Max Learns to Skate (1907) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
An important film but not an especially funny one.
planktonrules9 January 2012
Max goes ice skating. Although he appears confident, he has no idea what he's doing and is a complete menace on the ice--knocking folks down as he tries, in vain, to skate.

According to IMDb, this is the first Max Linder film where he appears as his rich dandy--a character he perfected and played for years--much like Chaplin's 'little tramp'. Unfortunately, while this makes it an important film, it doesn't mean it's all that funny. It's a very simple setup and not much more than that--though it is nice that they actually filmed it outdoors during winter. However, just watching Linder fall and knock others down isn't funny when seen today--though perhaps audiences were less demanding in 1907 and thought this was hot stuff. After all, he DID go on to make several hundred films!
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Ice frolics still fun!
Gblakelii12 December 2005
Warning: Spoilers
No doubt many articles on Max Linder start out with his being source material for Charlie Chaplin, so it would be redundant to continue along those lines. Watching this short French film is watching a true master at work. From facial expressions(including some rare close-ups for this time period) and physical contortions, Linder does it all. This movie is really a one man show, and very much worth the price of admission. The true test of course, can it still make kids of the 21st century laugh, and the answer is a resounding yes! In this humorous exercise in ice skating, Linder conveys many emotions throughout, from frustration, elation and revenge. Most of the time he is the butt of the jokes, but when others are knocked about because of his ineptness we laugh at them as well, with our main character(appearing to be the big bully)soon to be punished by the "tough kids" among the crowd. Then how sorry we feel when Max is rebuked for his exuberance. But that's what makes "Max Learns to Skate" so beloved. The character is real, one whom we can truly associate with.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Frequently hilarious
JoeytheBrit9 November 2009
I've only seen a few of early French comedian Max Linder's films - and one of them was more a fantasy than a comedy - but what I've seen of him so far is extremely funny. As the other reviewer to date on this film has mentioned, most articles compare Linder with his most famous fan, Charlie Chaplin, but as you watch this sometimes hilarious farce, you can see Chaplin mimicking - and, to be fair, often improving upon - Linder's actions here. Given how early this film was made, Linder can considered to be a genuine comic trailblazer: nobody else had committed such naturally funny moves to celluloid as this funny Frenchman. Be sure to give this one a viewing if you get the chance.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Star Is Born
springfieldrental28 December 2020
There's some debate of who truly was the first star in movies. Early film studios wanted to depress their actors' salaries by not promoting them. But French actor Max Linder is cited by most as cinema's first int'l star because of his reoccurring Max character, a dapper, rich guy always getting into jams because of his womanizing and his pompous attitude. As the Max persona was repeatedly seen, so was his popularity. The 1st Max film was 1907 "The Skater's Debut." The director of this film, Louis Gasnier, saw Lake Daumesnil in Paris frozen over and thought the ice would be a good backdrop for Linder's physical comedy. Dressed up in his soon-to-be trademark attire, Linder improvised all his stunts on ice skates. You can see the influence Linder had on Charlie Chaplin just in this 5-minute film, as seen here by Max's whirlwind skating legs, which is reminiscent of The Tramp's "The Rink" made 9 years later. Both were good friends during Chaplin's early screen days.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed