User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Preachy...again.
planktonrules21 April 2013
"Physician, Heal Thyself" is a very, very unusual episode of "Quincy". Think about it--the show deals with, among other things, abortion! In the States, you hardly ever hear about abortions on TV--mostly because it's such a divisive issue. But here, you have the likes of June Lockhart (of all people) playing a doctor who is very much an advocate for the procedure. Unusual to say the least! This episode is the third or fourth in Season 4 that dealt with incompetent, evil or ACCUSED or incompetent doctors! It makes you wonder if either the writers were lazy OR they simply hated doctors! Regardless, a pattern seemed to be developing this season.

The show begins with a mother requesting an autopsy on her daughter. It seems that the daughter had recently had a legal abortion but had unexpectedly died a few days later. Quincy sees that the woman should not have died but has a hard time proving incompetence. But, as the investigation goes, it appears as if the doctor might have a drinking problem and it might have caused this death. Next thing you know, without much proof, Quincy goes off on a crusade to have this doctor removed.

This episode brings up some excellent points, though I thought Quincy sure handled things in a ham-fisted manner (even more than usual). Additionally, he spent too much time preachy and yelling to make this a particularly good episode. Average at best.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
OK Quincy episode.
poolandrews22 February 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: Physician, Heal Thyself starts as seventeen year old Julie Reed (Tara Buckman) staggers into the Bennett Clinic where she ask's for an abortion, highly experienced & well respected Dr. Ronald Shafer (John Dehner) performs the abortion as requested but Julie dies on the operating table. Julie's parents contact Dr. Asten (John S. Ragin) in order to arrange a private autopsy which they will pay for, Asten gives the case to Quincy (Jack Klugman) who notices that the abortion wasn't done very well. He decides to investigate further & subsequently finds out that Dr. Shafer has a drink problem & regularly turns up to work to perform vital operations & surgical procedures drunk, outraged Quincy is determined to stop him before he kills anyone else but it isn't as easy as he first thought it would be...

Episode 18 from season 4 this Quincy story was directed by Corey Allen & is one of those largely moralistic Quincy episodes where he finds himself on some sort of crusade against bureaucracy, red tape, inadequate laws, incompetence & unhelpful people in authority. He pretty much takes on the whole system as usual. The themes here in Physician, Heal Thyself are rather standard issues dealing with alcohol problems & people make life & death decisions letting the alcohol rule their lives & therefore putting others at risk. There's also a stab at trying to say that keeping your mouth shut when you know someone who turns up for work drunk isn't good, which it isn't. It ends on a anti drink message which most will probably laugh at. It also points out some inadequacies in the law like usual & it's all rather familiar & routine feeling. There's nothing here amazing or overly enthralling either, it's OK I suppose & if you like these moralistic Quincy episodes then you may enjoy it but for most of us this isn't exactly going to knock our socks off.

A largely talkative & exposition based episode nothing of any real note happens, there's no murder (technically there isn't) & no mystery which doesn't help. It's just a bland fifty minutes of preaching more than anything else, sure it's always fun to watch Quincy run around getting angrier & angrier at people as he fights red tape & bureaucracy but that can only entertain to a certain extent. The acting is OK & Quincy gets to gatecrash a posh country golf club.

Physician, Heal Thyself is a standard fairly dull moralistic Quincy episode that fans will probably like but more casual viewers may find the going a little slow.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Dull episode focusing on medical malpractice and addiction
rayoflite2425 September 2015
Physician, Heal Thyself begins with a teenage girl in medical distress returning to the clinic where she had just underwent an abortion. She dies shortly thereafter from complications stemming from the procedure, and her mother requests that Quincy (Jack Klugman) conduct an autopsy. Quincy finds some evidence that Dr. Ronald Shafer (John Dehner) botched the procedure which ultimately caused the girl's death, but it is not conclusive enough to take action against him. Through further investigation, Quincy learns that Dr. Shafer has an alcohol problem and was possibly drunk during this surgery as well as others which had tragic outcomes. This puts Quincy on a mission to obtain more evidence against the doctor in an effort to put a stop to him harming patients.

While this episode deals with medical malpractice and incompetence due to an addiction which is a compelling topic in some respects, the fact that the deaths were the result of negligence and nothing was intentionally done wrong just seemed to make for a very dull story in my opinion. Here we see yet another medical professional showing a blatant disregard for the welfare of his patients and no remorse for his actions, this is of course becoming an overused and far-fetched plot of Season 4. There also really isn't much of a mystery featured here as Quincy figures out what happened early on and then becomes primarily focused on finding evidence to support his conclusion.

I found the final scene at the end to be especially ridiculous as Quincy orders a round of plain lemonades for his friends gathered at Danny's bar saying that any of them could become alcoholics. While I get the message trying to be conveyed, it just came across as righteous and hypocritical as we all know that group will be sitting around the same table drinking plenty of rounds of beer, whiskey and scotches in many, many episodes to come.

Overall, a pretty weak Season 4 episode with a dull plot and not a whole lot else going for it unfortunately.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed