Les mots bleus (2005) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
I will tell her the blue words, the ones you tell with your eyes
dbdumonteil8 April 2007
Alain Corneau has been occupying a steady surge in French cinema for more than thirty years now. Topnotch thrillers like "Police Python 357" (1976), "Série Noire" (1979), ambitious works with "Nocturne Indien" (1989) or "Stupeur et Tremblements" (2003) reveal his strong ability at film-making. "Le Prince Du Pacifique" (2000), unworthy of his directing skills is perhaps the nadir of his career.

"Stupeur et Tremblements" which was a triumph when it reached the streets signaled a new direction in Corneau's work. In this intimate film, a young woman (Sylvie Testud) was the main character and before he shot his work, stories of men were the filmmaker's specialty. "Les Mots Bleus" is an extension of Corneau's new direction in his career with once again a young woman as the main role. It was the opportunity for Corneau to work again with Testud after their fruitful alliance for "Stupeur et Tremblements" and also to deepen his set of themes partly revolving on communication.

Three characters are at the core of "Les Mots Bleus". Clara (Sylvie Testud), a mercurial, neurotic mother who after she saw her grandmother died before her eyes stopped to read and is afraid of words. Her daughter Anna who is deliberately dumb. To try to cure her, her mother takes her to an institution for dumb an deaf children run by Vincent (Sergi Lopez), a manager who behind his solid look reveals zones of fragility and is unable to have a lasting relation with a woman. The school methods bear fruit for little Anna who gains trust in herself although she still refuses to talk to Clara's disappointment. The latter is smitten with Vincent but is afraid to love her.

Relationships the three characters weave between them partly constitute the film's attraction. Of the threesome, Anna is perhaps the more mature one; Clara and Vincent in a way act like children. The former dreads words and can't face the world that surrounds her while the latter in his course amuses the children by aping animals (in one sequence he apes a gorilla). He's also unable to link a love affair with a woman. Bit by bit, they will become easier to get on with each other. Scenery is also a vital element, notably the shed on the beach, a refugee for comforting childhood memories or the institution, a refugee for deaf and dumb children who through drawings let express what's going on in their souls. Like in Jean-Pierre Sinapi's "Nationale 7" (2000) which took place in an institution too (for disabled people), the choice of a DV camera for the sequences in the institution give the film a documentary approach and a blue-tinted cinematography serves Corneau's ideas. All in all, the real subject of the film is Clara and her reluctance to discover words and love again.

"Les Mots Bleus" didn't have as much impact as its predecessor and its somewhat formulaic, slick master plan clouds its scale of masterwork in Corneau's filmography although there's nothing mawkish here. Corneau's fans may want to watch it but it's not a film to which you would want to return.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
interesting subject
copenhagen_buzz3 August 2005
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this film at the Berlinale in February 2005. It was in competition but got no prizes I think. The film is based upon a book about a little girl who has stopped speaking, since she feels that words can't tell the truth. Her mother sends her to a school for deaf children where she learns sign language and is happy. Very touching, but the main story is somewhat distracted by a side-story about the mothers romantic relations with the teacher, taking away some of the attention from the very interesting subject about words and how it is impossible not to lie etc. Although the ending could have been more tragic than it was, I couldn't hold back my tears.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
very touching film
sansay29 September 2007
I watched Les Mots Bleus last night. I felt very much taken at times by the emotions triggered by a very intimate film making. Alain Corneau takes you very close to the characters and their feelings. And the acting is so perfectly nuanced, so delicate, and therefore closer to the truth. This is one quality that is extremely important in psychological movies such as this one. Sylvie Testud reminded me of Isabelle Huppert in La Dentellière. Same very sensitive acting. And it's interesting that I recently saw Stupeur et Tremblement, by the same director, and they are very different movies, something I really appreciate in a director, this ability to explore totally different type of story and in very different ways. Sergi López is also a great actor. He is so convincing, the way he delivers his father's story at the restaurant... it gave me goosebumps. And of course, let's not forget Anna, the center piece of the whole movie, beautifully interpreted by beautiful Camille Gauthier with this fascinating stare of hers... ouafff! Great acting, great movie making, go ahead, see it, it's definitely worth your time.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A haunting story atypical of French cinema; a gem
leoneangelica13 October 2005
This film floored me. I sobbed throughout. There was something incredibly raw about it which triggered emotions inside which no other film has done. I caught this film at the cinema in France last year, and I can imagine that watching it depending on English subtitles to convey its sentiment would detract from your experience. The three main characters (the single mother of irrational, overblown emotions, the questionably mute daughter and her dedicated teacher) are confused and insecure, their haunting pasts preventing them from living fully. They don't fit in anywhere, but may fit in with each other.

For those of us who deal with characters like these, or ARE characters like these in everyday life, this film strikes a familiar chord which resonates deeply within and breaks up the balled-up frustration and sadness which resides deep within the psyche. The style of the cinematography and the lack of music combined with the excellent performances and script make this story and these people feel very real. To blow off the relationship which develops between the mother and the teacher as extraneous or unnecessary to the plot is a mistake; the high emotions ARE the plot and are expressed most effectively. Les Mots Bleus is a tearjerker in the purest sense of the word. Don't read into it or analyze it too much; let your emotions be controlled.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Lost For Words
writers_reign1 April 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Alain Corneau is one of the best and most versatile of present day French directors and his CV includes some excellent polars - three with Yves Montand - plus the 'costume' picture Tous les matins du monde right up to his last film, also featuring Sylvie Testud, Stupeur et Tremblement which was shot entirely in Japanese. Testud is again excellent as Clara, who, as a young child loved to read to her grandmother until one day Grandmother died in the middle of a reading leaving Clara traumatised to the extent that she refused/declined to read and write thereafter. In the interim she has herself had a daughter, Anna (Camille Gauthier) who is mute and mother and daughter communicate by drawing. Into their world - though that is perhaps a wrong description since they are entering his - comes Vincent (Sergi Lopez) a gifted teacher who specialises in children like Anna. For the role Lopez is required to be charismatic so that children warm to him and respond to his teaching and Anna is no exception, and in this respect the film resembles similar elements in the wonderful German film Mostly Martha in which Sergio Castellitto had a similar effect though this time on Aunt and Niece rather than Mother and Daughter. Although most of us will see the inevitable love blossoming from initial hostility between Lopez and Testud Corneau doesn't hit us over the head with this and does devote the lion's share of screen time to the problems of Anna. This is the first film made by Camille Gauthier and she is excellent though possibly more due to a child's lack of inhibition than genuine acting ability and it will be interesting to see if she continues as an actress. Lopez is as reliable as usual and I can only thank Alain Corneau for his lingering close ups of Sylvie Testud who is not an obvious beauty like, in their own different ways, Manu Beart and Audrey Tautau but nevertheless IS beautiful given the right conditions. A charming and delightful film. 8 stars.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed