5/10
A great performance stuck in a subpar movie that plays like a daytime drama with awful music
8 February 2005
I'm a big Al Pacino fan. I bought "And Justice for All" because of the fact that it starred Pacino, and I was excited because I had heard he was nominated for a Best Actor Oscar. Now, after seeing the film, I can see why--his performance is great. Unfortunately, it's a great performance stuck in a lousy movie - "And Justice for All" is incompetently directed and, worst of all, the musical score really, really dates the film and almost makes it hard to watch at times.

The subplots - like Pacino taking a ride on the judge's helicopter and having it crash - are so '70s-ish that I felt as if I were watching an episode of "Starsky and Hutch" or something. Honestly, this movie plays like a cheesy '70s daytime drama with better actors.

Underneath the mess it has a good message about the legal profession. Pacino fans should see it because his performance is one of his best. However I find it hard to warm up to any movie that presents its courtroom scenes with a disco track playing in the background. If someone were to re-edit this film and insert more dramatic music (like a John Williams score or something), it might actually be watchable.

I've never seen music literally ruin a film before, as I have with "And Justice for All." As you watch it (if you should choose to), you might recognize the score - it's the same song you heard in the last elevator you rode in. Yeah, it's that bad. The composer should be shot.
10 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed