"Popeye the Sailor" Barbecue for Two (TV Episode 1960) Poster

(TV Series)

(1960)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Oddest Entry In Popeye Series
stp4320 May 2007
Warning: Spoilers
This is the most unusual episode of the Popeye cartoon series in that it is made by one studio - that of Jack Kinney - yet it uses the opening theme and a particular cue from another studio - Paramount Pictures. Winston Sharples' mid-1950s power-march theme introduces the cartoon, editorially extended to cover the longer credits common to Kinney's entries, and the spinach cue from Paramount's 1957 entry "Patriotic Popeye" is also used, and also editorially extended.

The theme closes over the actual title card, which features silhouettes of Popeye and Olive Oyl over an outdoor stove. The silhouettes give away the cartoon's unusual visual quality. Dispensing with the handsome character designs of Paramount's 1950s shorts, Kinney goes back to the future with character designs straight out of E.C. Seger's newspaper funnies; Popeye even wears black sailor garb for the first time since his late-1930s shorts.

The subject matter here is a weekend off for Popeye and company in their new suburban setting, displayed by the opening establishing shot of a suburban block. Popeye is setting up a barbecue for himself and Olive. When he borrows some flowers for his sweetie from his neighbor Brutus, he gets a one-punch pounding but is otherwise unfazed. Brutus, after getting his "favorite pet petunias" back, begins scheming to get into Popeye's celebration (this leads to the short's funniest gag, when Brutus drops a lit match onto Popeye's grill, it blows up in his face, and all his hair is burned off only to regrow in an instant), but Popeye soon finds his hands full with J. Wellington Wimpy and Little Swee'Pea while Brutus regales Olive with his folk song about spilled mustard.

The cartoon is among the loudest and most chaotic of the entire Popeye animated series, theatrical or television, as Popeye runs himself ragged taking care of his unexpected guests while trying to get at Brutus. Falling into his cellar, Popeye finds a can of spinach and that gives him the strength to resolve this situation at last - Wimpy and Swee'Pea get the hint, but of course Brutus doesn't, instead being provoked merely by being referred to as "Junior." The soundtrack stock used for this cartoon has considerable room-sound-quality reverb in the voice performances, which hurts them (Mae Questel's in particular) as voices seem to crack at times. Nonetheless it still works as an entertaining if very unusual entry in the Popeye series.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Most suave dudes would not invite a gal over for a . . .
pixrox18 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
. . . BARBECUE FOR TWO, and THEN realize that they had to build a brick grilling apparatus BEFORE they could even begin cooking the food for their honey. This picture had immediate Real World consequences, informing stores and inventors that there could be a strong national market for portable grilling devices--something virtually unheard of in 1960. Americans began asking each other, "How is it that we're fixing to put a dozen guys on the moon, but we have to spend weeks building a brick kiln to grill a dozen burgers?" Back in the 1950's, the back yard of nearly every suburban home in our U. S. Homeland featured a permanent brick installation for warming meat. Thousands of youngsters were paralyzed permanently when they hit the bricks going long for a pass. Thanks to BARBECUE FOR TWO, this seldom happens any more.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Good TV Cartoon
boblipton12 June 2023
Popeye wants to have a barbecue for just Olive and him, but Bluto, Wimpy, and Swee'pea keep butting in.

This was the first Popeye cartoon produced for what became the television version following the long run of Fleischer-Paramounts. For some reason, they chose another episode as the first. Comparing it to the theatrical cartoons is a futile task, as the simple, primitive designs and quarter-animation. Still, the script is as good or better than the later theatrical releases, and the money spent on production was spent wisely, with Disney veteran Jack Kinney directing, and the trio who had done the voice work for the theatrical releases -- Jack Mercer as Popeye, Jackson Beck as Bluto, and Mae Questal as Olive -- doing the same here.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very funny short, unusually so for Jack Kinney
J. Spurlin1 May 2008
Popeye is getting his backyard ready for Olive's visit. It's going to be a barbecue for two -- or so he thinks. "I love barbecues," says Brutus dreamily from the other side of the fence.

"I loves barbecues, too," says Popeye, blowing in his sailor's hat to create a chef's hat. "But you ain't invited." But that won't stop Brutus any more than it'll stop Wimpy, who smells the cooking hamburgers and rushes over; or Swee' Pea, who suddenly decides he wants to be pushed on his swing. Olive arrives, and to Popeye's dismay, she's thrilled at the "big party." Now, Popeye's barbecue for two has become a headache for one -- namely him -- as he frantically tries to cater to the demands of Swee' Pea and Wimpy, while competing with Brutus for Olive's attention.

"Barbecue for Two" is a very funny short, probably the best one that came out of Jack Kinney Productions (one of five studios that produced the cartoons in this 1960-62 series). Almost invariably, the Kinney films are sloppily animated, unintelligibly plotted and off-puttingly weird.

"Barbecue" stands out for another reason. It's the only entry in the series, from any studio, to give Popeye the blue sailor suit he had back in the 30s. And it's the only entry to present Olive more or less the way she was designed in Segar's comic strips.

But a little of the usual Kinney sloppiness sneaks in. An explosion singes off the hair on Brutus's head and face. But then it instantly reappears. Cartoon magic allows this sort of thing, but not, as in this cartoon, from one frame to the next.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed