One thing irks me about this movie: It does NOT accurately portray schizophrenia. I write as someone who grew up with a schizophrenic sibling, and I have studied the topic. I also have a schizoid friend.
1. The movie's character mostly has waking visual hallucinations (the storm, the birds) although keeps hearing thunder. Schizophrenics usually have no visual hallucinations, and their auditory hallucinations involve voices talking to them, or about them.
2. He has nightmares, but is still able to sleep a little every night. The movie focuses more on his nightmares. Active decompensated schizophrenics have long periods of mania and sleeplessness, even for days at a time.
3. He is able to function normally at his job until he's fired for using the company's equipment on a weekend (an error in judgment, not work performance). For most schizophrenics, the ability to hold down a job is one of the first thing to go.
4. Schizophrenics (especially paranoiacs) will not seek treatment or counseling, as a rule. They don't think there's anything wrong with them.
5. Positive: The character's obsession with the fixed idea of the coming Storm, and his compulsion to upgrade his storm shelter, is accurate with regard to the obsessive/compulsive and delusional aspects of schizophrenia. His irrational need for gas masks in the shelter (based on a single news story early in the movie) is also good.
6. Positive: The character is emotionally flat and distant in his conversations with others (except for his daughter, and his outburst after he's assaulted by a former friend). "Flat affect" is a common symptom of schizophrenia. Then again, maybe it was just bad acting...
Well, that's my two cents about the so-called schizophrenia in this movie. However, I was also disappointed with that stupid ending. It resolved nothing.
6 out of 17 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends