7/10
given when it was made, a good and effective film
21 May 2006
You really can't compare many of the full-length films of the 20s to today's films. This isn't just because they were silent films but because the styles were so different. Compared to a modern film, this early Greta Garbo film is way too rushed--being completed in only 61 minutes when it would have been drawn out to at least 90 minutes or more today to tell the same story. However, one thing isn't so different between this film and today's--the acting and movie itself is amazingly subtle and restrained for the 20s. Most dramas from that era, frankly, try too hard and lack subtlety--but not this one. Even seen today, it's still a pretty good film. And, compared to the rather gaunt and extremely manicured and coiffed Garbo of the late 20s and 30s, she is quite beautiful and real--I really wish Hollywood had kept her that way.

The story itself reminds me of THE LAST LAUGH, another German film made at about the same time. Both focus on the struggle of the common people in the German-speaking world following WWI--as there is great poverty and disparity between the HAVES and HAVE NOTS. Both films are meant as social criticism and agents of change. And, both are amazingly well-done (though a better film, THE LAST LAUGH does have a rather poor ending), so my advice is see both.
6 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed