6/10
Peck good.--but Shoulda hired Brit James Mason for lead. Why blow $ on fancy Brit courtroom n then hire American lead???
7 July 2010
Warning: Spoilers
This movie is still fairly good...and still worth watching. But consider it (at best) a "double" instead of a home run.

And yes I like Gregory Peck---he is THE "Atticus Finch" etc. etc.

But British actor JAMES MASON - a MASTER at playing the Tormented Man - could have reacted much better to Alido Valli's "Mrs. Paradine"!!! She radiates such mystery. Is she innocent? Guilty? Or??? And Mason would have more "Gravitas" -as he was a Brit (clearly of upper class British origin) playing a British lawyer. He had one of the best speaking voices...Imagine the tense scenes between Mason and the wife---and Mason and the accused!!! And even Mason and the valet!!!Jourdan and Mason - would have been a better set of adversaries! No offense to Gregory Peck---but maybe the ACCOUNTANTS won this casting choice - as Peck was a big box office draw then.

I think that the two Hollywood 1947 "newbies" Valli - and Jourdan - are the two best actors in this film! Outshining even the great supporting cast!!!
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed