"Wagon Train" The Jess MacAbee Story (TV Episode 1959) Poster

(TV Series)

(1959)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
fun, nostalgic light fluff
talonjensen3 January 2018
I enjoyed this episode, it is different and very predictable, but a nice change of pace for me. The isolation of some of the first settlers of the west was very real, sometimes by choice. Flint handles the adoring daughters very well without hurting them, as requested by their mother. The father is an embarrassment, but loved by his family and I have certainly seen family dynamics like this in real life. For the time this was made this show reinforces some stereotypes such as a woman doing the cooking and it breaks some stereotypes such as a daughter plowing the field.

It could have gone in different ways to more comedic or more serious (dark, like many modern movies) but, I smiled as I watched it and remembered some of the innocence of my own childhood, infatuations with older people. The ending leaves us at a moment in time where everyone in the episode is happy.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Like winning the lottery when a man of Flint's caliber shows up
glitterrose5 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I really enjoyed this story. But I'll also admit this particular episode might not be everybody's cup of tea. The characters in this episode are very southern. So that might turn a lot of people off if you're sitting there thinking "Nobody's that much of a hick. Nobody." But I'm southern so the talking and mannerisms didn't bother me any. Nor was I offended.

It's never really explained how or why this family has isolated themselves as much as they have. The father is a bit of a drama queen so it might be a case of always having a story to tell if anybody in the family wanted to branch out on their own. This is a family that keeps to themselves and they don't really interact with outsiders until Flint shows up.

Boy, did this family win the jackpot. It bothered me the mother always referring to her husband as being a southern gentleman. Flint's the gentleman. Flint's also a man. Let me explain that last part. Just because you have the right equipment doesn't mean you're a man. Would I say the father is a man in this story? No. He laid his butt down on the hammock and let the rest of the family work their butts off and the girls do work hard. Flint pitched in and helped the girls out. Man, I thought Charles Ingalls on Little House on the Prairie was lazy but he doesn't have anything on Jess MacAbee!

So let's get to the guts of this story. I'm sure everybody can predict it. The girls go into heat over Flint. The only exception at this time is Junior. Junior's upset at everything changing because he's shown up. More on Junior later. The mother can see her daughters have fallen in love with Flint and she asks him to let them down easy. This ties in with another part of the story where the father want's Flint to pick one of his daughters and marry her. I don't even think she needed to say a word about letting the girls down easy. Flint's a nice guy. He's not gonna suddenly become a jerk. He goes up to each daughter and is a true gentleman. He makes it a point to highlight the strengths of each girl. Again, Flint's a class act.

Turns out the MacAbees have some neighbors nearby. I'm sure everybody knows where this is headed. The actor that played Sheriff Coffee on Bonanza plays a character in this episode and his character has 6 sons. The end shows practically each daughter having a good time talking, playing, laughing with one of the sons. Only exception is Junior. Junior has now fallen in love with Flint. Flint has a talk with her and mentions her growing up. I wasn't really fond of the open ended ending about Flint riding back through when Junior's 17. Yeah, a lot of viewers might write if off as Junior won't even be able to remember Flint's name by the time she's 17 because it looks like the door might finally be opening up for this family when it concerns meeting people, doing what they want to do, etc. I still can't help but think of Junior being 17 and still having the hots for Flint. Girl's gonna be disappointed unless one of the writers remembered this episode and mentioned Flint visiting the MacAbee family during an episode that didn't have Robert Horton in it at all.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Paradise Valley
bkoganbing22 April 2013
If you're a big fan of Andy Devine you'll probably love this Wagon Train episode. But sad to say it's a rather unrealistic story that depends just too much on his comic talents to put it over.

Robert Horton is looking for food for the Wagon Train as supplies are running low. He stumbles across a hidden valley much like Omar Sharif in The Proud Valley. But there's no 30 Year War on the outside. It's the private preserve of Andy Devine and Glenda Farrell and the five daughters they've raised.

And Devine does not like no outsiders at all, he chases them away with fake Indian raids. But Flint McCullough doesn't take 'no' for an answer. And being he's the only man these young ladies have ever met they're all falling in love with him.

One has to wonder about these people, especially Glenda Farrell married to this lazy lout. When we first meet the McAbee family all the women are hard at work doing farm chores and Devine is supervising from his hammock.

Andy and Glenda came to the area 20 years earlier and Glenda asks about the good health of President Polk. They managed to miss the Civil War altogether. One wonders how they managed to not be invaded by unfriendly Indians all that time. Or now that at least two of the girls are growing up that they haven't just up and left the place.

More outside people do come to alter the situation permanently in the end. What happens is for you to see. The episode funny as Devine and Farrell are, is a bit too unreal for me.
13 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed