"The Edgar Wallace Mystery Theatre" To Have and to Hold (TV Episode 1963) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Not the best Edgar Wallace, but still well above the quality we normally associate with second features.
jamesraeburn200312 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Sgt Fraser (Ray Barrett) is sent to protect the glamouress Claudia Matthews (Katherine Blake) who has been getting telephone death threats. He falls in love with her, but when he returns to her flat he is surprised to be answered at the door by his inspector (William Hartnell) who informs him that she has been murdered. Fraser is convinced that her husband, the businessman George Matthews (Nigel Stock), is the killer. However, Inspector Roberts takes him off the case due to his emotional attachment to it and makes him take leave. This does not stop Fraser from carrying out his own unofficial investigation, which takes him to Bournemouth where Matthews has a holiday home. Here, he meets Claudia's identitcal twin Pauline who agrees to help him prove Matthews' guilt as she too believes he is the murderer. Fraser soon finds himself falling for her and, so it seems, vice versa, but it isn't long before she reveals to him that she is really Claudia. In addition, she tells him that Matthews murdered his wife then hid her body in his flat and went away to establish an alibi. Later, Claudia informed the police anonymously before joining him in Bournemouth. She then says that they were lovers, but she now loves Fraser and agrees to his plan to murder Matthews. First, he takes out an insurance policy in Matthews name before arranging a fake road accident. The plan is that Claudia will collect the money before the pair disappear and start a new life together in Australia. However, the niave young policeman is soon to get a nasty surprise...

Although it is not one of the best Edgar Wallace mysteries, it is still well above the quality we would normally associate with British 'B' features and rubbishes the long held view that this area of film making could not deliver worthy results.

Anybody seeing the Edgar Wallace films for the first time more than fifty years after they first did the rounds in cinemas will be struck by the number of talented directors they brought to the table. This one was directed by Herbert Wise who sustains the intrigue and suspense remarkably well for most of the time.

The screenplay by John Sansom (a pseudonym for Hammer writer/producer/director Jimmy Sangster) is packed with red herrings and plot twists galore that are guaranteed to keep you on the edge of your seat throughout as you try to figure out how the femme fatale Claudia will lead the niave young police sergeant into hot water. It leads us up many paths before changing direction entirely. Is Claudia, for example, really a victim of threatening phone calls from a former lover? Or, could she and this ex-lover really still be in love and are creating a smokescreen to divert attention away from a plot to kill her husband? Alternatively, did Claudia and George bump off her twin sister to create the impression that she is dead for them to be able to commit an insurance fraud? They are the kind of questions that you will be undoubtedly be asking yourself as the movie unfolds.

So why isn't it the best, then? Well, I felt that it held its grip really well for about 90% of the time, but by the time it got to the climax I felt it drifted towards predictability as the plot panned out the way I thought it would by then after all the red herrings and plot twists had gone. Up until that point, it threw me off the scent entirely and I was expecting Mr Sangster to have had one final ace up his sleeve and take me by surprise. But he didn't. I also felt that the performances from the leads were not quite strong enough to bring out the emotions and passions that a couple in their predicament would have felt. There was, however, stirling support from a supporting cast of familiar British faces including Nigel Stock, William Hartnell and Noel Trevarthen and the production values were top notch for a 'B' movie with Bert Mason's classy b/w camerawork making full use of the Bournemouth setting heightenning the tension and creating a real sense of place as if you felt you were actually there.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Enough intrigue to make this one interesting.
Sleepin_Dragon13 April 2023
Sergeant Fraser is tasked with protecting Claudia Matthews, who's received several death threats. He falls for her, but isn't able to save her life as she's killed, her husband George Matthews is The Prime Suspect, but Fraser is taken off the case.

It's a very pleasing mystery, I'm not sure it's my favourite entry, but it's definitely a worthy entry in the series.

It's a super stylish looking production, it's packed with atmosphere, it definitely has enough intrigue and suspense to keep you engaged.

Maybe the twin element was a bit of an overused plot device, but I'll give it the benefit of the doubt in this instance, it did actually work quite well. Katherine Blake did a fine job in making the sisters feel very different to one another, they looked and felt different.

Ray Barrett was very good I thought, a charismatic actor, I really enjoyed William Hartnell too, this is around the time that he had his first stint in The TARDIS, interesting to see him in this stage of his career without that wig on.

7/10.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Katherine Blake - A bloody good looking woman
howardmorley26 September 2015
Katherine Blake - I could not take my eyes off this dark raven haired beauty and readers of my reviews will have noticed I am attracted to this type of actress, viz:Jennifer Jones,Gene Tierney, Vivien Leigh, Ava Gardner, Jean Simmons etc.It may be they all have wonderfully sculpted faces with incredible cheekbones but I do like this dark Latin type of look.The previous reviewer has done a good job so I don't see the point of reiterating the plot.In my case I thought "Double Indemnity" was a closer fit rather than "Laura" both from (1944).

In my review of the first episode of "Riviera Police" (1965) which was "Catch a Falling Star".I believe Katherine Blake appeared along with another siren one Christa Nelli as she was dubbed then.The subject film had a very un-pockmarked face of Ray Barrett who would later achieve fame in the TV series "The Troubleshooters" when he looked then as if a swarm of locusts had attacked his face.Perhaps that was in his native Australia.My User rating? 7/10, it was good and held my interest to the last reel.
6 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
To Have and to Hold
Prismark1015 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Detective Fraser (Ray Barrett) is sent by his dour boss Inspector Roberts (William Hartnell) to keep a watch on Claudia Matthews (Katherine Blake) who has had threatening phone calls.

Fraser falls for Claudia but it is short relationship. She is killed and Fraser suspects her husband George Matthews (Nigel Stock) but he has an alibi.

Although pulled off the case, Fraser still sniffs around Matthews but is later shocked to discover that Claudia had a twin sister.

He also decides to do something about Matthews and takes an insurance policy out on Matthews name.

Based on an Edgar Wallace story, this dramatisation has plenty of nods to Double Indemnity.

Unfortunately this plods along. It should had been shorter, sharper and more noir.

Katherine Blake is appealing twice over but I kept thinking that Fraser is not much of a cop.

This would had been Hartnell's last role before he became Doctor Who.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed