I just finished watching this film, and, on the whole I liked it. I liked the story, I liked the protagonists, I liked the issues and the point of view, for the most part.
But what I found disappointing was that this was supposed to be a comedy, and in that regard, I think it is largely a failure. I just didn't find it funny. I had a couple chuckles during the film, but not many, and no serious laughs. I am rather rankled that my Leonard Maltin book described it as "hilarious"; it was most assuredly not.
Judy Holliday's performance was fine, but I am in agreement with those who would've given the Oscar to someone else that year. I'd have to go with Swanson and Sunset Blvd.
So, all in all, a good film, but don't set your expectations too high.
But what I found disappointing was that this was supposed to be a comedy, and in that regard, I think it is largely a failure. I just didn't find it funny. I had a couple chuckles during the film, but not many, and no serious laughs. I am rather rankled that my Leonard Maltin book described it as "hilarious"; it was most assuredly not.
Judy Holliday's performance was fine, but I am in agreement with those who would've given the Oscar to someone else that year. I'd have to go with Swanson and Sunset Blvd.
So, all in all, a good film, but don't set your expectations too high.