I'd say the positive reviews are from people who either never endured LOST or actually liked it. This is a reboot. Obviously they are dead in some kind of purgatory. You can't make this show work. It can't exist in the real world we know at all. Electricity, mail, food, etc. LOST was made an episode at a time and was so nonsensical. Darma? The numbers? It just serves no purpose. This show is the same. No logic applies. If you are looking for a weird drama that goes nowhere, this is the show for you. I am a fan of all genres of TV and movies but i can't make a copy of LOST work in 2023. The music, characters, non logical stuff is a direct copy.