It is not a bad game, but this game is very clunky, some pretty bad camera, and it just isn't really fun to play honestly. There is also surprisingly a ton of backtracking, as well as the game being so dark at time you literally cannot see what you are doing. James is actually a horrible human being, and you can't relate to this guy at all. Once you figure out what he is about, he is not of an antagonist than protagonist.
Silent Hill 1 is better because it had a nice mystery to it and there really isn't that much backtracking in my opinion. It also has a better protagonist. Harry is a great character.
Silent Hill 3 is better because the graphics are amazing, the combat is actually realy nice, and the story is great.
Silent Hill 4 is just plain awesome.
7/10
Silent Hill 1 is better because it had a nice mystery to it and there really isn't that much backtracking in my opinion. It also has a better protagonist. Harry is a great character.
Silent Hill 3 is better because the graphics are amazing, the combat is actually realy nice, and the story is great.
Silent Hill 4 is just plain awesome.
7/10