004)
Scintillating stuff!
Mani Ratnam has brought tears to his viewers' eyes with his sensitivity in his earlier works. With "Yuva" he returns, but this time as a rogue filmmaker. This film's energy is infectious, its style gritty, rugged, yet fresh, and its execution, though a touch flawed at times, is immensely entertaining.
"Yuva" is highly recommended viewing for its brilliant direction, scintillating performances (especially Abhishek Bachchan), terrific music (the great A.R. Rahman), and stunning action on the razor's edge.
Pseudo-critics of certain Bollywood portals have panned this film. Oh if only they had a brain to understand this fine work of pop art.