Ok the reviews here are all over the place, people who love the original Trek giving it high marks for 'staying true..' while others giving low marks because of poor production values.
But lets be honest here, you have to review the ENTIRE movie, not just whether its 'Trek' or not and whether its 'production value' is good or not. It all ads up. Honestly, would anyone give the "Empire Strikes Back" a 10 if the music was to "Henry Mancini's - Baby Elephant Walk"? Probably not.
So lets break it down:
Acting: Not bad considering I have seen worse acting from supposed "A" list movies. Most of the actors had experience and they did fine but lets try to remember not to give a speaking part to your buddy 'Ralph' who shows up on the set to wish you luck. Maybe a silent role in the background. A good 6
Plot/Scrip: Again, you have to weight this against everything that came before, I honestly believe this script was better than most of the Abrams movies, could it have been better, sure. At least the script didn't ruin the movie. Not to bad for a 'fan' made film. Solid 6
Special Visual Effects: Considering the quality of the 'Fan made' stuff out there, this was a big MISS. I mean, there are SOOOO sooo many people out there who could have helped you do this so much better and would not have charged you a dime. The Ships looked like 1980s CGI and the Phazer effects look worse than classic Doctor Who. You are lucky I gave you a 3
Costume and makeup: I am going to lump this into one to save on time, the Uniforms were nice but not tailor made for each actor and it showed. Everyone looked a bit frumpy. Make up was solid, though the Tellerite make up made me wince, and the Alien intruders costumes were laughable. Solid 3
Now lets address the monkey in the room. I am going to put Sound and Editing into one last category because I have NO idea how and where they screwed up the sound so badly that it could not be fixed in post, but I have friends who have IMBD pages that work for Independent films that could have helped fix some of the problems. I am NOT in the industry, though I am a member of IATSE and have worked as an audio engineer for 30 years, and if they hired an audio tech with only 5 years experience, they could have had better sound out of this movie. I feel like MOST of the problem was in post, the editing of the music would often drown out the actors speaches, or inversely over drive the audio and make ones ears burst because you had to turn the volume up to hear what they were saying. So sound and editing gets a nice fat 1!
Now I am going to add a bonus because this IS a fan made project and I fully understand the logistics and effort they gave to making this a reality. 5 points
All in all it is far from the BEST fan film of TOS I have ever seen but FAR from the worst. I am glad I spent the time watching it and know that I gave this a higher rating than any Abramstrekabomination.
Yes, I am a Trekie, Yes I am old, Yes Kirk over Pikard as he is the total package and Pikard needed Ryker to be equal to Kirk.
But lets be honest here, you have to review the ENTIRE movie, not just whether its 'Trek' or not and whether its 'production value' is good or not. It all ads up. Honestly, would anyone give the "Empire Strikes Back" a 10 if the music was to "Henry Mancini's - Baby Elephant Walk"? Probably not.
So lets break it down:
Acting: Not bad considering I have seen worse acting from supposed "A" list movies. Most of the actors had experience and they did fine but lets try to remember not to give a speaking part to your buddy 'Ralph' who shows up on the set to wish you luck. Maybe a silent role in the background. A good 6
Plot/Scrip: Again, you have to weight this against everything that came before, I honestly believe this script was better than most of the Abrams movies, could it have been better, sure. At least the script didn't ruin the movie. Not to bad for a 'fan' made film. Solid 6
Special Visual Effects: Considering the quality of the 'Fan made' stuff out there, this was a big MISS. I mean, there are SOOOO sooo many people out there who could have helped you do this so much better and would not have charged you a dime. The Ships looked like 1980s CGI and the Phazer effects look worse than classic Doctor Who. You are lucky I gave you a 3
Costume and makeup: I am going to lump this into one to save on time, the Uniforms were nice but not tailor made for each actor and it showed. Everyone looked a bit frumpy. Make up was solid, though the Tellerite make up made me wince, and the Alien intruders costumes were laughable. Solid 3
Now lets address the monkey in the room. I am going to put Sound and Editing into one last category because I have NO idea how and where they screwed up the sound so badly that it could not be fixed in post, but I have friends who have IMBD pages that work for Independent films that could have helped fix some of the problems. I am NOT in the industry, though I am a member of IATSE and have worked as an audio engineer for 30 years, and if they hired an audio tech with only 5 years experience, they could have had better sound out of this movie. I feel like MOST of the problem was in post, the editing of the music would often drown out the actors speaches, or inversely over drive the audio and make ones ears burst because you had to turn the volume up to hear what they were saying. So sound and editing gets a nice fat 1!
Now I am going to add a bonus because this IS a fan made project and I fully understand the logistics and effort they gave to making this a reality. 5 points
All in all it is far from the BEST fan film of TOS I have ever seen but FAR from the worst. I am glad I spent the time watching it and know that I gave this a higher rating than any Abramstrekabomination.
Yes, I am a Trekie, Yes I am old, Yes Kirk over Pikard as he is the total package and Pikard needed Ryker to be equal to Kirk.