"Doctor Who" The King's Demons: Part One (TV Episode 1983) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
The Master tones it down
profh-123 December 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Just re-watched THE KING'S DEMONS last night. This starts out looking like a "historical", and for several scenes, isn't bad. Then the TARDIS materializes right in full view of a jousting match in progress, The Doctor has no idea why or how they were diverted (they were headed for Turlough's home planet, supposedly), and the trio are mistaken for "demons"-- or are they?

Anthony Ainley FINALLY gets to "tone it down" in this one, and for the first time since he played Tremas we get to see that he does have some decent acting talent. Poor Mark Strickson & Janet Fielding, on the other hand... OY. I swear, Tegan didn't get to smile ONCE in the entire story, and was much grouchier than even her usual self. Turlough, meanwhile, goes from one overly-tense scene to another, and after 3 whole adventures with The Doctor, has the stupidity to say "I DON'T KNOW!!!" when asked what The Doctor's purpose is. (I'd have thought it would have been obvious by that point. He travels from place to place, helping people in trouble, and fighting evil. In medieval terms, he ALREADY WAS a "knight"!!!)

I'm frustrated by the way the 3 family members running the castle continually mistrusted The Doctor and misinterpreted his every word and deed. It's even more frustrating that they took the word of The Master, who they should have realized was not who or what he seemed (didn't they SEE the "King's Champion" change his appearance right in front of their eyes?). And it's perhaps the most frustrating that at the very end of the story, The Doctor & co. have to "escape" for their lives, with that STUPID family still believing HE was the evil one, and not The Master.

And then there's Chamelion. I ran across a comment online about how for much of the JNT era, there was a severe lack of back-stories, clearly-told stories, and proper explanations-- not to mention character development (or even likable characters). The intro of this STUPID robot, merely by saying he was a remnant of an "earlier" invasion force on Xeraphas, and how he "helped" the Master escape from there, was BAD storytelling in the extreme!!! Then having him / it join The TARDIS crew was absurdity beyond belief. Tegan actually correctly predicted how things would go, when she questioned if the robot might still be under The Master's control. Instead of any stories where the robot might have been utilized in interesting ways, he disappeared completely with no explanation for almost an entire season-- and when he finally did turn up, sure enough, he was under The Master's control AGAIN. (yawn)

The scene at the very end where The Doctor argued with Tegan about sending her home when she said she didn't want to go home screamed "padding" to me. Tegan didn't even seem irritated or any of her usual annoying moods, just bored, like shooting the scene was just a bother to do. I suspect it may be because the serial was originally intended to end on a cliffhanger leading into Eric Saward's DALEKS story, but when that got canceled, they had to stick something else in there instead. Said cliffhanger eventually found its way onto the end of FRONTIOS midway thru the following season. (I wonder if Tegan would have left the show at the end of the 20th season if the Daleks story had been filmed when they intended to? I also understand Michael Wisher was scheduled to come back as Davros, but when it got shoved back to the following year, he was no longer available. A shame, he's the only one of the 3 Davros actors I think of as being the "real" article.)
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Time Meddler
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic25 November 2019
Review of both episodes:

A two part story quite reminiscent of The Time Meddler and other pseudo-historical stories where the Doctor finds events in the past being impacted by some interfering influence. This is nowhere near as good as The Time Meddler but it an OK effort. The TARDIS arrives in medieval England at the time of King John just before he is due to sign the Magna Carta in 1215.

I really like historical stories when done well and while this is certainly not done well enough to approach the best historicals the show has produced I do not think it is anywhere near as poor as its reputation. It has some really nice historical atmosphere, decent settings and costumes. It is solidly acted by the whole cast. It also benefits from brevity with a neat 2 part story rather than being dragged out. The only problem is that it is a bit lacklustre at times in terms of a plot that is not fully worked out and a couple of slow sections which seem fairly pointless. It has a decent showing for the Doctor's nemesis The Master who again - unsurprisingly - turns out to be the one playing havoc. His plot to use an android who can make himself look and sound like anyone in order to meddle in history and control worlds is perfectly good but it is not clear why intervening in the signing of the Magna Carta would be a worthwhile part of his plans. On the plus side he has an enjoyable sword fight which harks back to the Pertwee/Delgado days and it is a new twist on the alien in disguise motif with Kamelion and the overall plot to use this to gain power. There is some fun and some quality but it just does not rise above the level of a decent filler between more major stories.

My ratings: Parts 1 & 2 - 7/10.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Are they all stupid?
Sleepin_Dragon2 February 2019
It's not a story I watch with any degree of regularity, and having managed to get through the excruciating first episode, I remember why. The plot is a total shambles, the historical accuracy is dubious to say the least, and I have to question if The Doctor, Tegan and Turlough have had accidents to the head, failing to recognise Mr Ainley. The King is definitely behaving oddly.

Who on Earth thought it would be a good idea to give Christopher Villiers blond highlights, has he time travelled with the Master to an 80's hairdressers?

On the plus side I'd say some of the costumes are nice, I like the location work, but those nice elements aside, this one is painful to watch. 3/10
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Flat Ending To A Flat Season
Theo Robertson31 January 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Refers To Both Episodes . Spoilers

Arriving at the court of King John in 13th Century England the Tardis crew are mistaken for demons but still welcomed by the King . Finding out the date The Doctor concludes that the real King John would be in London and this king is an impostor

It's impossible to watch this in hindsight and not be reminded of another medieval show from 1983 called THE BLACK ADDER . At least that show was funny as well as being a bit silly . Here however the silliness negates any drama from a threadbare plot and while Jon Pertwee would be at home during a swordfight Peter Davison seems ill at ease when it comes to action . Sitting through season 20 of the show you just know The Master is going to make an appearance at some point and here he does . The Master of course spent the Pertwee era in league with Daleks , Sea Devils etc in trying to rule the Earth or become master of the universe . Here The Master plan revolves around stealing The Magna Carter ! Let me get this straight: a megalomaniac who has tried to exterminate or enslave billions of sentient beings throughout time and space has decided to steal something of almost zero significance . It's a bit like Bin Laden declaring war against Western civilisation by sending out a bit of hate mail to George W Bush

In its defence it's disposable mid season nonsense and Season 20 was supposed to end with a four part Dalek story but an industrial dispute meant that story was cancelled at the last moment hence we have this lacklustre story closing a distinctly mediocre season of DOCTOR WHO . Even so one would have thought the story might have been broadcast earlier in the year and Enlightenment should have been a more natural close to the 1983 series

The Kings Demons also features a new companion in the shape of Kamelion which was a genuine robot not operated by an actor and was supposed to be a new companion but was too complicated to operate to make this viable so didn't make an appearance until the following year's Planet Of Fire where he was quickly written out of the show . This lack of foresight by JNT was becoming indicative and would become more and more pronounced . That said Kamelion could change physical shape so you could see the character being constantly used as a lazy plot device so perhaps it was best that he disappeared as quickly as he arrived
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed