The Town That Was (2007) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Brief documentary regarding one of the heralded underground mine fires
digital_groove5 July 2009
Warning: Spoilers
I had been anticipating the release of this film onto DVD for quite some time now. I first become privy to the film over two years ago, just missing my chance to view it in a nearby city by a few weeks. I began to wait and wait until the DVD hit stories. After an online rental, I finally got to satiate my desire.

I must say, I knew quite a bit about Centralia prior to the film. I've read Joan Quigley's "The Day The Earth Caved In", read various websites, and even visited the town of Centralia in person. I was not sure how they were going to tackle the film. From reading the history behind the town, the press for saving it, and the aftermath, they had potential to really delve into a convoluted situation with many theories of why the government failed to act quickly and the heavy disputes between those who wished to keep the press out of the town. The film mentions these things, albeit too briefly for one with limited knowledge of the story to gain a better insight into the turmoil surrounded within.

The film mainly follows one of the last current residents of the town, we get quality reminiscing of how the town was, childhood memories, the camaraderie of neighbors, and he provides a great warmth for one to imagine how a town that is doomed to be torn down once prospered. We're treated to old film of Holiday parades at the intro of the film, I personally was expecting much more of this type of medium. This was one of my biggest expectations of the film, old achieve footage of the press the fire got. From reading up on the town, they actually appeared prime time on ABC in the 80s when they were trying to garner enough support to finally put the fire out. Sadly, no news footage of the sort appears in the film. The film largely comprises of first had accounts of how the town used to be from old residents, politicians, and relatives. Between these scenes, we are treated to the hometown resident walking around town giving us a detailed tour of how the town looks now.

I guess now is also the proper time to dispel any unseemly expectations. Cenralia is not on fire above ground. You will not see this film or visit the town and see flames billowing from the grounds or trees on fire. What you will see is the old highway deteriorated and cranked, smoke rising from the ground, and lots of dead trees and vegetation letting the viewer to realize the roots were torched from beneath the surface.

Overall, the film is a good introduction for those who may have heard about the film or the legends. It's too brief in spots, but many books were written to help fill in those gaps. I do wish in included news footage from the past, a topographical map detailing a then/now perspective, and just all around a longer documentary; there's much more history to push it over the ninety minute mark.
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Excellent representation of the demise of Centralia
lenmodz31 December 2015
My first visit to Centralia was in 1977, as a TV news cameraman shooting 16mm film for WNEP-TV. That film is now in the ABC News archives. My fellow photographers and I shot lots of film and video in Centralia over the following 30 years. Chris Perkel approached WNEP-TV News Director Dennis Fisher and and me circa 2005 looking for archival news footage of Centralia from WNEP. We were happy to accommodate the project. I spent many hours researching old news video in WNEP-TV's archives, making copies, and sending them to Chris and Georgie. I've viewed the documentary several times and, in my judgment,it provides an accurate account of what happened to this small, unfortunate town in the late 20th century.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The BEST Centralia documentary out there.
panthersfreak14 November 2018
For anyone who is a fan of Centralia or wants to know more about this town, this documentary is for you. It has a (now former) resident of the town walk you through the history of Centralia and what life used to be like there. This documentary also has experts on coal mines, the fire, and other things. Everything in this documentary is top notch and you will never look at Centralia the same way again after watching this documentary. I have been to Centralia 4 times this year and this documentary gave me insight into this amazing town that I would not have been able to get elsewhere. A must watch.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed