6/10
Too pretentious!
23 August 2007
Warning: Spoilers
I truly had high hopes with this film, but it turned out to be one of the biggest disappointments ever.

Its visual style tries desperate to imitate "Amores Perros" but it fails. Its director has so much to give, and I expect to watch his next film, because I think he has potential.

So why do I give it a 6/10 when it's pure garbage? Mainly because of the acting, which is great, specially Diego Luna. I also kind of liked cinematography and film editing. And yet, the screenplay is awful, full of corny lines, pretentious and empty, vacuum. What did it tried to tell us?

You never get to know many things, like motivations. It tries so hard to give a message that it gets lost trying, it loses strength. Another treatment of the same story might resulted in a masterpiece, since its main theme (loneliness and the search for one self) is a great issue.

Plus, it is full of unjustified nudity and sex, (***Spoiler***) like scene with Diego Luna and Camila Sodi when all of sudden she begin to undress, I mean, the woman is gorgeous but what was the point of that scene?

Finally, I must accept I prefer this film over some other Mexican films, it might worth watching, but I wouldn't recommend it.
13 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed