7/10
Victory or Death.
3 June 2020
In 202 BC Publius Scipio inflicted a devastating defeat on Hannibal at Zama. This triumph has been used in this flagrantly propogandist film to justify Mussolini's invasion of Abyssinia. This expensively made 'epic' was not a success and we can safely assume that its influence on the average Italian cinema-goer was minimal.

Despite its jingoistic speeches and upraised Roman salutes this film, purely as a film, should not be entirely dismissed as there are some very effective scenes with marvellous images captured by cinematographers Ubaldo Urata and Anchise Brizzi. The score is by Ildebrando Pizzetti who contributed to the original score for Pastrone's 'Cabiria' in 1914!

Director Carmine Gallone's film career stretched from 1913 to 1962 and he keeps the momentum going here with powerful crowd scenes and some intimate dialogues involving Hannibal, Velia and Sophonisba. In fact Gallone's best directed scenes feature the tantalising Francesca Braggiotti as Sophonisba. This actress did very few films and when her husband John Lodge did the acting profession a great service by going into politics she became the First Lady of Connecticut. Our loss. Velia as played by luscious Isa Miranda is nobility incarnate and defiantly declares to Hannibal: 'Romans fear only the Gods'. If the character of Scipio is meant to mirror that of Il Duce it is very much an 'own goal' as the actor Annibale Ninchi is totally devoid of charisma. Ironically it is the character of Hannibal as played by Camillo Pilotti who is by far the most interesting and sympathetic. This cannot have been intentional surely?!

The last fifteen minutes is devoted to the Battle of Zama which depicts the gruesome brutality of hand-to-hand combat. The battle opens with the charge of Hannibal's trumpeting elephants. Should any animal rights activists be watching I would strongly recommend they take an opportunity at this point to make a cup of tea. As one critic has cleverly observed: 'What Scipio did to the elephants, Mussolini was to do to Italy!
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed