Ab-normal Beauty (2004) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
37 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Visually stunning, but to no effect
afdiazr23 January 2006
The Pang Brothers know their stuff when it comes to visual style. This movie is a proof. It's visually flawless. Beautiful photography, nice camera tricks, gorgeous looking leads and eerie atmospheres, but that's as far as it goes. Oh… And the sound is nicely done too. In some ways this film is like The Crow: City of Angels, an absolute feast for the eye, but it delivers no content to back it up. And it gets boring in some parts, since you don't really give too much about the characters. The so-called violent scenes at the end are a letdown –that's if you're looking for something truly disturbing. It's well done, and creepy in some parts. The killer's method was a great idea, with all the cameras and the sound of him approaching. I loved that. But at the end it's like if someone mixed Beverly Hills 90210 with Thesis (the Spanish flick). If that's your cup of tea, then this movie is for you.

Watch it on a nice home system. You will get it's full blow.
12 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Morbid, Bizarre and Fascinating Aesthetic
claudio_carvalho7 May 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Jiney (Race Wong) is a talented student of Arts with a trauma in her childhood and lack of communication with her mother, and excellent photographer that is not satisfied with her awarded works. When she witnesses a car crash, she is driven by a morbid wish and takes pictures of the dead victim. She becomes obsessed with death, and her close friend Jas (Rosanne Wong) feels that Jiney needs help with her abnormal behavior and attraction. When Jiney supersedes her death wish, she receives a snuff video where a girl is tortured and killed in front of the camera. Jiney shows the tape to Jas, who questions the authenticity of the footage, and they believe it is a prank of their friend Anson (Anson Leung). When the girls realize that it is not a joke of Anson, Jiney receives another tape with the message inviting her to take a look. When she sees the tape, she becomes scared with the sinister footage.

"Sei Mon Se Jun" is morbid and bizarre, but presents a fascinating aesthetic and an awesome cinematography and the style of Dario Argento. This gore and violent tale is stylish and dark, with magnificent use of colors prevailing red. Oxide Pong gives a homosexual connotation to the close relationship of Jiney and Jas, but it is never explicit. The childhood trauma of Jiney should have been previously disclosed and not in the last scene. Race Wong and Rosanne Wong are very beautiful actresses and the killer recalls Leatherface. I am a big fan of the Pang Brothers and I really liked this creepy film that in some moments looks like pictures at an exhibition. My vote is seven.

Title (Brazil): "Desejos Mortais" ("Deadly Desires")
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
An American take
dave-sturm20 September 2009
This is either brilliant Asian horror or total claptrap. I'm leaning toward the latter.

Hmm. I'm split. The first half is totally compelling as we watch a brilliant young Chinese lesbian art student veer off into a fascination with photographing death after witnessing a fatal traffic accident. She's obsessed with capturing the moment of death on her Nikon, be it chicken or fish or a suicide jumper from a tall building. We watch lovely young Jin as she follows her muse into dangerous places.

There may be a reason in her past for this obsession. Her lesbian partner is really worried about her. And -- whoa! -- now there's a boy in her life who has obviously fallen in love with her.

A lot of interesting elements have come into play. And the Pang brothers are brilliant cinematographers and editors. Sheer beauty on the screen. I cannot stress how magnificently this is filmed.

Then comes the last half hour. It is total gibberish. And it's filmed in such deep darkness you cannot see what's going on (I am talking about the DVD version). All you can tell is that it involves bondage and sadomasochism. A woman bound to a chair is screaming her lungs out. Someone unseen is tormenting her.

If some truth came out, I totally missed it. Maybe it's a western thing. I like Asian horror movies. But this left me baffled.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Race Wong is indeed beautiful.
fedor86 April 2007
Warning: Spoilers
The main female protagonist is indeed beautiful. And she is abnormal. Why don't more movie titles deliver what they promise? A gorgeous (though a little too skinny) lesbian art student finds out she is attracted by death, or to be more precise the moment of it. As her morbid fascination grows, we find out her psychological profile, i.e. why she is as screwed up as she is. The director sets up the stage for a female serial-killer.

However, there are almost two movies in this. The first half ends with her coming to terms with a traumatic episode from her childhood hence she leaves her perverse hobby behind her, and all seems to end happily. Obviously, no-one would fall for that one, 45 minutes being still left. Suddenly, the movie's serial-killer makes an entrance. Is it the guy who's in love with her? Is it maybe even her? The chicken-butcher (that was my guess)? Her mother even? No. The killer is the guy who sold her the books on death in the store. Was this convincing? Not really, but at least it was a surprise, for whatever it's worth. The scene in which she faces her tormentor in the torture chamber isn't very credible, either. On one hand, the killer has shown to be very capable and sly, and yet, in the dungeon he behaves as if he were a Leatherface-like retard straight out of "Texas Chainsaw Massacre".

Still, in spite of its flaws, the film isn't as superficial as many other horror films, the first half being more in the psychological horror vein, although the last third does fall into the "mainstream" sadistic-sicko genre. It's never boring, and the lead female is interesting – and beautiful. How is it Japanese/Chinese films nearly always have a great-looking woman in the lead, while American films are perpetually stuck with uglies/mediocrities like Julia Roberts, Julia Stiles, Drew Barrymore, La Lopez, or Jennifer Aniston?
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Crazyness...
chubbylove15 January 2007
A very weird tale about a lesbian girl, semi-losing her mind from a combination of past events, and her present preferences. She is an artist, with an emphasis on photography. She suddenly starts becoming obsessed with taking pictures of death.

Her friends don't really take that very well. They think it's psycho, and so do other people that you wouldn't really call her "friends"...

All in all a very good movie. If you're into Asian films, especially those with a chilling twist... This ones for you! The director portrayed losing your mind very well in my opinion, which I didn't really expect because the main character was very good looking. Making her lesbian made me think that it was going to try and make her looks sell the picture... I was very wrong. This film was written very well, and the character development was nothing short of amazing.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Abnormally Bad
danstewart2529 January 2006
It's very easy to write a bad review. Every hack reviewer gets the temptation when sitting through a boring film to just pack in the screening, go home and write 500 words of spiteful critical mass. It's easy.

But there are no words in the critical lexicon to convey the sheer, utter awfulness of this film. It's laughable. It's terrible. It's incredible that it got made.

Firstly you have the frankly quite masturbatory concept - clearly thought-up by a creepily lascivious film producer - of having the film's two leads as hot teenage lesbians. Immature voyeuristic fantasy, anyone? I'm guessing censorship issues denied Mr Producer the chance to get the sapphic activities of these two lovely ladies on film: if you're watching this film to get your kicks you'll be disappointed.

Hot lesbian #1 becomes obsessed with taking photos of dead animals. This plot strand takes up about an hour of the film, before it sinks into a dull rip-off of 8mm, Lost Highway, and Ringu. Hot lesbian #2 has little to do except stand around looking hot, and getting into sexy arguments. The shocks aren't shocking, and the gore isn't gory. If you're scared watching this, then you should steer well clear of Scooby Doo. Odd filters and silly jump editing do not a horror film make.

The ending is ridiculous, and you will certainly feel cheated if and when you suffer the misfortune of watching this film. I don't know what 'Oxide Pang' was thinking. Perhaps he was thinking 'i can't think of a proper ending... i'll just make it up as i go along'. Not that it matters much, because it's so badly edited and lit you can hardly see what happens anyway.

English-speaking viewers will be hampered by the ludicrously bad subtitles. At one point, a character asking (presumably)'why the long face' has her words translated as 'why are you so lengthy of countenance?'. Some lines aren't translated at all.

If this hyperactive, under-lit, overwrought and incomprehensible film is the new face of bold Asian horror cinema then I'm Jackie Chan. You will regret watching this. It is almost an hour and half of your life that you could do far better things with. Visit your grandmother. Cook your wife a meal. Just don't for God's sake watch Abnormal Beauty.
12 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Visually striking, slow burning and classy psychological horror
Bloodwank16 November 2011
Films about art and artists are of great interest to me, delvings into the relationship of image and imaginer, into the imagining itself and what change it wreaks on the two parties. Abnormal Beauty is then a film of interest to me and though it has little new or especially intelligent to say, it speaks with elegance and it speaks from the heart. Its central artist is the troubled Jin (Race Wong) who comes across a car crash and feels compelled to photograph it, in doing so reopening cracks of childhood trauma, widening them to deathly obsession, morbid sensuality and danger. Much of the film is dark psychological drama rather than horror, the whole visual scheme mirroring Jin's descent. Shots are still, sparsely composed and sometimes richly tinted, an imagery of bleak yearning, of the cameras power to make beauty from from death, to bring something from nothing and yet in the freezing of image eternally condemn, forever sequester from reality. All this perhaps the highlight of the film, its thoughts internalised speaking with so much more eloquence than the occasional fragments of exposition. Its powerfully acted stuff too, Race Wong subtly moving, quietly pained, she does well in suggesting character shadows. Her real life sister Rosanne plays (in a slightly perverse bit of casting), her girlfriend Jas, though the lesbian currents are pretty restrained. Another fine turn, possessive and emotionally fraught, the extrovert half of the two. Anson Leung is good too as a classmate of Jin innocently drawn to her. All cylinders fire pretty well it must be said, things reaching an emotional climax around two thirds of the way through as Jin heads towards her precipice. Then the film switches gears to head for real horror in its climax, a move that works thematically but not so much dramatically. Quite simply it's a lop sided film, what should be a thought out second half becomes a climax instead and ends up feeling more of an undernourished epilogue than the savage gut punch it aims for. In more general terms the film suffers from being somewhat restrained as well, some will no doubt praise its subtlety but the story is a bit too lurid for restraint to really work. There's too little actual threat, the menace being predictably largely of the mind, and too little pointed exploration, for a film too restrained to go mad it doesn't help itself by being intellectually undercooked. In a film so concerned with dark aesthetics and the break from normality there's comically little treatment of the related moral issues and the general psychological fall out follows standard plotting lines rather than great insight. Still, this is a pretty fine film despite its ills. Its a film to submit to and swim around in, to abandon oneself to the leads and drink in their sights, sorrow to their sorrows. Truth be told it was only after viewing that the films flaws started to fall into place, its such a well oiled beast (and more to the point, looks so goddarned pretty) that I was almost captivated for most of the run time. As such I recommend it if you like your Asian horror slow and artful, some I'm sure may like it more than me. But it certainly isn't the latter day underrated classic some have hailed it as. 7/10
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Disappointing film which never knows what it wants to be
f_jiff8 May 2006
From half of the two directional wizards behind 'The Eye' comes this half-finished piece of 'cinema'. The plot is intriguing, starting off well and progressing slowly as if leading up to a wonderous and haunting conclusion. The first two thirds of the film echo of Asian horror films such as Ringu, The Eye and Audition, but they're eclipsed by an ultimately ridiculous, Troma-esquire conclusion. The last part of the film lets it down; turning a suspenseful and disturbing story about morbid fascination into some poor attempt at ridiculously boring Hollywood horror/thrillers in the vein of Saw and Seven. The film never feels like anything beyond two half finished ideas stuck together without any form of cohesion.

Oxide Pang needs to get back with his brother! Go watch The Eye instead.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Beautiful, intriguing, but watch your nerves for the last 20 minutes.
fedtho19 February 2005
Only 2 comments as I'm writing this, and this movie definitely deserves better.

I saw it at a little horror festival in France in January.

This movie is about being lost when you're supposed to become an adult, being lost in the harsh, individualistic world we live in... (that sounds very common, but the movie isn't.) It also takes on voyeurism in a quite original way, even questions photography and "beauty"...

There is a perpetual and nameless menace surrounding the young girl we follow. She feels alone, misunderstood. But she's got strength and will and talent...

Her obsession with death will ultimately be an opportunity for her to face herself, although she really seems to loose it as the story unfolds.

I really find this movie appealing and quite outstanding, and I want to recommend it... ...but there is that finale!!! I can't talk about the ending without destroying what is certainly an intended impression...

*******************

but I feel this movie should warn audiences about its extreme violence.

*******************

That said, there are a lot of reasons to watch this if you have the opportunity.
36 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
pretty, but somewhat uneven
xenodolf15 January 2006
the photography and the use of the music was very nice. i enjoyed the majority of the first half, and was expecting the movie to end when the second segment of the plot unfolded. i think the transgression was a bit awkward, and a certain person at the end of the film wasn't entirely flesh out. this is not the same kind of movie as The Eye, and if you are not interested in the earlier portion of the movie, fast.forward toward the end for all the gritty material. its nice to see, that even with the movie's flaws, it stands out from the influx of carbon-copy split-personality/long haired ghosts/technological entities gone evil. the violence isn't too harsh (although there is some animal-oriented slaughter, which i assume is simulated to maintain American film standards) and most people shouldn't get too overwhelmed to handle a viewing: my rating: seven out of ten stars.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
1st half excellent, 2nd half confusing...
dwpollar17 February 2008
1st watched 2/16/2008 - 5 out of 10(Dir-Oxide Pang): 1st half excellent, 2nd half confusing. This disparity in the movie makes for a so-so movie when it could have been great. The movie is about a photographer/artist who is not happy with her work even though she's getting awards. On her way out of her house one day, she sees an accident and decides to take photographs of the incident including a death. After this, she becomes fascinated with the subject. partially because of an incident that occurred when she was young where she was molested by her cousins and her mother didn't believe her; since then she deep down didn't feel worthy of anything to the point of attempting suicide. Her girlfriend is at first confused by her obsessions but as they become more and more bizarre she helps her address her demons in her past including talking to her mother again. She appears cured and then starts receiving anonymous pictures and videos of women being tortured by a masked man. The assumption is that the person sending the info wants her to go back to her old ways. This is where the story goes awry, in my opinion. It now becomes more of a cat and mouse horror story then a morally tale, which the first half of the movie was. The couple tries to determine who's sending the pictures, as the girlfriend is pulled into the trap and tortured and killed. When the movie became about the identity of the masked man and less about the original main character in the movie it becomes confused and loses it's spark. Too bad, because the movie started out portraying a subject not shown much in movies(the effects of abuse) and ended as a typical horror/thriller.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Creepy and fascinating thriller.
HumanoidOfFlesh24 July 2005
Jiney is a young photographer,but she is not satisfied with her work.One day,she witnesses a car crash which stimulates her to take some pictures of its dying victims.The girl starts obsessively making photos of dead and dying people and animals.This morbid fascination with death become her ghastly obsession.These images of death and destruction turns on Jiney and when she is finally able to shoot a suicide,she finds complete sexual relief and totally losses herself.However,knowing that her sexual desires are not right,Jiney wants to stop this before it gets out of control.Together with her intimate friend Jas,Jiney starts to acknowledge her wrong behaviour.Suddenly she receives a snuff video from a killer who is sharing the same artistic idea about death as Jiney."Ab-normal Beauty" is a pretty unsettling thriller made by Pang brothers.It's a fascinating look into a young woman's obsession with death.The film is loaded with truly ominous and dark atmosphere and there are some lashings of gore that may shock casual viewers.The S&M style killer looks creepy but his identity is rather easy to guess.The film is colorful and stylish as it resembles a truly moody painting.Give it a look.9 out of 10.
22 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Potential isn't enough
Thorsten_B11 August 2005
Warning: Spoilers
This film clearly wants to be more than meets the eye. The outline is promising: A young girl fascinated by images of death (picture of dead people and animals, that is, or their killing), making photos of that subject, is slowly learning (and so is the viewer) that this affinity is motivated from some dark secrets of her past. This leads to a more psychological drama involving a risky sort-of suicide attempt (probably the films best scene) until the lead and her best friend find a way out. Though there's tension between the girls, don't expect or fear any "action" between them, since they're twin sisters in real life. But don't except the film to end here, either. Added is a finale to return to the "abnormalness" of the beginning. But ultimately, the picture fails. Whereare the directors recent film 'The Eye II' managed to weight the horror against a more consonant ending, he attempts the opposite here - only to deliver a foreseeable finale. Probably something for fans of the genre, but no real gem. The material is good, but the use made of the potential is unsatisfying. Still worth a look, if not the least for the stunning visuals and Payont Permsits great score.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Another Extremely Mediocre Asian Horror Film...
EVOL66625 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
The Pang brothers have done some notable work that I've seen. BANKOK DANGEROUS is a GREAT film, THE EYE is loved by many, but I thought it was lame. AB-NORMAL BEAUTY is another predictable and relatively lame Asian horror film, in my opinion. Granted, I'm pretty much a gore/sleaze/exploit fan, so maybe some of the "finer" nuances are wasted on a viewer such as myself, but oh well...that's just how it is.

A female student photographer takes pictures of a car-wreck scene that changes her outlook on "art". She becomes obsessed with death and photographing death-scenes and a bunch of boring sh!t happens until the relatively derivative and predictable ending...

I got nothing' really to say about AB-NORMAL BEAUTY. I'm sure Asian horror bandwagon-jumpers will probably jizz their shorts over this one, I found it dull and with no real redeeming value, other than some decent photography. I found it to be a mix between SAW and MUZAN E, with neither of the strong-points of either film. If you love everything that Tartan puts out, then have at it. If you've seen enough of this sort of thing, then you probably don't need to see any more...4/10
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
fascinating, appealing, intriguing but a deviating (and somewhat disappointing last 20 minutes.
Chrysanthepop6 August 2007
Warning: Spoilers
'Sei mong se jun', with it's fascinating cinematography and background score tells us the story of Jiney. Jiney is a lonely, introverted and talented young lady who's in search of herself in a somewhat deceitful world. She only confides her thoughts to her friend/cousin Jas. She reveals a deep painful secret that is destroying her inner self. Photography is her passion but she lacks the inspiration to find it fulfilling until she develops a fascination (which gradually shifts to obsession) for death. Why does she find comfort and solace in such a disturbing act?

The Pang brothers have really created a visually wonderful film. The camera, the lighting, the choice of colour, all of it adds to the beauty. Oxide Pang gives us a visual treat. The background piano tune really brings out the mood. The screenplay during the first hour is very well written and the events unfold quite smoothly. However, it is during the last 20 minutes that the plot seems to take a different direction and (spoiler alert) it was quite disappointing when the identity of the killer is revealed.

The performances are quite good. Race Wong and Rosanne Wong share a warm chemistry and their relationship is very sensitively portrayed. Anson Leung as the awkward guy in love is impressive.

This really is a worthwhile watch mainly because of it's visual appeal that really makes you feel a part of its world. Even otherwise it's quite a decent watch.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Spoiler - Plot Summary -
shaidarharan22 January 2005
Warning: Spoilers
This is a quote from a great contributer to another forum that may help some of you out with the plot(it helped me out). ".:: S T O R Y ::. Jiney studies Photography in a university. She is academic, sexy and rich. Rumor has it in her school that she is a lesbian with her classmate, Jasmine. Although her photos achieve great successes in both public and school, she is still not satisfied with her work. There are still missing parts. One day, on Jiney's way to school, a woman is knocked down by a car and dies horribly. Jiney witnesses the accident; and is at first scared than excited, she gets closer and closer to the body and finally takes a photo. After she experienced the excitement during printing the photo of the dead in her basement, she finally finds out what are the missing parts of her work.

It is blood, the moment of death. Since then, Jiney has a new feeling towards photography, that is, to capture the moment of death. She starts to shoot dead animals. This gives her fulfillment but can't last for long. These photos are not as good as the one of that dead woman.

She knows she needs dead human bodies. By chance, she sees a girl standing on top of a building. Jiney holds her camera tightly in hands begging the girl to jump off the top. The girl jumps, she instinctively takes a series of shots for her. Unlike the last experience, she experiences sexual climax when the girl's dress is blown up and she has a glance at her private part. Jiney becomes worried and afraid of what she is going to do. Jiney knows it is wrong but she can't help herself."
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
An hour and a half I will never get back.
junk-mail-46 May 2009
Little more needs be said then that, as other reviews have nailed it. Occasionally pretty, but utterly without substance. Faux profundity, pointless but at the same time oddly timid torture porn, and an ensemble cast of utterly unlikeable characters. The Pangs should be ashamed to have their once respected name hung on this. Really, do not bother. Get Amenábars 'tesis' instead, as it covers similar themes far more grippingly. Or, frankly, go do some washing up, it'd be time better spent.

J-horror has entered its death throes. The baton has passed to France, I suppose.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good creepy horror film...
MovieGuy0115 October 2009
I thought that Ab-Normal Beauty was a good creepy horror film. It is about a young girl called Jiney who is a talented art student she had a trauma in her childhood and she did not communicate with her mother very much. She is a excellent photographer but she is not satisfied with her art work. When she witnesses a car crash, she is driven by a morbid wish and takes pictures of the dead victim. Soon Jiney becomes obsessed with death, her friend Jas thinks that Jiney needs help with her abnormal behaviour. Later she receives a snuff video where a girl is being tortured and killed in front of the camera. Jiney shows the tape to Jas, who asks if she thinks that the footage is real. They believe it is a prank of one of their friends. When the girls realise that it is not a joke Jiney receives another tape with the message telling her to take a look. When she sees the tape, she becomes scared with the footage. I thought that this was a great Asian horror film. Recommended.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A film of two halves
Leofwine_draca22 June 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I watched AB-NORMAL BEAUTY (2004, original title Sei mong se jun) as a big fan of the Pang Brothers on the back of their masterful THE EYE, but sadly this is a very different beast of a film and one that ends up being a waste of time for the most part. Race Wong stars as Jiney, a photographer and art student who becomes obsessed with capturing images of death on camera, but her new-found passion soon leads her to some very dark places and she ends up being menaced by a mysterious figure. This Thai-Hong Kong co-production is very much a film of two halves. The first half is a pure psychological thriller, looking at abnormal psychology and exploring how childhood abuse can affect an adult's mental state. The second half descends into 'torture porn' style tedium, with chained girls menaced by a masked maniac, and feels like a totally different movie. A pity as if the second half had been more like the first then this could have been interesting.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Ab-normally stunning
horbachewsky4 March 2006
I give this movie a ten, and not lightly.

It was beautifully filmed, and very artistic. The darker portions of the movie where you're engulfed in an eerie feeling are very dark and dingy in the colors selected, and yet so very bright when goals have been accomplished, putting forward a great feel and really intriguing anyone interested in artistic films.

The writing wasn't great, but the story was amazing. Still, I'm drawn to the shots and beauty behind the movie.

If you're looking for a creepy movie that isn't about the fairy tale monster, but rather the monsters we may look at every day, this' the movie for you.

I recommend this movie whole heartedly. A GREAT watch.
13 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Dealing with Some Serious Psychological Issues
Uriah4322 January 2017
"Jiney" (Race Wong) is an art student who specializes in both painting and photography. One day she happens to hear a car accident not too far from where she is standing and rushes out to take a photograph of the dead man. After exposing the film she begins to have hallucinations which she then incorporates in her artwork. Soon she becomes fixated with blood and death and incorporates these two elements in all of her pictures. And the further she goes the more it scares her girlfriend "Jasmine" (Rosanne Wong)and her new friend "Anson" (Anson Leung). To further complicate the situation, Jiney has a childhood issue she still hasn't quite recovered from and somebody close to her has even worse psychological problems. Now rather than reveal any more I will just say that this movie had an interesting plot but the director (Oxide Chun Pang) was much too deliberate in his technique which caused the film to drag on much too long in some cases. Be that as it may, I thought that the presence of both Race Wong and Rosanne Wong definitely enhanced the scenery which certainly helped to some degree. In short, it wasn't a great movie by any means but it wasn't that bad either. Average.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Nothing Normal about this movie...
Lccrusher19 February 2006
"It's the most beautiful thing I've ever seen" - Richie, "American Beauty" The Asian films are so different from American films. They put a different thought process behind it. They make you think about things, while many American films are just sit in the theater for 2 hours, watching nothing.

The heart of this film is everything is beautiful. It can be a purple skyscraper. An overpass. Someone dead in the middle of the street from a car accident. This movie shows the beauty of the latter, which is good, until the character becomes obsessive about these pictures. Then it becomes a nice little thriller. Not jumpy, but it is wince worthy.

At times, I almost felt bad for liking this movie so much, but it is now one of my favorite.
11 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Disappointing!
frankie_662 January 2005
Warning: Spoilers
I've just seen this movie, looking for good horror movie, such as The Eye... But, sadly, I couldn't find any horror here. Jiney studies Photography in a university, and she is good enough to win some contests. She's lesbian, and has a relationship with Jasmine, a classmate. One day, she witnesses a car accident, and starts to taking pictures. This is only the beginning for her obsession about photographing dead things...

I've been waiting a lot for this movie, but it didn't fulfill my expectations. As I said: there is no horror here. Technically well done, but empty and predictable.

*******************

***SPOILER ALERT***

*******************

There's a killer who becomes obsessed about Jiney since her obsession on taking pictures of dead things...sadly you can figure out who is he 20 minutes before the end, and you can even anticipate the revealing flashback!
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Twisted cinema; not a masterpiece, but certainly not something you're likely forget
ThreeSadTigers19 March 2008
As the previous reviews might suggest, Ab-normal Beauty (2004) is something of a difficult film to pin down; both in terms of its abstract visual style and the actual presentation of the plot. In terms of appearance, the film is a visual labyrinth of warped neon colours, moody lighting and the occasional splash of cold, stark monochrome, all added to further reflect the inner world of the central character; in this instance, a young, misfit photographer becoming obsessed with the notions of sex and death. Further complications are created by the interesting use of narrative; with the film starting out as a kind of sinister art drama with a serious psychological subtext, before eventually changing gears in the second half and becoming an altogether more unusual experience. In this respect, I would draw a natural comparison to two very recent Japanese films, Takashi Miike's Audition (1999) and Takashi Shimizu's Marebito (2004); two films that use the conventions and, to some extent, more recognisable iconography of the horror genre, without ever really becoming horror films in the traditional sense. Also, like those two particular examples, Ab-normal Beauty tends to surprise – and perhaps even infuriate? – its viewers with the bold switches in narrative texture and the occasional disregard of logic.

