I really enjoyed Redford in this role. The lack of any back story has pluses and minuses. You never know why this guy is sailing (around the world?) solo. We never see him make any kind of personal action, like looking at a picture, talking to himself, etc. Tossing away a gift card is the extent of it. But you're certainly drawn into his world, to face the same uncertainties and fears he does. Our unfamiliarity with the situation mirrors his.
As other reviewers and commenters have noted, there's much to question about his seamanship. He's confident and able enough to solo in the middle of the Indian Ocean, but commits several foolish actions like not securing the water. That the crash took out ALL his electronics is a little to convenient, but necessary itself for the story. The whole sextant/navigation makes no sense, particularly since he has no means of propulsion.
This may be the biggest problem. The Cal 39 sailboat has a diesel engine. This is never acknowledged. The damage would not have affected it. Only a REALLY good sailor would try to make this trip solo on sails alone.
That being said, if you enjoy sea or survival stories try this one. Redford makes the film, flaws and all.
As other reviewers and commenters have noted, there's much to question about his seamanship. He's confident and able enough to solo in the middle of the Indian Ocean, but commits several foolish actions like not securing the water. That the crash took out ALL his electronics is a little to convenient, but necessary itself for the story. The whole sextant/navigation makes no sense, particularly since he has no means of propulsion.
This may be the biggest problem. The Cal 39 sailboat has a diesel engine. This is never acknowledged. The damage would not have affected it. Only a REALLY good sailor would try to make this trip solo on sails alone.
That being said, if you enjoy sea or survival stories try this one. Redford makes the film, flaws and all.