7/10
Disappointing, but it has its moments!
7 November 2016
Warning: Spoilers
SYNOPSIS: Accused and then acquitted of killing her husband, Doris Day tries to run a sheep farm, much to the amusement and/or dismay of the locals.

NOTES: Doris Day's fourth last movie. After this one she made Caprice (1967), Where Were You When the Lights Went Out? (1968) and With Six You Get Egg Roll (1968).

COMMENT: Doris Day's first western since Calamity Jane (1953) isn't half as bad as most critics (including Doris herself) make out. It not only boasts bright color and sets, but our Day looks quite attractive. The support cast is worthwhile too, featuring wonderfully scatty performances by Andy Devine, William Talman, Paul Fix and John Fiedler (as a nervous storekeeper). One of the funniest touches is provided by the uncredited cafe proprietor whose eyes roll delightfully every time Miss Day moves from one accident to another in what is undoubtedly the film's best scene. A pity director Andrew V. McLaglen's control of the rest of the film is not as tight. George Kennedy is pretty well wasted, though he does figure in some exciting action highlights. Milton Krasner's color photography also impresses as a major asset.

One big disappointment, however, is that Doris herself doesn't sing a note, the warbling chores being handled by The Sun Set Group and Ronnie Dante. DeVol's excellent score, with its astute combination of familiar folk airs, would seem to provide some excellent opportunities for vocalizing, but this doesn't happen. Ronnie Dante does an excellent job with the pleasant title tune, but this was no doubt added after the movie was completed, as the song is not used at all once the credits roll by.

OTHER VIEWS: "Ballad of Josie" was nothing more than a second-rate television western. A terrible movie! —Doris Day.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed