War Stories (2009) Poster

(I) (2009)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Screen the actors more carefully next time.
paul-collado27 June 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I'll start with praises. The plot was well written and delivered. I didn't have the plot figured out until the end when the truth about what happened to Tim's father was revealed. Most of the script was very well written and the cinematography conveyed the mood of the characters near perfectly. The music and sound added to and carried the mood in a way I didn't expect for a low-budget production. This part of the film went above and beyond my expectations. The actor who played Austin (Mark Ayesh) was great; he was very believable and comfortable in his role. He definitely has a future in acting. Besides the carefully orchestrated plot and the cinematography, this film's value is mainly tied up in its statement of and protest against the bigotry and closed-mindedness of Midwestern culture (the Bible belt), which was for the most part well executed. To really understand the conversation between the ex-journalist and Tim, you'd have to live in Wichita and read the local news (or lack thereof). These aspects of the movie were nearly perfect.

The actor who played Tim (Michael Gordon) was alright. In the beginning, he seemed uncomfortable and awkward, but after a little character development (about 1/3 of the way through the movie), he settled into his role. By the end, it was easy to believe his emotions. I would like to see him in another movie.

Now to my complaint (one really big one). The actress who played the mother (Danielle Wolverton) was absolutely abhorrent. What sucked about her horrible acting is that her character is so pivotal to the plot and to the emotions and motivations of the other characters. The entire plot hinges on her blind bigotry and psychosis and the effects of her actions on the main character, and she failed miserably at delivering any of these emotions. Anyone who thinks that her acting was anything but dry and insipid has both not seen enough movies (independent or mainstream), and has not had to deal with any true emotional conflict in their own lives. She monotonically delivered all of her lines with comically false embellishment. I almost laughed out loud during the scene when she asked Tim if he was on drugs; what a joke! She ruined all of the emotionally tense scenes in which she was involved, which was a big part of the movie.

However, the last about half of the movie (from the chase through downtown Wichita to the meeting in Oklahoma City) when she was not present was very good.

All in all, it was worth the watch. It did hit home for some of us who have lived in the Midwest for our entire lives and have not agreed with many of the politics of the region. With a different actress playing the mom, this would have easily been an 8 to 9 out of 10 stars for me. To the creators of this movie, I hope you do a better job of screening your actors and actresses before you begin shooting. This was really the only downfall to this film. Good luck and I hope to see your next production.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Timely, engaging, suspenseful
oaksong24 May 2010
This work goes in no direction you expect. Poor Tim wants to write about his war hero father who died in the Gulf War. It's his school final history project. The teacher calls him into his office and tells him he needs to provide an obituary if he wants to write about his father. This leads Tim on a most unexpected journey.

The suspenseful music right from the beginning leads us to question what might be coming. The director manages to engage us immediately and keeps us engaged through the zigs and zags of the story. With a minimum budget for special effects he still manages to convey distinctions in time and place.

I recommend this film highly, as I'm hoping it will be either the opener or centerpiece film for the festival I've just screened it for.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
intriguing film all the way
petesneat24 April 2010
War Stories has a plot that draws you into a coming of age story of a young man. However, as an adult, it seems most films in the genre are 'been there, done that... please don't remind me', but this one is an exception and is entertaining. An impressive example of a low-budget film for its establishment of context (though I wish there had been more audio context/background noise present)and character evolution. Without giving away spoilers, I will say that the mother is possibly the most tragic character -- having lost touch with reality. There are some humorous moments when the film borrows scene-types from other movies.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A routine class project sends a high school student digging through his past. The kid soon finds out the stories his mom fed him about his war hero father were largely lies.
bernardrd24 April 2010
My expectations were not very high since this was an amateur film. In fact, my only expectation was to lose interest half-way through. To my surprise, the plot and the built-in suspense held my attention to the very end. Where as most amateur films have predictable endings, I was surprised when the end revealed itself.

Great story development, bolstered by rich and mature cinematography. You can see the director think through each scene.

The acting was solid. The kid who played the main character had spunk and energy. My favorite, though, was the bit part played by the former newspaper reporter.

This film is so well executed, it's better than some Hollywood movies. I'm looking forward to the director's next flick.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"War Stories is unarguably a film for the heart, mind AND soul!
BerniceJMiller26 April 2010
It's cheesy to say, but you only get one chance to make a first impression. Whitman, with his feature debut, does one hell of a job! His natural cinematography abilities make you forget that you are watching an indie film. He takes risks with camera angels that turn out so amazing that I'm sure it will be mimicked. The editing is smoothly done which was expected after only watching the trailer. The story, as well, is weaved together impressively and deals with so many issues that this film is a must see for every individual. The actors give such an emotional performance that you develop a deep love/hate relationship with each one within minutes of the film. WAR STORIES is unarguably a film for the heart, mind, and soul! Whitman is absolutely brilliant and I am excited to see what is next for him!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
War Stories Delivers a War to the Conscience
chunktile15 April 2010
When I first lined up to see WAR STORIES, I didn't know what to expect; that's the joy of watching independent films! And frankly, I'm surprised this hasn't been featured in any other festivals besides the one down in Asheville. Sure, we've all heard the premise "What if everything you knew changed?", but WAR STORIES handles it in quite a different manner. To post how would be spoilerific; however, I can say that the plot twist towards the end of the film is dramatic and unsettling, because it very well could happen. The film makes one empathize with the main characters, for they're quite well-written.

Whitman's cinematography is beautifully done; most of the acting is spot-on (with the main characters at least); and the music does carry some lasting appeal, especially since (mind you) this is an independent film; and best of all, the film keeps your attention, running close to two hours. My only qualms with the film apply to the delivery of some minor characters' lines and the mother's appearance hardly changing after a time transition during the first fifteen-or-so minutes. Where can I find a plastic surgeon like hers? She doesn't even have a wrinkle after raising a son into his teenage years!

Film Quality: 10/10 Story: 10/10 Acting: 8/10 Music: 10/10 Audio: 9/10

Overall: 9
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Very Enjoyable film, keeps you guessing until the end
MLite8123 April 2010
I really enjoyed this film. Its plot twists keep you guessing, with plenty of misdirection. I won't give any spoilers, but many of the topics the film deals with are very timely right now, so hopefully it will get wider exposure. There are strong performances from many members of the cast, especially the younger actors. The film also has some very funny moments, which keep the film from getting too dark (or tied down by teen angst). You really identify with Tim's confusion as he seeks to unravel the mystery of his Father.

This is a strong debut for writer/director Lee Whitman, and was obviously a labor of love. Definitely worth seeing for yourself if you have the opportunity!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed