I've had this kicking around my house for a while (a gift) and finally got around to viewing it and was pleasantly surprised. I agree with many of the views, it isn't the most original story, world-weary outsider woos naive old-world woman. But it's done, in my opinion very well. The characters felt fresh and the direction the story took them was at times surprising. Emmy Rossum is a dream as the daughter and if this film is any indication will survive the debacle that was "The Phantom of the Opera."
Not having any real experience with Portugese culture, I didn't notice the apparent many mistakes/sloppiness. So, I guess if you're looking for authentic Portugese culture, you'll be disappointed. The emotions feel very authentic, however and the romance is engrossing.
It IS an excellent retelling of boy-meets-girl (well man-meets-woman), so if that's what you're looking for you'll enjoy it.
Oh and the cinematography is top-notch, Bedford, Mass looks sooooo gorgeous, I'm ready to vaca there soon.
Not having any real experience with Portugese culture, I didn't notice the apparent many mistakes/sloppiness. So, I guess if you're looking for authentic Portugese culture, you'll be disappointed. The emotions feel very authentic, however and the romance is engrossing.
It IS an excellent retelling of boy-meets-girl (well man-meets-woman), so if that's what you're looking for you'll enjoy it.
Oh and the cinematography is top-notch, Bedford, Mass looks sooooo gorgeous, I'm ready to vaca there soon.