The first half of the film is slow, subdued, beautifully shot with sporadic moments of surreal violence presented in a distant, dreamlike manner that stresses the characters' disconnection from society. The scenes in which she sets up and photographs various monstrous, decaying objects is masterful; creating a warped sense of beauty that seems as far removed from the horror genre as you could possibly get. As the character continues to stock-pile these images of death and decay - including that first fleeting moment wherein she snaps the aftermath of a car accident, or a tense and thrilling scene in which she documents the suicide of a man from the top of a tall building, one devastating frame at a time - we get hints of something else beginning to take shape that won't truly become apparent until right at the very end. Until then we must wonder where the film is going; with the first half of the story seeming at times to be more like a biographical drama about a tortured artist losing their grip on reality and the world around them and, as a result, creating their own world in which murder and sex become dangerously inter-twined and beauty can be found within the piles of decapitated chickens and the damp, soaked carcass of a rotting dead bird.

Describing in more detail the switch in tone and texture that occurs somewhere towards the end of the film might be considered too much of a spoiler, especially given the ideas, mood and atmosphere so skilfully established during these first forty minutes. That said, I don't think the eventual unravelling of the narrative is quite as random as many of the other reviewers seem to suggest, with a number of scenes, particularly those between Jiney and her sort-of boyfriend Anson foreshadowing many of the elements of power, humiliation, sex and violence that will reoccur during the eventual twist in the tale. It's fascinating stuff, but again, as with Audition and Marebito, could prove to be somewhat disappointing to anyone expecting a conventional horror film; with the lingering mood of ambient dread and voyeuristic terror conveyed in the more psychological first half recalling some of the more tense moments of Oxide Pang's earlier co-directed hit, The Eye (2002) - and similar Asian horror films that arrived in the wake of Ju On: The Grudge (2000) and Ringu (19998) - being completely replaced with something much darker, grittier, physical and explicit; tapping into the territory of Eli Roth perhaps, although it's worth noting that this particular film was released a good year before Roth's near iconic Hostel (2005).

Whether or not the ending really works is a question for the individual, though I suppose it would be easy to view it as an extended fantasy sequence in keeping with the character's dark descent into the depths of her own tortured imagination. Regardless, this for me is still a great film; one that creates a mood and an atmosphere perfectly pitched between elements of fantasy and reality, and riddled with images that are bold, striking and completely unforgettable. It is the style of the film and the strange wavering atmosphere in which every character seems to be a potential victim or victor that really pulls us in; enticing us with a story of fear, regret, terror and paranoia, leading us down numerous narrative blind alleyways, convincing us that all is well and that we've emerged from the psychological wilderness and then BAM! - they hit us with the hard stuff. Understandably it won't appeal to everyone; it begins slowly and takes time to pick up the pace and never make a conscious effort to appease conventions of genre or narrative expectations. However, anyone with a fondness for interesting, challenging and edgy world cinema should enjoy the fantastic atmosphere and lingering traces of horror presented to us by this fine piece of work.
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Shut your mouth and kill them
nogodnomasters5 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Jin is a top art student and photographer at her Hong Kong (?) university. When a car accident happens outside of her apartment, she pulls out her camera and that's it! That is the photo she was looking for! Jin become obsessed with photographing death to the dismay of her girlfriend Jasmine. Jin doesn't like boys. This stems from an issue as a child when apparently three boys (cousins?) took her panties down or something and her mom didn't believe her. They looked about 9 or 10 and I had trouble relating this incident to a life time of trauma...as did Jasmine. Jin seems to be getting over her death obsession, but has picked up an admirer which creates issues.

Jin's drama appeared very fake as most Asian dramas. The film failed to capitalize on the horror saving everything for the last few minutes. The characters lacked realism.

Guide: Nude model. No sex. F-word on Jin's shirt, most likely payback for all those "Japanese" shirts sold in the US in the 80's with obscene messages. Film is in Cantonese with English and Spanish subtitles available.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed