"Perry Mason" The Case of the Bedeviled Doctor (TV Episode 1959) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Perry defends a doctor when his confidential tapes are stolen
kfo949410 May 2013
Even though the mystery surrounding the stolen tapes is very interesting, I just do not understand the human element in this story. When a secretary betrays your livelihood, it would be hard for any normal person to forgive such an act. But it seems, in this story, that the person that aided the criminal will be back working in the same location previous. That does not seem like good business sense.

It involves the practice of Doctor David Craig. As a psychologist the good doctor hears many personal and confidential stories that is part of his regular practice. Dr Craig makes a tape of these sessions for further review. When a notable businessman, Peter Haywood, finishes his session the doctor's nurse, Edith Douglas, places the tape inside the safe.

But the doctor's nurse has a different plan for the tape. It seems that the nurse's brother, Mark Douglas, is in trouble with some roughs. If he does not come up with about $4000 of scratch then they are going to hurt him. Edith makes a copy of the safe's key and gives to her brother so that he can steal Peter Haywood's tape and sell to his wife in a divorce case.

After the theft, Dr Craig finds out that Mark is the one that stole the tapes. He confronts Mark and gets his tapes back. But little does the doctor know that Mark has make copies and is trying to sell the tapes to the highest bidder of either Peter Haywood or his wife Barbara Haywood.

When Mark is found dead all the evidence points to Dr Craig as the murderer. From his fingerprints on the victim's telephone to saying that he was going to kill Mark, Perry will have a difficult time bring the suspicion of doubt away from the doctor.

There really is nothing wrong with the story. It was a good plot surrounded by a nice mystery as who was the true murderer of the victim. The only fault in the episode was the casting of Barry McGuire as the person with the stolen tapes. First his appearance as the tough guy just did not seem believable with the boyish face and straight lace attire. Second his acting ability proved that he should have been cast in an nonspeaking part than given a near lead in the show. But because of the fine mystery this flaw is quickly overlooked.

A good story with an entertaining ending. Good watch.
24 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The case of the really rotten relative
AlsExGal2 January 2023
A psychiatrist's secretary has a brother who claims to owe four thousand dollars to gamblers who are going to kill him if he doesn't pay up. He says he can get five thousand dollars for a tape of a particular patient of the doctor's admitting to an affair, the soon to be ex-wife being the one willing to pay. The patient, Peter Heywood, has lots of money and it would mean big alimony for his wife. The sister is conflicted between loyalty (and love) for the doctor and her desire to help her brother out. Eventually, blood wins out. But the brother is lying about the gamblers and just needed a story to get his sister to help him with this inside job.

Soon after the tape is stolen the brother is found dead. Instead of a medal ceremony, believe it or not the police are looking for the murderer. The doctor is charged although, of course, there are a multitude of suspects. The wealthy patient who was being blackmailed could have been the killer as well, since he was not so intent on protecting his money as he was his secretary, with whom he is in love. Della must be jealous of all of this interoffice romance.

No courtroom confession here. This time Perry sets up a situation to entrap the real killer. As usual his insight into human behavior and eye for detail serve him well.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Ball Of Confusion
darbski30 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** Yes, yes.... just like the Temptations song, this is a ball of confusion. high points - nurses brother "I'm no good" - right; killing is too good for you. Doc understands his patient's problem is Co-Dependency; His problem, too; Nurse, too, Perfect for blackmail; that happens; brother (the contemptible scumwad), is clipped; Doc is picked up, fingerprints, the works; Perry's already on case - fun starts.

One problem I have is the fact that Nursie isn't getting help from Doc about her bro. Second, why does bro live with her? a scheming rat like that would have stolen her blind long before this case; see, he's paying her back for not being mommy. Here, she has a really nice Edsel Convertible (new), and a nice apartment. Bull. Doc gets copies of tapes back - later, goes back finds scumwad croaked; hates himself, so he tosses his .38 in the drink. This whole bit is right out of "After the Thin Man" a great psychological divorcement of intellect. One more idiot with a gun. Perry asks Tragg how many .38 caliber weapons are out there? 100,000? Nope ...WAY more than that, believe me.

Now, here's where being an alcoholic helps; see, if Mrs. Heywood (I happen to think she was pretty sexy, in that "naughty librarian" way) had been sober, and thinking straight, she would have realized that all she had to do was call up the bunko squad, and when scum shows up, have him arrested for attempting to involve her in blackmail. even if scummy slides out of it, the cat's out of the bag, and her Huz is grist for the divorce mill. IF. Of course, scumwad is in L.A. county lockup where he is a new toy for a gorilla; one more step toward his doom, and sis is out of the mix. Professionally, she's gotta be finished, right? Uh Huh.

Tragg in Perry's office, and the headlines are 2" high about the murder. Of a nobody? Not likely. Real good courtroom drama. Mrs. Heywood calls her Huz a liar, gets time for contempt, and you're gonna have to see the rest of it for yourself; but let me just add, that the business of a "happy ending" for Doc + Nursie has to start with serious couch time for both of them; as far as I can tell, they're both nutz. I give them an icecube's chance in hell.

The last exchange between Perry and Della is gonna cost him a real nice dinner out. One thing is this; at the same time this episode was playing on METV, I had it loaded in the DVD, so I could check facts right away. I like METV, but they can't include details that you can get from the real recordings. Next month, I'll complete this collection through Amazon. Very good acting, camera-work and dialogue Kudos.
9 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The case of the murdered blackmailer
jn-9134813 September 2021
Warning: Spoilers
A nurse and her brother steal patient files to blackmail a man for money the doctor is charged with the blackmailing brothers murder.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Violating Trust
bkoganbing5 September 2014
Psychiatrist Dick Foran is the Perry Mason client in this story. Dr. Foran tapes his sessions and Andrea King is willing to pay big money for the tape where her husband Phillip Terry confesses to an affair with his secretary Norma Moore.

King is working with Barry McGuire the no good brother of Foran's secretary Marianne Stewart who says that Las Vegas gangsters want to kill him over gambling debts to get that tape. Stewart buys that story and helps him get the tape. When Foran finds out about it he's naturally enraged and when McGuire is shot to death he also becomes the man in the jackpot.

Some false testimony about a gun, presumably the murder weapon being lost is what triggers the discovery of the real killer.

Stewart is particularly touching in a performance where she shoulders all responsibility for the bad behavior of her brother. She refuses to realize that some people are just plain no good.

It's an interesting story though the perpetrator is one who has played some bad people on the big and small screen.
13 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
When they fish my body out of the ocean don't bother to identify it!
sol121813 August 2012
***SPOILERS*** The kind respected and beloved town psychiatrist Dr. David Craig, Dick Foran, finds himself in the eye of the storm in this Perry Mason episode. That's in Dr. Craig recording his patients problems as part of his therapy for them. It's when Dr. Craig's secretary Edith Douglas', Marianne Stewart, degenerate gambler kid brother Mark, Barry McGuire, finds out that he's been treating big time plane manufacture Peter Heywood, Philip Terry, for depression over his failing marriage that he, in having an extramarital affair, in fact is responsible for he schemes to get his sister to get him the recordings of Heywood's sessions. Mark plans to use them to blackmail Heywood in order to get the $4,000.00 he owes the mob run casino he's been gambling at.

With Edith making a wax impression key to Dr. Craig's safe where he keep the tape recordings Mark now uses them to both blackmail Heywood as well as his wife Barbara, Andrea King, by having her pay for the recording so she can use them in a future divorce settlement. It's when Mark is found shot to death in his apartment by Perry and his in house private eye Paul Drake, William Hopper, that all the evidence points to the good doctor and psychiatrist! Since just a few hours earlier Dr. Craig threatened to shoot Mark, who made a number of copies of them, for stealing his personal audio tapes! It's now up to Perry Mason who's Dr. Craig's good friend as well as lawyer to track down who really did Mark Douglas in. In fact Dr. Craig did himself in real good by stupidly deep sixing his licensed .38 revolver in the Pacific Ocean making it impossible for Perry to prove, through ballistics, that his gun wasn't the one that blew Mark away!

***SPOILERS*** With all the people who would have had it in for Mark and gone so far as to murder him Perry gets that person to come out in the open not in court but at the scene of the crime. That's by tricking him or her to show up at Mark's apartment for the audio tape he hid there. Not realizing that by doing that Perry had the police waiting for the killer to not only show up but in trying to retrieve the audio tape confess to his crime as well!
10 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
ACTOR PLAYING BROTHER ALMOST DERAILS EPISODE
talula10605 October 2023
The actor playing Mark, the brother of the nurse is completely awful and almost ruins the entire episode. First of all, he's way too young or the actress playing the nurse is way too old. She looks 50 and he looks to be about 17. Something wrong there. But it's his acting that's really the problem. He is overly dramatic and makes many amateur mistakes. It reminded me of a 30s B movie. If someone knocks on the door, he jumps as though he was shot out of a cannon. He gives this ridiculously exaggerated grin when he successfully cons his sister. It doesn't help matters that he's got a face for radio so isn't easy on the eyes. I watch a lot of old movies and I don't think I've ever seen him before. Maybe he was only on TV? He's just awful and very hataeble but not for the reasons written into the script. All 50s actors exaggerate their movements to some extent. It was just the style of the time. But this kid behaved like he was a mime in a silent film. Waving his arms, tiptoeing dramatically, and trying to keep audience attention on him even if he wasn't supposed to be the center of attention. Very glad when he got killed but it wasn't soon enough for me.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Privileged Information
Hitchcoc31 December 2021
This is an ordinary episode with little happening. A punk kid claims to be in trouble with gamblers and hits up his sister to help him steal personal tapes from a psychiatrist. Not much there.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Case of the Bedeviled Doctor
Prismark1014 February 2024
Dr David Craig is a psychiatrist who tapes his patients sessions. Barbara Heywood wants the tape of the sessions Dr Craig has had with her husband Peter.

In his sessions Peter Heywood has confessed to an affair with his secretary. This would lead to a lucrative divorce settlement for Barbara.

She hires a mobster to retrieve the tapes. In turn the mobster goes to Mark Douglas. His sister Edith is Dr Craig's secretary.

Mark puts the right amount of pressure on his sister. That he is being pursued by some heavies over some gambling debts.

After the tapes are stolen Dr Craig goes to see Perry Mason. He soon becomes a suspect when Mark Douglas is found dead.

I did think actor Barry McGuire was hammy as Mark Douglas, the sneering victim.

Refreshingly Perry Mason traps the villain but not in the courtroom. Having guessed the means and motive.

I was surprised why the judge wanted to lock up Barbara Heywood for her outburst in court. If she publically claims that her husband's alibi is false. Maybe he would had wanted to do some more probing.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed