"Gunsmoke" Father's Love (TV Episode 1964) Poster

(TV Series)

(1964)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Felt like I needed a shower after viewing.
kfo949429 December 2012
Warning: Spoilers
After watching this episode for some reason I felt I needed a shower. As another said it is a creepy view into a world where a uncle tries to steal his nephew's wife. A theme more suited to Payton Place than Gunsmoke. After watching even the title of the episode was freaky.

The story begins in a saloon in Wichita called the Golden Horn where a new girl named Cora Prells has just been hired as the new saloon girl. She works there only a short time until she finds out this job is not for her. But in that short time she meet an older man named Jesse Price that takes a shine to the girl. Cora gently tells him to get lost as she tells the bar that she quits.

She moves to Dodge City and starts a new life at the General Store. But there are a few people that remember her from her saloon days. One of them just happens to be Jesse Price.

A nice young man named Tom King comes into the store and is smitten with Cora. They have a few dates and the next thing you know they are getting married. Tom takes Cora to where he lives with his Uncle and it just so happens to be Jesse Price.

Jesse now wants Cora for herself. Even tells her to run off with him. When she refuses Jesse cooks up a scheme where he kills a man then frames Tom. Everything looks lost for Tom and now Jesse will have Cora either by mutual agreement or by force. That is until Marshal Dillon starts to investigate.

Perhaps what was strange was that the Uncle was the predator in this story but what ever it was it just did not seem settling. A nephew that you have raised all your life and he finally finds a woman that loves him and you want to take that young woman from him- even to the point of watching your nephew hang.

Now with all that said there was a lot of action in this episode. Plenty of fighting and gunning so it kept you on your toes. Overall it was a story that was at least entertaining for those reasons. The script was weird but the outcome was good.
27 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Shary Marshall in a Starring Guest Role
TheFearmakers8 November 2018
A former saloon girl tries going straight in Dodge. In Wichita an old creepy guy wouldn't let up, and he happens to live here too, and still won't let up. The hook is the girl falls in love with the man's kind nephew.

But the reason this is a good and worthy episode is Shary Marshall, who played a very similar role in Steve Cochran's Tell Me In The Sunlight. A stripper trying for true love and having a tough time living down her past with a man she loves. Marshall is lovely and classy, and sexy too: all these things. She's underrated and only appeared in a handful of TV shows and even fewer movies.

Only in the Cochran film did she play the ingenue, so this episode, her second as a saloon girl on Gunsmoke but the main character this time, we get a proverbial movie that's less than an hour run time, and starring Shary Marshall.
20 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Were Men of the Old West really THIS Lecherous??
lrrap2 October 2022
Boy, these guys..whether or good or bad, can't seem to keep their...shall we say...hands to themselves in this show.

The plot gets somewhat complicated in the final 3rd, and Meston's script is pretty unpleasant, especially the Robert Simon character (Jesse), who is really a jerk. But then, so is Anthony Caruso.

BUT, it's all very well acted and directed, and quite intense throughout. Matt's gradual piecing together of the events is well plotted, and there's a nice resolution/ending to top it all off (PLUS a very convincing shot-gun in the back murder scene, and..of course..a good barroom fight to boot). LR.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
...a trio of talent...
gclarkbloom2 September 2022
...in this tale of romantic deception, 3 of Hollywood's best and most enduring character actors go to making this a vibid, memorable episode...

...Robert F. Simon, veteran authority figure actor played hundreds of such roles, most memorably as wacky General Maynard Mitchell on M*A*S*H...plays the sexually irrepressable "dirty old married man"...Jesse Price

...Ed Nelson...known most widely for his role as Michael Rossi on the blockbuster prime time soap, "Peyton Place"...and after hundreds of guest appearances, he retired to New Orleans to complete his BFA in fine arts at Tulane... where he went on to teach acting and screenwriting...

...finally, the "heavy you loved to hate", Anthony Caruso played loud-mouthed and racist Simms...was part of a group of Hollywood talent tapped to play mobsters, gamblers and criminal racketeers for early television...in spite of such imagery...Tony was a kind, gentle and devoted father, husband of 63 years... and a gardener...
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Definitely one of the best episodes
bobbyrcr17 March 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Definitely one of the best episodes with romance, action, subplot, building tensions, and lots of action.

Gunsmoke is at its best when it illustrates the human drama of people interacting under the influence of their passions for better or worse. I just loved this episode!

I mostly remember actor Ed Nelson (Tom) for his memorable role as doctor Michael Rossi in the prime time soap opera Peyton Place. He played this role convincingly as the smitten ranch owner beguiled by the beautiful ex saloon girl.

The versatile Robert Simon was excellent as the villainous lecherous uncle who tried and failed to spin his web of lies.

Great script and execution by all actors!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Shouldn't it be "Father-in-law's Love", or better yet...?
rrolwing13 March 2024
I was wracking my brain for a while trying to figure out how the title *"FATHER'S Love * fit the story and the principals involved...I finally decided FATHER referred to her relationship with Jessie post marriage-wise, as in "father-in-law"...Of course, Jessie was Tom's uncle, so shouldn't that have been "uncle-in-law?" Or just (nothing)-in-law? This then led me to the suspicion that maybe the original story had Jessie indeed being Tom's actual FATHER and they just left that title on even after they had figured maybe that as his father Jessie's actions would stretch credulity a tad too much...

In any case, I kept waiting for Tom's dark underside to be revealed, that, is, until Matt gave him his glowing endorsement, of course (In 99% of other Gunsmoke similar situations Matt would have responded, "Tom King!!??") Consequently, I guess most of my attention was directed at Robert F. Simon's intriguing performance...just as I was getting into "enjoying" the "comic" side of his oblivious amorality it would be replaced by the thought that this guy is a dangerous psychopath...!! So, in any case, as I stated before definitely an intriguing performance that was the highlight for me.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Is there an echo in here?
nanny-12412830 March 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Edith Evanston was a hoot as the housekeeper, Nell, who repeated everything anyone said to her. I cracked up at her last line, after Uncle Jesse gets his just desserts. I think it was Matt Dillon (Arness) who made the pronouncement: "He's dead", dutifully repeated by Nell.

This was Edith Evanston's only Gunsmoke appearance but it was 10 years before she retired. So I wonder if she ever ran into any of the other actors in this episode, either professionally or socially. I know if it was me, I would repeat whatever the other person said to make them laugh, if they remembered that idiosyncrasy in this episode.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed