This third feature by director Flora Gomes of the African country of Guinea Bissau is a bit disappointing after his previous film, the stunning Po di Sangui, but this musical comedy about the success in Paris of a young black women singer from the island of Cape Verde is quite charming, if a bit amateurish at parts. The starring actress can't be faulted, the songs are good if not particularly memorable but the often silly dialogue and story are the main culprits here, I think. Still, for those interested in seeing a different sort of film (far away from the dull, artier African films often seen at film festivals) this is a movie I can readily recommend. (By the way, the director, despite his name, is a man).
3 Reviews
Worse than amateur, destroying the essence of what a movie is meant to be
nathalie-karouni2 November 2010
Warning: Spoilers
A part from the huge amount of goofs regarding the camera angles and repeated plans, this movie shouldn't have turned into a movie.
It's too simple, amateur, fake, stereotyped, with bad and unmotivated actors (well, who can be motivated for such a thing?) and a scenario with a huge lack of real conflicts, with a humble dumb lazy conventional ending coming from nowhere.
The only thing that fulfills a bit the view is all the colors and some music is not bad. Even the 5 minutes in the beginning promess much more than the rest. Why all this beginning with her ex lover following her all around while herself is not really going anywhere until she arrives to Paris. She gets into a church, everyone sings, she leaves them. She looks for her brother, she finds him, the speak a bit, she leaves. She promesses to her mother she won't sing because it's a malediction for women in her family(the movie turns into a weird fiction children argument). But after 1 week in Paris, or maybe a year (no one knows) she sings and becomes famous so easy and quick, she's so glad to announce it to her mother when she comes back in Africa!
Anyway, no point in waisting my time flustering more this "movie", no point for you in waisting your time watching it.
It's too simple, amateur, fake, stereotyped, with bad and unmotivated actors (well, who can be motivated for such a thing?) and a scenario with a huge lack of real conflicts, with a humble dumb lazy conventional ending coming from nowhere.
The only thing that fulfills a bit the view is all the colors and some music is not bad. Even the 5 minutes in the beginning promess much more than the rest. Why all this beginning with her ex lover following her all around while herself is not really going anywhere until she arrives to Paris. She gets into a church, everyone sings, she leaves them. She looks for her brother, she finds him, the speak a bit, she leaves. She promesses to her mother she won't sing because it's a malediction for women in her family(the movie turns into a weird fiction children argument). But after 1 week in Paris, or maybe a year (no one knows) she sings and becomes famous so easy and quick, she's so glad to announce it to her mother when she comes back in Africa!
Anyway, no point in waisting my time flustering more this "movie", no point for you in waisting your time watching it.
They say that "the end is the beginning"!
stuka241 January 2010
I loved this movie, rocked my head with the superb music, and even learnt quite a few things about Africa. Besides having the hell of a good time.
Let this be clear: I'm not African, don't know anything about the continent, neither do I have any link with musicians. Thus, I feel I can be objective.
This joyous film about life in Africa (not exactly a happy topic) is the best musical fable I could conceive.
Fatou N'Diaye is ravishing, dances and sings very well. All the African cast is joyous and natural when dancing, and of course their in sync choreography transmit they are enjoying themselves. The contrast with the brief time in France is horrible: the French sing, dance and move awkwardly, everything seems staged, and without any grace to boot. Coming back to Cape Vert: The beautiful wooden painted coffins with shapes of Mercedes, a huge fish, a lion or a pink butterfly are beautiful, and show us their different conception of death. How traditional religions live with animism is also talked about without telling us what to think, just "a fact of life". The guys who go to funerals to eat, brag about how they knew the deceased and even the one who drops the fact "they owed him money" are a welcome comic relief. Like everything done in the movie, "part of life". So is colonialism, her mother having worked for them in the house they now live in, etc. On a more intellectual level, the "message" of the film is very uplifting and clear: you can live with your traditional values and also grow out of them. Vita makes the only possible choice, a very creative one, for getting hold of her life. The hard facts of life in an underdeveloped, poor country are not eschewed. The chorus sings: "Everybody who goes abroad never comes back", "You won't be hungry anymore" and "Here a College degree is worth nothing". This film is of special interest for those of us who were born in a poorer country that the one they long for. You can come back to your roots and help a little bit, without complaining, and even make peace with your former couples :). Their Portuguese is hard to twig at first, at least if one's accustomed to Brazilian one, like us Latin Americans. But once we do, it' even musical. The way everybody, rich and poor, old and young, fat and slim, eat, dance and sing, reminded me of Brazil, another country with stark social contrast and with a "joie de vivre" unthinkable of basically anywhere else. She becoming "the owner of death" is another bonus of this film, like the phrase that I quoted on this IMDb summary.
Enjoy this movie, you won't regret it. Great for watching on a 1st of January, or when you need to feel you can renew your life.
Let this be clear: I'm not African, don't know anything about the continent, neither do I have any link with musicians. Thus, I feel I can be objective.
This joyous film about life in Africa (not exactly a happy topic) is the best musical fable I could conceive.
Fatou N'Diaye is ravishing, dances and sings very well. All the African cast is joyous and natural when dancing, and of course their in sync choreography transmit they are enjoying themselves. The contrast with the brief time in France is horrible: the French sing, dance and move awkwardly, everything seems staged, and without any grace to boot. Coming back to Cape Vert: The beautiful wooden painted coffins with shapes of Mercedes, a huge fish, a lion or a pink butterfly are beautiful, and show us their different conception of death. How traditional religions live with animism is also talked about without telling us what to think, just "a fact of life". The guys who go to funerals to eat, brag about how they knew the deceased and even the one who drops the fact "they owed him money" are a welcome comic relief. Like everything done in the movie, "part of life". So is colonialism, her mother having worked for them in the house they now live in, etc. On a more intellectual level, the "message" of the film is very uplifting and clear: you can live with your traditional values and also grow out of them. Vita makes the only possible choice, a very creative one, for getting hold of her life. The hard facts of life in an underdeveloped, poor country are not eschewed. The chorus sings: "Everybody who goes abroad never comes back", "You won't be hungry anymore" and "Here a College degree is worth nothing". This film is of special interest for those of us who were born in a poorer country that the one they long for. You can come back to your roots and help a little bit, without complaining, and even make peace with your former couples :). Their Portuguese is hard to twig at first, at least if one's accustomed to Brazilian one, like us Latin Americans. But once we do, it' even musical. The way everybody, rich and poor, old and young, fat and slim, eat, dance and sing, reminded me of Brazil, another country with stark social contrast and with a "joie de vivre" unthinkable of basically anywhere else. She becoming "the owner of death" is another bonus of this film, like the phrase that I quoted on this IMDb summary.
Enjoy this movie, you won't regret it. Great for watching on a 1st of January, or when you need to feel you can renew your life.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
