I discovered this documentary on MSNBC shortly after its debut in 2008. Never has a film or documentary touched me as Dear Zachary has. Not only about the tragic murder of a young man but, it also shows how the Canadian Justice system failed so miserably.
Andrew Bagby was a 28 year old man from California, who recently had received his medical degree and was practicing at a hospital in Pennsylvania. He had ended a relationship with an unhinged woman, Shirley Turner, a doctor, 12 years his senior, twice divorced with a couple of children. She would not accept that the relationship was over. So, in 2001, she made an unannounced visit to Andrew in Pennsylvania. He immediately put her on a plane back to Council Bluffs, Iowa. Once home, she got into her car and drove 1600 miles back to Pennsylvania. The next morning Pennsylvania State Police responded to a call that a man was found shot to death in Derry Township State Park. The State Police named Shirley Turner as a person of interest because they discovered she owned the same type of gun that killed Andrew and she had been in Derry Township at the time of the murder. Shirley quickly left the US and returned to her home country Canada. Now, Exhibition papers to return her to the US to stand trial for Andrew's murder had to be filed.
Andrew's parents, Kathleen and David Bagby relocated to Newfoundland in Canada from California to be there while the expedition process proceeded. Andrew had went to medical school in St Johns where he met Shirley. Friends and family immediately noticed that Shirley was more interested in a relationship with Andrew than he was about her.
A news conference was held by Shirley to announce she was 4 months pregnant with Andrew's baby. Now there was not just the expedition to be concerned about, the Bagby's wanted to get custody of the baby, because once back in the US Shirley would be tried for murder, and they were the logical, loving and responsible choice to have custody of the baby. Andrew was an only child. As she appeared before Judge Walsh, it was evident the judge fawned over her. She asked Shirley if she promised not to cause any problems if Shirley was to be let out on bond. Incredibly, the Psychiatrist Shirley saw posted her $75,000 bond.
Once Zachary was born the relationship between Andrew's parents and Shirley was troubled. It was evident to everyone that Zachary preferred to be around Kathleen. The Bagby's consulted a lawyer who drew up an agreement between the parties regarding visitation so there would be mutual consent regarding visitations.
Andrew's closet friend since childhood, Kurt Kuenne, decided to film the ongoing events and, in addition to film he had accumulated of Andrew over the years, he planned on making a film he could give Zachary so he would get to know his father. Kurt did an outstanding job filming, producing, editing and directing the documentary. Zachary would not only get to know his dad, but Kurt traveled to England and met with Andrew's relatives (Andrew's mom was originally from England). Kurt also visited and filmed relatives in various states around the Country.
My heart aches for the Bagby's. In addition to the tragic loss of their beloved son, the drama increased significantly once the Justice system failed, miserably.
To review the documentary further would result in spoilers so I will stop. You will watch the finest documentary put together by loving friends and family.
0 out of 1 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends