This short is another in the endless variations of the "wandering into the house of a mad scientist" comedy set up. This time the innocent victims are Thelma Todd and Patsy Kelly in a Hal Roach production directed by Charley Chase's brother, James Parrott. There is nothing here that hasn't been done better by Laurel and Hardy, Abbott and Costello, and the Three Stooges. James Parrott keeps the action fast and furious, but the short is completely forgettable. Character actor Clarence Wilson plays the mad scientist; he is completely over the top and is neither funny nor scary. Wilson creates a robot that adds nothing to the comedy. Matthew Betz is thrown into the mix as an escaped convict to put some twists into this whole mess, but his presence leads to nothing. There is some typical slapstick, which is competently executed. It could have been helped by the inclusion of that famous LeRoy Shield background music which kept many Roach shorts moving. However, there is no music at all. What a shame!
Review of The Tin Man
